Need vs Want
Chapter Two
Plot Summary : Billy Russo is tired of playing the dating game, so he decides to try and find his perfect match online with a very specific ad. When you respond, it quickly becomes clear that you're everything he wants, but is he what you need?
Pairing : Billy Russo x Reader
Story Rating : R
Warnings : [This is a fic for 18+ only, minors DNI] Just smut. There is an unspecified age gap between Billy and reader. Please check the warnings on each chapter if you choose to follow this story.
Word Count : 5.1k
A/N : Thanks for your patience over the last week, my dog is still ill but he seems to be doing a little better now that he's settled in a bit.
CHAPTER ONE
Chapter Two
He spent the night thinking about you, already desperate to see you again. After spending hours finding out what little he could about you online, he'd found himself in a cold shower, stroking his cock to thoughts of you.
It was insane.
He felt insane.
No one had ever had such a profound effect on him in such a short time and Billy wasn't sure what to do with himself. There was something so fragile about you, but the way that you'd kissed him, the way that you'd moaned and writhed against him, screamed of the same eager desperation that he often felt. You were just like him — you just didn't seem to know it yet.
The next morning, he texted you, asking how you would be spending your day. He already knew the answer, but he wanted to get you used to talking to him and answering his questions, even over the phone. You would be at your studio, no doubt losing yourself in your work.
He'd noticed the far away look in your eyes as he'd walked you from the coffee shop, the way you seemed to want to exist in a world of your own. Normally such a thing would have him rolling his eyes, but you didn't seem to belong in the harsh reality of everyday life.
After another cold shower and some intimate time with his hand, Billy decided that he needed to see you. And he couldn't wait until dinner.
So, he came up with a plan.
You stumbled and almost fell over when you rounded the corner to find him waiting outside your studio — you would have landed flat on your face if he hadn't stepped forward and caught you.
He made sure you were steady on your feet but he didn't step away, nor did he take his hand off your arm.
"What are —" you started and stopped, confused. "Were we... I didn't think we were meeting until later..."
Billy smiled, his heart practically skipping in his chest. Something about seeing you so flustered had him wanting — no, not wanting, needing — to take of you, needing to step up and take control.
"I know, but something from yesterday was bothering me," he glanced over his shoulder towards the door to your studio and the Anvil employee who stood there. When he looked back at you, he noticed your confusion had deepened. "Your studio... it's not very secure. In a neighbourhood like this, you need more than a motion sensor alarm. And, since security is my business, I thought I'd sort it out for you. If that's alright with you?"
He watched as you thought over the offer, weighing it up, and eyeing him as if you thought it might be a test.
"I don't know if I can afford it..." you said softly, cautiously.
"It won't cost you a thing," he said, giving your arm a reassuring squeeze. "I'd just feel better knowing that you're safe when you're here working."
"Oh..." again you paused, taking a few seconds to think things over. "Okay."
He smiled widely, glad that you were already letting him take care of you without question. His hand slipped down to find yours and he led you to your studio door. You unlocked it and he followed you inside.
"Can you set up cameras and make sure the locks are secure?" He said to his man.
You stood quietly beside him for the conversation that followed. Billy's security expert started to explain what he was going to do and what would be the best way to get the job done, and Billy trusted him implicitly. Anvil only hired the best of the best, after all.
It wasn't until his attention returned to you that Billy noticed you'd retreated into your thoughts, no doubt overthinking what was happening and what you might owe him because of it. He didn't want that. He didn't want you to think you’d ever owe him anything. That wasn't what this was about.
"Don't worry about it," he said, drawing your attention back to him. "I did offer to compensate you — just think of this as part of that."
You nodded and glanced towards the back room where you'd showed him one of the paintings you'd been touching up. The back room where he'd been sorely tempted to fuck you against the wall last night.
The thought alone caused his cock to twitch.
(Would you let him, he wondered. Would you let him fuck you, knowing there was someone in the next room?)
It was too tempting. You were too tempting.
"Have you had breakfast?" He asked.
Your eyes widened a fraction at the question, giving him his answer long before you shook your head. You looked sheepish, embarrassed even, that you hadn't eaten. Billy got the impression that it was something that happened often.
