so yeahhh

"b-but unbecoming...." umbecoming was an illusion created by merlin to manipulate jim

"b-but toby wouldn't self-isolate and self-sacrifice himself instead of accepting help" did it ever occur to you that jim's self-sabotaging behaviors are a weakness, not a strenght? did the fact that he keeps being punished by the narrative whenever he refuses to let others help him give you any sort of clue?

"b-but jim real trollhunter. others just sidekicks..." how does one hear "not Trollhunter. Trollhunters!" so many times and not realize that it was always a group effort? It was always ab collaboration, and togetherness. It was the main theme of the show! How did y'all miss it

"b-but how is it possible that jim refused the amulet? He'll end up realizing it will never be right unless he is the Trollhunter. No matter how much he wishes to give the role to someone else, he is stuck with it" tales of arcadia has always been SUBVERTING the chosen one trope. By showing that Jim can't do it alone, by showing that choosing him was chance. By showing that any good person with a big heart can fight. Besides, the whole being mad that a teenager found a way to refuse something that to him is a burden, and pass it on to someone who wants it enthusiastically, is not a good look.

"b-but will blinky be father figure to toby now?" Not necessarily, blinky would probably get attached to jim again, and aaarrrghhh to toby, it makes sense bc of their personalities. Also Blinky and Aaaarghhh have been parental figures to the gang for the entire show anyway.

"b-but strickler and nomura still evil... Janus order still evil" both strickler and nomura were obvious victims of abuse,clinging to the illusion of power bc they knew they would not be safe in the world w/o the janus order. I'm sure all it would take is knowing that they would be safe on the good side to turn. (not to mention they were never too attached to the gumm-gumm side either... They always chose the best option for their self-preservation.

"b-but if toby fat... How fight.... :(?" he literally fought by jim's side, also aja and krel's side,all the time. And jim wasn't that good at fighting at first either. Your fat phobia is talking.

just grab the seals from douxie before he uses them in his trap and have him use fake ones. put the real ones somewhere else! destroy them for all i care!!

I have a theory that Jim is "making things right" by taking Toby's place maybe? So when the events of the film roll around, it's not Toby that dies but Jim.