Part 2! Fair warning, most of these are creators I don't watch as much (or at all, with people like Skizz, Bdubs, Etho, so if I don't get their arc quite right in the way that makes sense for them, I apologize. This is based on everyone's interactions and lore that I've seen throughout the LS.)
I want Big B who isn't purposefully trying to gaslight people. I want Big B whose lies are because he is genuinely broken. He's a compulsive liar, yes, but his brain is so scrambled he doesn't know what's real anymore. I want Big B whose trauma from Last Life, whose betrayal, broke him more than it broke Cleo. I want Big B who was so messed up that the Watchers couldn't fix him. Couldn't. Wouldn't.
I want Bdubs who doesn't… really… know what to do when he can't work himself to the bone. I want Bdubs who is the man that pushes as hard as he can to get the best results. But this game, this is a game where he can't do that, where he is completely powerless to push himself too far. I want Bdubs who starts to feel useless without putting his whole self into this game, I want Bdubs who pushes that aside because he's Bdubs, he's always smiling, he's always happy, I want Bdubs who forces himself to put those feelings in another place and tries to be useful in other ways. Bdubs who trusts people even when they kill him because who else does he trust? Where else does he go?
I want Etho who feels so incredibly out of his depth in this game. I want Etho who is a naturally built redstoner, someone who can do everything but chooses not to. I want Etho who's a loner when he has the chance, but in this game, he doesn't. I want Etho who struggles with fighting his friends, Etho who tries not to be hurt when alliances are broken and friends become enemies. I want Etho who does, actually, remember all the games via a glitch the Watchers don't realize (because he's The EthosLab, c'mon, who else would be a glitch in the code). I want Etho who doesn't talk about the other games because they hurt, who compartmentalizes so much that dozens of eldritch god-beings don't realize he's remembering more than he should.
I want Cleo who wishes they could embrace the zombie part of them. Wishes that it wasn't so easy to slip into that mindset of I am not alive and everyone knows it. But I want Cleo who can't. I want Cleo who struggles to feel alive when it's just not possible. I want Cleo who has such incredible social skills, who is top notch in all forms of combat and manipulation, but who's trust issues make it so that they can't trust anyone but the people they know. Who even with allies, is still fighting in most ways for only themself.
I want Impulse who gets way too attached. I want Impulse who has vague memories of his friends (Skizz, Tango, etc.) and struggles to fight them in any way. I want Impulse who is a people pleaser, but also knows exactly what's going on. He knows whose side he's on. I want Impulse who will fight and die for his friends in an instant, because they are his family. They are his.
I want Skizz who tries so hard to be nice. I want Skizz who wants to be like Impulse, Skizz who wants to love everyone and be peaceful. But I want Skizz who can't help but be violent. I want Skizz who struggles with his blood lust, Skizz who fights himself tooth and nail to stay green for as long as he can, Skizz who tries not to let himself go, because if he does, everything fails. I want Skizz who wants more than anything to be the good guy, but can't help the part of himself that simply isn't.
I want Mumbo who was told by a possessed Grian (although he didn't know it) about the games. I want Mumbo who was told this was just a game, who didn't understand the full depth of it until he was too far in. I want Mumbo who wanted to be friends again, who just wanted to take the hand and fall. I want Mumbo who's preservation instincts are wildly out of alignment because he trusts his friends, and who are they to lie to him? I want Mumbo who remembers all the times outside of the games, and that clouds his judgment.
I want Tango whose anger issues get a hold of him a little too often. Who was so incredibly angry as the Ranch burnt that he gave Jimmy burns on his hands that stayed raw for way too long. I want Tango who has a long fuse, but when the fuse is gone, it's gone. I want Tango who snaps when things don't go right, Tango who feels so much guilt when he explodes, Tango who tries so hard to win but flails every time, Tango who just wants it all to be over so he doesn't hurt someone else he loves. I want Tango who's body is manipulated by the games to make his anger more potent, Tango who blames himself every time he hurts someone like that. Tango who hates himself like this.
I want Jimmy who is so desperate to break the curse, he'll do anything. I want Jimmy who prays and makes offerings and tries all the teams and strategies, but nothing works. I want Jimmy who was cursed from the beginning because "it would be funny," who couldn't shake away the chains because they are so tight. I want Jimmy who, when Lizzie died in Secret Life, broke down sobbing because it wasn't him this time. It wasn't him this time.