Well, not anymore.
He gave your hand a gentle tug back towards the door. "C'mon, I'll take you for something to eat."
You followed him without question. Billy made a point of explaining to you that his guy was highly trained and that he'd have everything sorted for you before you got back from breakfast, so you didn't need to worry about anything. You nodded, still not questioning, just accepting everything Billy was doing for you.
It was exactly what he wanted.
"Do you normally skip breakfast?" He asked as you walked together, hand in hand.
"Sometimes, if I'm in a rush..."
No, that wouldn't do. That wouldn't do at all.
"From now on, I want you to have breakfast every morning," he said. Your gaze dropped to the pavement and you started to chew at the inside of your cheek, thoughtfully silent. When you didn't say anything, he continued; "if you forget breakfast for any reason, I want you to call me, okay?"
The question was left to hang between you and, when you didn't look up or answer him, Billy stepped in front of you. His free hand cupped your cheek and urged you to look at him. The same look of embarrassment was all over your face, and he hated seeing it.
"What's wrong?" He asked.
"I just... I don't want to promise you something and then disappoint you," you said, voice small and quiet. "Sometimes I forget things or I lose track of time, and people get upset about it... and I don't want you to think I'm doing it deliberately."
He considered your words for a few seconds, wanting to ask a dozen questions but knowing things needed to happen at your pace.
"Okay, how about this; from now on, I'll take you for breakfast every morning?"
There was a flicker of shock on your face, then your lips parted and you looked ready to tell him that he didn't need to do that. But you stopped yourself, clearly remembering your arrangement.
"Okay," you finally said.
He didn't give you time to keep thinking about it — he was starting to realise just how much you tended to overthink and worry needlessly — he leaned in and pressed his lips to yours, tenderly kissing you and letting your body melt against his. You relaxed almost instantly, wrapping your am around his waist, content to remain in his embrace until the blaring of a car horn pulled you back to the moment.
The kiss broke but he held you against him, wanting you to know that he wanted you near. It was clear you needed reassurance, that you needed to know that he didn't see you as a burden.
His thumb tenderly ran across your lips and you smiled for him. It was all the sign Billy needed that he was doing the right thing.
He lingered for a few more moments, then he turned and resumed walking. A couple of minutes later you were sitting in the coffee shop where you'd first met, hot coffees and bagels in front of you.
This time you shrugged off your coat and he finally got a good look at you. You looked utterly adorable in your denim overalls, already splattered with paint — nothing like the women he normally ended up with. Maybe that was why he was drawn to you. You were something new, different, and you didn't want the same things that they had wanted from him
It took you a few minutes of silence to work up the nerve to ask the question that had been playing on your mind.
"Why does it bother you so much that I skipped breakfast?" You asked with genuine curiosity.
He took a breath and swallowed his mouthful of bagel.
"I don't like the thought of anyone going hungry," he answered, shrugging. He saved you the trouble of asking why. "I grew up in foster care and, some days, there wasn't really enough food to go around..."
He watched as your gaze softened, but it wasn't pity on your face as he expected but a sad sort of sympathy. It was almost as if you understood.
"Okay," you said softly. "I'll try not to skip breakfast anymore."
Billy smiled and sat back, nursing his coffee. "Since we're talking about the past, can I ask you a question?"
You hesitated but then nodded. "Sure."
"When you said people get upset with you —"
"I didn't mean upset-upset," you interrupted, immediately flustered. "I don't upset people that much, they just get a little... annoyed with me sometimes."
"It's okay," he said, reaching across the table and taking your hand in his. "I just wanted to know if it happens a lot; people getting... annoyed with you?"
Again, you were quiet for a long, drawn out moment. "Not so much anymore. I'm always so busy with work, I don't really have time to see people. And... they were mostly my ex's friends anyway..."
He gave your hand a squeeze.
"And they got upset with you for forgetting things and losing track of time?" He asked, and you nodded. "Well, that isn't going to happen anymore. I don't want you to worry about things like that with me. But, I do have one rule I need you to follow. When I call you, I need you to always answer. And if I ask you a question, I need you to be honest."
