Our sweet Mom, Ruth Palanker graced this planet for 92 years. She passed peacefully last week and we laid her to rest, next to our Dad, Marvin Palanker, in Buffalo, NY.
Our mother's many gifts, qualities and talents include her voluminous expressions as a writer. She wrote throughout her lifetime and a few months ago, she asked me to help her gather, and  curate her work in order to create a book that we can share with you, complete with photos which compliment her many stories. I am in the process of completing this rewarding work and I brought along something she wrote that I would like to read for you today.She calls this piece, Happy Birthday.
Today is your birthday and polka dots of memory swirl through my mind like fan blown confetti. One is of the Friday night we sat at dinner and you asked, âHow come weâre having chicken but there is no chicken liver tonight?â âOh,â I beamed. âI give the liver to the baby now. Amy just loves it.â Well, that beats everything,â was your response. âWhen I was a boy, the chicken liver was saved for my father. Now I am the father and the liver goes to my baby.â From then on, you referred to us and our contemporaries as the âchicken liver generation.
âDo you remember the time Joann ran up to you, threw her arms around your knees and wanted to know, âDaddy, are you 93 or 39? I canât remember.â
Do you remember when I wanted to file for divorce but insisted on waiting until after the big dinner party we were giving on a Saturday night?
What about the time I crushed your cigars and sprinkled them in the top drawer all over your clean handkerchiefs? You laughed when you discovered them and I couldnât remember why I was angry.
Once you totally forgot my birthday. We ate at that restaurant on Main near Utica that isnât there anymore. You didnât acknowledge the day and I was in a sulky snit. You asked, as you always did, âIs anything the matter?â And, as I always did, I answered, âNo,â even though my bucket of petty gripes was pretty nearly filled. How did you ever put up with me? Moody, sulky, impatient - that pretty much describes me. In fact, if grudge-carrying had been an Olympic event, I surely would have won a medal.
When we vacationed in Sarasota, I would take long walks on the beach and return to find you waiting for me, puffing on your cigar, watching my approach with a loving smile. Back in Buffalo, I remember you watching me in our backyard garden as I planted and weeded and watered. You shared my joy when some things flourished and others, at least, failed to die. And you helped me shoo the rabbits away.
A special memory is of the day you were scheduled to fly from Sarasota to Fort Lauderdale. Amy, jetting in from Los Angeles, was to meet you there. You two would spend the day with your parents and then fly back to Sarasota that night. I had made the reservations myself and been assured that there was, âno problem,â for a passenger with a wheelchair. When we arrived to check in, however, Mohammad, who it turned out was the ticket agent, the baggage handler and the pilot for the single engine plane, informed us that if you could not maneuver the stairs by yourself, you could not fly with him. I raved, and would happily have strangled Mohammad. You, on the other hand, calmly looked Mohammad in the eye and said, âIf I need to go up the stairs alone, I will.â And you did. On your bottom. One painful step at a time.Â
At 10:30 that night, as I waited for you and Amy to return to Sarasota, my mind raced with murderous thoughts of Mohammad. The toy-like plane taxied to a halt near me. The door opened and Mohammad carried you down the stairs. As he set you into your wheelchair, you beamed at me and said, âHoney, have you met my new friend, Mo?â
That was your way. You always made a friend of an opponent. And you taught me so much. Never back anyone into a corner; always leave them an out. Donât waste time assigning blame for an accident; work on trying to fix the problem. Listen and never judge.Patience is still not my strong suit. But if I am tolerant and open-minded, it is because of you. If I have a sense of self-worth, it is because of you. If our four children are lovable, good citizens, it is because of you. All of the good in our lives is because of you. You would have been eighty-five today.Â
This is a stunning piece of writing but I do have a couple of notes.Â
1) Thatâs a big âifâ about all four of us being lovable, good citizens. It leaves so much open for breakout groups. AndÂ
2) Assuming we accept the premise that we are all, in fact, lovable and good, Our Mom is not giving herself enough of the credit for that outcome.
I have been typing up her catalogue of memoirs and stories and it is illuminating, for me, her unique perspective as a young mother of four kids. Ages, 5, 3, 2 and 0, married to a man who can not walk. As instrumental as was our Dad's emotional, financial and wise support, our Mom was lugging and pushing and pulling strollers, buggies, babies, diaper bags and a wheelchair all on her own. Toddlers donât stay where you put them. How did she do it all?
Yes, there were some cranky moments but our Mom was determined to have and raise four kids and she did it by determining to become and remain a lifelong learner. This is why she was so open to my Dadâs gentle wisdom.Â
Momâs heart and mind were always actively and urgently growing, learning and expanding to reach wide enough and far enough to understand us, accept us and continuously exemplify what it means to be good, decent, warm and loving in an ever evolving world.If there was a new concept to grasp, she listened. She asked questions. She offered insights and unique ways of looking at a situation or a development.Â
Our Mom always remained our Mom, while also, gracefully evolving into that friend you can talk to who is more interested in your day than even you are. As children, she loved us fiercely, terrified of a time when we would grow up and move away.Â
She pretended to joke about us kids one day, buying houses on Catherine Street and moving around the corner. She wasnât joking. That was the dream. For sure and for certain.Â
So, when we began moving to California, she moved to California and she bought a house around the corner. Veteran Avenue became our Catherine Street.
The big draw really though was her grandchild Jake. Our grandparents were Hannah and Joe Palanker. They were distant, a bit self absorbed and Iâm not fully certain that they knew our individual names. In fact, I was without a clear concept of what a grandparent could be until I watched how my Mom did it.
Jake, Grandma knew your interests, your activities, the names of your friends. She did not care whether or not those friends were Jewish. Jake,Your grandma loved you without measure. If you were interested in a topic... and you are interested in many topics... Grandma avidly absorbed as much as she possibly could about it. She adored watching you grow and not just teaching you but learning from you how to better understand our world.
She thoroughly embraced your wife Rhody and the two of you so fully enriched her. It was a treasure to witness.
If the wave of loss is as large as the love we knew from Ruthie, then we all may feel like we are drowning in this moment. But when we are able to come up for air, we will breathe in the scent of so many sweet memories that they will forever sustain us. And we will find a way to honor the joy and the gift of her light and kindness by continuing onward and sharing it.