Untitled

Not the most normal title for a post, I know, but it’s something that’s been eating at my brain for a while. My mind has this habit of taking statements that are meant to be taken at face value, or simply left alone, and running with them anyway.

But to get to the point: I mean that statement quite literally. I don’t think Karna belongs in the way his contemporaries do. From the very moment of his conception, everything about his birth was abnormal.

Where the other Pandavas are concerned, Kunti (and Madri, by extension) invoked a specific god, slept with him (or them, I do NOT want to think about the Ashvins right now), and carried the child to term. Their births followed the natural order of things, even with divine intervention in the way.

The same can be said for Krishna, even if his case differs slightly; Vishnu took the reins to fulfill a prophecy concerning his own incarnation in response to mass invocation. The important detail is that Vishnu was invoked, and his avatar was conceived and carried to term by the mother chosen to bear him.

Karna’s case is entirely different. Not only was he not the result of a physical union between Surya and Kunti, but depending on which version you read, he wasn’t even born in the natural sense—he emerged from Kunti’s ear once his incubation was complete. This was done in response to Kunti's own wishes, namely to preserve her "purity" and leave her unmarked by the union so that she would remain a marriage candidate. Plainly speaking, she asked for Karna to be as untraceable as possible.

Surya, in a sense, bypassed the alchemy of conception and gestation. Karna is an imperfect incarnation of Surya’s divinity because Surya implanted a fraction of his authority into Kunti in response to her wishes, leaving it to be shaped into whatever her human body was naturally programmed to create, without the proper "genes" to reflect it. So he wasn’t born through biological inheritance, he just took the shape of what Surya’s authority should look like in that context.

I know this is a bit abstract, but I’m not entirely sure how else to phrase it. Every other demigod is the reconciliation of two currents: divinity and mortality. Surya, as far as deities go, is especially jarring because he’s not just the god of the sun, he is the sun itself, the celestial body as we understand it, rendered in human form so that we can comprehend him.

So the argument here is that divinity needs to be translated through a specific framework before the deity can "safely" exist in the mortal realm, a process supported by the existence of avatars rather than the related god manifesting as is. Karna never went through that due process. He’s basically sunlight condensed into a mortal vessel.

And it goes without saying that trying to contain even a fraction of his authority in a half-baked vessel would have disastrous consequences. Which is exactly what happened.

Karna isn’t just socially out of place, he’s ontologically out of place. On some subconscious level, he understands that he doesn’t really belong, but he can’t comprehend why because he spends most of his life in the dark about his true identity. So he spends his entire life trying to scratch an itch that can never go away because of his incomplete nature. On a surface level this is interpreted as a discrepancy in societal stratification, what he was intended to be (a Kshatriya) and what he grew up as (a Suta) because of Kunti's abandonment, but the well obviously runs much deeper.

And in turn, that breeds the deep inferiority complex and obsessive drive for legitimacy that defines him. His need for structure and justice stems from an internal void. He was never "anchored", so he clings to external hierarchies and codes (honor, loyalty, dharma) as ways to stabilize himself. He carries the form of humanity but lacks the fundamental tether that makes one of humanity. He's an imitation of something he can never belong with. Even in FGO, he continues to push himself to embody a certain ideal, because even now, especially now, he's only a fragment of his potential. And that's all he can ever be.

(Not the best examples, but I can't remember where else he mentions his desire to keep growing as a hero at the moment. Feel free to add onto this post if you know what I'm referencing!)

But to shorten an incredibly abstract and headache-inducing post: Karna was never meant to exist within human boundaries because he wasn’t born as a human being should be. He’s left to perpetually struggle to prove something that shouldn’t need proof, because his authority already exists all around him. Because the sun impacts everything.