"That's two things," you said, smiling at him.
"You're right, it is," Billy laughed. "I need you to follow those two rules then, okay?"
You agreed and seemed almost relieved at the prospect of it. He could already tell that you were the sort of person who liked to live with their head in the clouds, and he hated that anyone had tried to pull you back down to earth. There was just something fragile about you, and Billy wanted nothing more than to protect it.
"While we're here, why don't you tell me a little bit more about yourself?" He asked, gently trying to coax you out of yourself. "You came to New York for college, right? What made you stay?"
"I, uh..." you trailed off a beat but he didn't pressure you to continue. "I didn't have anywhere else to go?"
"No home? No family?"
"No, they... they died..."
"I'm sorry. We don't have to talk about it if you don't want to."
You shot him a confused look. "It's not that. I just know most people don't like hearing about things like that..."
That spark of irritation filled him again — who had been filling your head with this bullshit?
"When it comes to things like that, it doesn't matter what other people like," he said, barely managing to keep his tone neutral. "If you want to talk about it, then I'll listen."
You didn't say anything. Instead you fixed him with a questioning look, like you were trying to figure something out.
"What?" He asked.
"I just didn't expect you to be like this..."
"What were you expecting?"
"I thought you'd only be interested in sex," you admitted.
"Is that why you agreed to this?"
It was hard to keep himself from smirking. Despite your shy nature and reluctance to talk about certain parts of yourself, you clearly weren't embarrassed at the thought of sex. And that was good.
"I don't know," you answered with a shrug. "I liked the sound of the rest of it too, and I don't want you to think that I just want... that, but..."
You fell silent, but Billy knew exactly what you were trying to say. "It's okay. I enjoy sex and I probably wouldn't be entirely comfortable with someone who didn't. And I meant what I said last night, it's okay if you want that. I'll never judge you for wanting."
"So, tonight, after dinner, are we..." you trailed off again, glancing around the coffee shop, seeming worried someone might overhear.
"If you want to," he said. You shot him a confused look. "When it comes to sex, that's the only choice I'll never make for you. When we fuck, I want it to be because you want it as much as I do." He gave your hand another reassuring squeeze before letting you go. "Finish your breakfast, sweetheart."
And you did. You must have been hungry because you barely looked up as you ate.
He returned you to your studio once the work was completed, and let you for the day. At least, he left you in a physical sense.
The second he got to his office across town, he accessed the camera feed from your studio and watched as you worked. You had a spring in your step, seeming more settled. Happy, even. Selfishly, Billy hoped it was because of him.
He didn't speak to you again until later that day when you texted to ask him what to wear for dinner — either because you couldn't decide or because you were already embracing having him to make your choices for you. What followed was an hour of messages sent back and forth, with you taking photos of yourself in various outfits, until he saw you in a blue silk dress.
It sat half way up your thighs, accentuating the curve of your hips, and the corset style bodice pushed up your breasts in a way that had Billy's cock straining in his pants.
That one, he told you.
The picture didn't do it justice.
He collected you from your apartment, pausing before knocking on the door, overhearing you talking to someone. Your cat, he realised. When you opened the door, your eyes raked over his body, while he did the same to you. It was an effort to keep himself from walking you back into your apartment and fucking you against the first hard surface he came across.
You let him take your hand in his and lead you outside to where his driver was waiting.
Your face lit up when you saw the cosy little Italian restaurant he'd picked, and Billy smiled at the way you closed your eyes and breathed in the smell of freshly cooked food.
At the table, you stared at the menu and, again, he saw that spark of uncertainty in you.
He gave you a few minutes but, when you didn't look up to tell him what you wanted, Billy asked; "would you like me to choose for you?"
You flashed an embarrassed look, running your teeth over your lower lip before nodding.
"Do you like carbonara?" He asked, and you nodded. "Then you can have carbonara."
Your waiter appeared and Billy rattled off your orders, taking the liberty to add a starter and a bottle of wine of the both of you — you were busy looking around the restaurant and taking in the frescoes on the walls to even notice. When you were alone again, Billy's full attention returned to you.
