I've been reading The Last Binding trilogy, currently about halfway through the third book. And I'm enjoying it overall for the magic plot and like, heist-adjacent mischief, but it's becoming clearer that I'm not so much a fan of the romance plots as I am of Edwin Courcey, specifically.
I did some tumblr skimming to get a sense of the ~fandom discourse~ after finishing A Marvellous Light, just because, and saw someone recommended it for drarry shippers, and like, a) really, in 2025? do we need this? b) as far as I can tell the only resemblance is that Edwin is blonde and kind of mean and Robin is dark-haired and kind of dumb, but then my understanding of draco-related shipping was always that people just made up a new character to take the place of the cardboard bully in the texts, so whatever.
BUT, it kept niggling at me, because I am in fact a huge mark for horrible prickly geniuses guarding their softest vulnerable hearts, so surely I could come up with a better comparison. And then I read the following two scenes, and I realized the obvious parallel is McShep from Stargate Atlantis.
"Blast, I hate riddles.â
âNo, you donât,â murmured Sir Robert.
Edwin reached out without breaking his hungry perusal of the letter and flicked the back of Sir Robertâs hand, winning himself a smile that he didnât notice.
The next few sentences began sensibly enough but soon spiralled off into a level of judgemental detail about cradling minutiae that was extreme even for Edwin. Robin began to open his mouth, then closed it again.
Manning was clutching his books to his chest as if theyâd save him. Finally he managed to interruptââStop! Iâlook, I didnât write it. It was my sister. Abigail. But you canât tell anyone. Our parents donât approve of her fiddling around with spells.â
âWell,â said Edwin sniffily, âyou can tell her itâs sloppily argued and lacking breadth.â [...] This was the most amusing thing to happen in weeks: a jealous Edwin Courcey trying to wield secondhand academic cattiness against someone whoâd fucked his partner.
Rodney McKay would absolutely get into a jealous academic pissing contest calling someone's thesis sloppily argued and lacking breadth.
Meanwhile Robin's out here being Just Some Guy/himbo who doesn't even go here and then turns out to have a very Special and Important ability that no one really understands. At first Edwin is like, ugh, I gotta work with this guy? and then is quickly obsessed with studying him like a bug for both his magical mysteries and his beautiful, muscular forearms. And Robin is like, this guy's an asshole, but also a genius, and amazing. And anytime he sees anyone else be mean to Edwin his reaction is, how dare you insult this man? He is MY asshole and you are hurting his feelings, I will punch you.
Also repeatedly, one of them almost dies and the other one almost loses their mind over it.
So yeah, extremely McShep.