I was a professional bellydancer for over a decade.
The focus on gendered talk is one major reason I had to leave bellydance behind. Thereās way too much gendered talk in that dance despite that not being its real history and it made me feel very uncomfortable (not to mention the general policing/cattiness aspect, which also rubbed me the wrong way; it was like dealing with cheerleaders/mean girls in high school). Really unfortunate, since I did love the actual dancing.
I think we all need to be a lot more mindful of how we talk about and depict gender. I canāt be the only one in the bellydance community, or other communities, that feels shut out by the gendered talk alone. Even prior to realising I was trans in some capacity, I knew about my own genetic chimerism, and that really makes you feel like you donāt belong *anywhere*. How do I relate both to bellydance as a masculine person, and to fixing cars as a woman? Neither of these things are *actually* about gender, but in our society, weāve stratified this stuff to the point of insanity.
People often say things like, āwell my girl loved dolls/boy loved cars and I didnāt teach them anything like that, therefore all boys and girls just naturally do X and Y!ā Iāve heard this used as: an excuse for men to act like shitheads, a way for women to demean each other, all in the name of gender. Like each gender has this *inherent behaviour* that canāt be helped, because itās instinct. I fight *hard* when someone says, 'oh of course heās useless at housework, heās a manā or when a woman says, 'Iām disgusted by women who donāt paint their toenailsā. This just perpetuates the general horror of gender to the nth degree. And the thing is, even if a parent never spoke a single word to their kid about any of this, indoctrination starts young, all the way down to the blue and pink bassinets.Ā
Parents donāt have to do it. The world will do it for them.
For example, I had bright ginger long hair for a while. I am a model and actress as well as a writer, director, and historian. So most of these style choices were related to filming or modelling (requested/necessary vs. choice of my own). I find that I like having long ginger hair. I also like having short, spiky brown hair. But the number of people who keep demanding why I donāt have long ginger hair anymore isā¦weird. It gets to a point where you wonder if the way you look is your own choice, or pressure to conform. I even had one model photographer recently say exactly the above-mentioned phrase about painted toenails; when I mentioned that I didnāt do that and itās not very nice to shame other women,Ā citing the 'prettiness is not a rent you pay to occupy a space marked femaleā quote, she spent ages trolling through my Facebook page in order to point out thatĀ āsince Iāve dyed my hair I obviously care about beauty!ā Ā This also prompted a friend of hers, in the usual Facebook echo chamber, to not only agree with her but to say that she was more concerned about having unpainted toenails in front of other people while she was having her baby at the hospital than she was about people looking at her crotch. This type of performative femininity is insidious, and tends to turn people on each other.
One male friend of mine wrote to me privately and said that he knew I was 'much happier in my femininityā than I was with short hair/looking masculine because one of my modeling photos (the blonde, fake-cheerful one, commissioned by The Sun) made him think that it was clearly natural that I 'glowed with femininityā. I WAS PAID GOOD MONEY TO LOOK LIKE THAT. This is exactly the kind of bullshit that Christians used to tell me regarding the roles of men and women. The thing is, that photograph was ACTED; itās probably the phoniest one of me I have. The short-hair photos arenāt 'angerā, thatās what I look like with a straight face if I bow my head a little and look up from under my eyebrows. ie my NATURAL FACE. Iāve always had a terrifying face, or I wouldnāt have the streetfighting reputation I have. Itās amazing what you can do just because you naturally look scary. Ask Christopher Walken. Other friends have told me that theyāve never seen me happier than when I have short hair. But sexism is a powerful thing.
And itās these things, they arenāt even necessarily mean or meant maliciously, that push you into one box or the other. The shame is hardcore, sometimes. My partnerās mum recently asked why I didnāt have my 'long beautiful auburn hairā anymore. Sheās seen me several times with the short brown hair. She also insists that the new Doctor 'shouldnāt be a womanā even though she thinks the actress is a good Doctor. I know that sounds small, but itās death by a thousand cuts, and thatās not even my own parents saying it, but somebody elseās. This is what I mean by 'you donāt have to tell someone you disapprove of them directly if by what you say itās evident that you disapprove of them in generalā.
I think a lot of people donāt have any idea how harmful the language they use can be, and that goes for pretty much all groups Iāve been a part of, including LGBT groups that have a 'trans-enoughā purity test (if you havenāt decided yet, if you wonāt admit youāre 'transā out loud, if you no longer want to be called 'transā after you transition, etc). So thereās a lot going on when it comes to all these things, and I canāt imagine how this makes intersex people feel, let alone everybody else.