"Well," he said, "what do you think of my world?"
"It's nice. I like it," you said.
"Good. I want you to be comfortable," he continued. "What's that smile for?"
Your gaze dropped to the table, that shyness he was coming to adore taking hold again. "It's just... nice. You're nice..."
"I'm glad you think so."
You stared at him for a long moment. "Can I ask you something?"
"You can ask me anything you'd like. I want us to be able to talk to each other."
"Am I the first person you've done this with? The ad, I mean..."
He regarded you for a beat, wondering where the question came from and how best to soothe whatever concerns you might have.
"Yes, you are," Billy confirmed. "I've had... issues with dating in the past. A lot of women have wanted to get close to me but they've also wanted me to change. I'm not interested in changing, so I posted the ad and hoped I'd find someone like you..."
You gave a nod, accepting his answer with no further questions.
Over the course of the meal you got to know each other, sharing little snippets of your past with him and, in return, Billy told you about himself.
You'd studied art history at NYU, then gone on to study art conversation at The Institute of Fine Arts. It took every ounce of self-restraint he could muster to not say anything when you explained that you'd followed your ex to New York, even though you'd had your heart set on Yale. Billy didn't push, but he noticed an awkward tension fill your body every time you mentioned your last boyfriend. It was something he'd unravel, but not tonight.
But you did reveal something that made him sit a little straighter — it had been over two years since you'd last had sex.
In turn, he told you about his time as a Marine, and how he'd come to start his company with his best friend Frank when they'd finally come home. You listened with rapt attention, asking little questions about the places he'd seen and telling him how much you wanted to be able to travel.
Conversation flowed easily — perhaps helped by the wine — and he quickly started to learn when to take control, steering you away when the weight of things threatened to drag you down and ruin the mood. And you let him. No, more than that, you seemed to genuinely appreciate it.
Billy didn't stop to think before ordering dessert and a coffee for you at the end of the meal, and you didn't even blink. The more he let you just exist in the moment, the happier you seemed to be.
And, by the time you were finished with your food and the bill was paid, you were comfortable enough to take his hand in yours before he even had to offer.
In the back of his car, he pulled you against his side, warming you as you shivered and daring to press a kiss to your forehead.
"So, do you want to go home or come back to my place?" He asked.
You eyed the privacy partition that separated the pair of you from the driver. "I want to go wherever you're going."
After another tender kiss pressed to your temple, Billy tapped the intercom and told the driver to take you back to his apartment. The car started to move, and you leaned into his side, resting your head on his shoulder. When your hands balled into loose fists on your lap, Billy reached for one and gently eased your fingers open.
"What's wrong?" He asked. You stayed silent. "Talk to me, sweetheart. Are you nervous?"
"No, it's just... I don't want to disappoint you," you said. "I had a really nice time tonight, and I don't want to ruin it."
"How do you think you're going to ruin it?"
"I don't know if I'll be any good at the... y'know submission..."
He ran his thumb over your knuckles, once again finding himself overwhelmed by the need to make sure you were comfortable.
"We're not doing that tonight — and it's something I'll walk you through. I don't expect you to know anything," he said as softly as he could.
"So, we're not..." you felt silent for a moment. "I thought we were going to have sex..."
"We are. If that's what you want, but tonight it'll just be that; just us getting to know each other better," Billy explained. Your thighs pressed together and it was all the sign he needed that you wanted him. He angled his head so he could whisper in your ear. "If you let me, I'll spend all night inside you."
"All night?" The word left you in a shaky exhale.
"All night," Billy repeated. "You're all I've been able to think about; I want to know how you taste and how loud you'll moan for me when I make you come. I want to know how wet your cunt gets and how good it'll feel wrapped around my cock."
You squirmed beside him, thighs now clamped together. It was exactly what he wanted; you needy and desperate, too lost in thoughts of him to think or worry about anything else.
"I bet you're wet right now, aren't you?" He asked.
Your throat bobbed as you swallowed.
"Aren't you?" He repeated in a firmer tone — a little nudge to remind you of the agreement you'd made to always honestly answer his questions.
"Yes," you said softly. "I've been wet all day."
He took a slow breath, resisting the urge to reach between your thighs and check for himself. As much as he wanted to touch you, Billy was desperate to taste you, and for the first orgasm he gave you to be on his tongue.
"You're perfect," he muttered, letting his lips brush against your ear. "I'm glad you answered my ad, sweetheart."
"I'm glad too," you said, your fingers gripping his tight.
Billy couldn't help himself, couldn't silence the part of him that always wanted more, so he pressed a kiss behind your ear and started trailing his lips down your neck. A soft sound escaped you and your hold on his hand tightened.
"You look so good in this dress, but I can't wait to see you out of it," he murmured between kisses. "I'm going to enjoy learning every single inch of your body and —"
The car came to a stop and Billy heard the driver's door open and close. He pulled away from you, not wanting to cause you any embarrassment — though your hooded and glassy eyes all but gave you away.
Billy helped you out of the car and bid his driver goodnight. From there, he was on autopilot, leading you through the foyer and into the elevator, keeping a firm grip on your hand. You followed eagerly, quiet but stuck to his side.
When the lift doors opened to reveal his penthouse, he only gave you a few seconds to get your bearings before he was on you. His lips met yours in a starved kiss, the last strands of his sanity snapping and fraying. Your lips parted for his tongue and your hands gripped his waist as he led you towards his bedroom.
"You've no idea how much I want you," he groaned into the kiss. "The ways I want you... the things I'm going to do to you..."
You showed neither reluctance nor restraint, even as he reached behind you and started to tug the zipper of your dress down. You just pressed closer, losing yourself in the kiss and in him.
"Please," you breathed against his lips.
Your dress fell and, finally, Billy pulled back — not because he wanted things to stop but because he wanted to see you.
"Fuck," he muttered, taking in the sight of your red lace lingerie set. "Perfect."
He claimed your lips again, smiling and helping you start to relieve him of his clothes. First his jacket dropped, then his shirt, and finally his pants.
You were given a moment to look him over, to see him as he'd seen you, and nothing prepared him for what followed. Billy's heart stuttered when you saw the scars on his chest and your expression softened. You dared to reach for him, ghosting your fingers over the faded line on his shoulder. He blinked as you pressed a kiss to the scar.
Billy wasn't sure what came over him, but he took your face in his hands and stared into your eyes. Nothing made sense. You didn't make sense. How could you be so soft and perfect? How did you make him feel lost and found all at once?
He hardly knew you but, already, Billy couldn't imagine going back to not having you in his life.
"Tell me you want this," he said. "I need to hear you say it."
"I want this," you answered without hesitation. "I want you."
Another blur of motion ensued. You were led back, onto the bed, your bra removed, and legs spread wide enough for Billy to kneel between them. You were completely still as he drank in the sight of you, and didn't even flinch as he tore your panties from your body.
"These are mine now," he said.
You didn't argue. You just watched as he lowered himself to trail kisses along the inside of your thighs, slowly creeping upwards. Billy listened as your breath hitched, and smirked against your skin when he felt you tremble.
He paused when he reached the apex of your thighs, letting you feel his hot breath against arousal slick skin.
Then, he spread you wide with his fingers and swiped his tongue from your dripping entrance to your throbbing clit. One stroke was enough to have your back bowing off the bed, two had you moaning, and three had you whining his name. You made the sweetest noises he'd ever heard, something caught between shock and pleasure, like your body hadn't expected it to feel so good.
You'd already been wet for him but, after a couple more greedy swipes of his tongue, you were soaked.
Fingers tangled in his hair as you tried to anchor yourself.
The tip of his tongue pressed against your entrance, slipping inside you and causing your hips to jerk. You gasped and moaned, every muscle in your body tensed. Billy knew that you were already on the brink of an orgasm, and that you were denying yourself. That was the last thing he wanted.
He moved upwards, his lips closing around your clit and sucking.
You cried out as your orgasm crashed over you, hips bucking and grinding against his face. He'd never heard a more desperate sound in all his life, and he knew that he'd never get sick of it.
But, even as you came, he didn't stop.
Billy slid a finger into your trembling cunt and began to draw it in and out of you while his tongue lavished your clit with attention.
He didn't emerge from your legs until you were shaking and crying out his name, and his desire to taste you had finally been sated. You could barely lift your head to watch as he finally slipped out of his boxers.
Shockwaves were still coursing through your body when he crawled over you, taking a moment to run lips and tongue over your stomach and breasts. He couldn't remember ever wanting someone as much as he wanted you in that moment, his cock throbbed, nudging against you, already leaking.
Two years. It had been two years since you'd last been fucked.
"Are you on birth control?" He hated asking, but he needed to. It was for your safety and comfort.
You shook your head, worried that he was going to change his mind. Billy silenced your concerns by reaching into his bedside table and pulling out a full pack of condoms. He sheathed himself with a practiced ease and pressed a fleeting kiss to your lips.
"Are you ready?" He asked, letting you feel the crown of his cock at your entrance.
All you could manage was a nod.
His hips rocked forwards and —
Billy bit back a gasp as he notched inside you, your walls snug and warm around him. Just the tip was enough to have your hips lifting off the bed and a moan spilling from you.
He moved slowly, working his way inside of you with measured thrusts, not wanting to cause you any discomfort. When he was about half way inside you, Billy paused and tenderly kissed you.
"You okay?" He asked. You nodded. "I need you to use your words."
"Y-yeah," you said, breathlessly. "It just... you're... big... but I like it..."
There was no stopping the grin that pulled on his lips, even if it was tinged with some other emotion, a fondness that he didn't want to think about when he was inside you. But, he didn't say anything. Instead, he reached down to pull up one of your legs, hitching it against his thigh as he sank deeper. You moaned and gasped, and it wasn't long until you'd taken every inch of him.
Then he started to move, slowly drawing his hips back and pushing forward again, letting you adjust until you finally broke.
"Harder..." you begged.
And Billy obliged. He fucked you, easily pulling an orgasm from you, then another. You writhed and moaned beneath him, fingernails biting into the skin of his back. His name punctuated every single breath you took until you were practically screaming it.
Then your third orgasm hit, and your walls clenched so tight around him that it pulled Billy over the edge too.
He lingered inside of you until he was spent and your orgasm had subsided, then he dealt with the condom, and dropped onto the bed beside you.
The calm silence lasted all of five minutes before you spoke.
"Do you want me to leave now?" You asked.
"What? No. No, I don't want you to leave." Fuck, he needed to kill whoever had made you this way.
"You want me to stay the night?"
"Of course I do," he said, draping his arm across your body. "I'll always want you to stay after sex. And, anyway, I said I was going to spend all night inside of you, didn't I?"
Something in the smile you gave him threatened to break Billy because, for the life of him, he couldn't understand anyone not wanting to keep you around. When you shifted closer and relaxed on the pillow beside him, Billy made a point of pulling you against him and holding you tight.
You fell asleep with your head on his chest and, for the first hour after you drifted off, Billy laid awake, just watching you.
A/N : So, yeah, my poor little rescue pup is still unwell, but we're getting there with him. I'm hoping that by next week he'll be better, but he's been a brave boy and he seems to be settling in quite well. That said, my hours at work go up next month because of Christmas, but I'm hoping I can get back to weekly posting. If not, I'll post another update. Anyway, hope you enjoy this chapter! (Also I don't know why both chapters have been Billy PoV but I've been having fun with it)
As always I love and appreciate every like/comment/reblog and keyboard smash of love. Thanks so much for reading! Hope you all have a great weekend!
If you’d like to be tagged, please let me know! Otherwise new chapters will hopefully be posted around 7:30pm GMT on Fridays.
Tag list : @oliviaewl @lincerad @xxxsweetcarolinexxx @benbarnesprettygurl @dreadfulxives18
@danzer8705 @snowkestrel @fireeyes-on-teller-dixon-grimes @bartonsparrow25 @shwnirwin
@vis-arc xoxabs88xox

















