Monday Essay: I don't like sand is peak flirting.
Rating flirting and relationships in star wars
Okay guys, I promise I'll do one on clone rights and Ahsoka's trial and all that later.
A brief analysis of flirting in star wars. (Inspired by @sgalclevergirl's repost of @myfairkatiecat's post about I like sand)
Alright, before I dive into "I like sand", let me just bring up some other couples in star wars. Cause ooof there's some flirting that's good, and some flirting that makes me want to turn off the TV. I think I'm gonna rate some stuff.
Worst flirting: Han and Leia
Okay guys, don't kill me for this, but this might be the worst flirting in star wars. I get what they were going for - a suave rogue who can't admit his feelings. This idea that they're both playing games. It worked at the time; but as somebody who's seen the movie for the first time more recently... I cannot. Stand. Han's flirting. Specifically in episode V.
He constantly disregards everything she says! She sais "get away from me", he gets closer. She sais "Get off me", he grabs her more. He is constantly going "admit it princess you want me", and she keeps trying to push him away. It gives me the absolute icks. This feels like a relic of the rediculous movie trope that women like a guy who keeps pushing past no, and that's just toxic from all fronts. Sorry guys, I prefer men to respect my rejections. And women who communicate openly.
That being said, I want to say I do like their dynamic when they get together. The playful banter, the "I love you" "I know". When they connect, it's good and it's fun. I just wish they could've gotten there in a less HR-call worthy way.
Getting there...?: Anakin and Padmé
Ooooh boy this one is complicated.
In short: Anakin has massive issues, but I can respect his efforts to always be better.
First off we have the flirting in Attack of the Clones. I'm not the biggest fan of some of the directing choices here. It often feels like Anakin is a bit of a creep, and Padmé is uncomfortable with him. What I think the dialogue was meant to convey was that Padmé was uncomfortable because she feels the same and she knows she can't be with him. But it just doesn't feel like the director got the memo.
As a result, there are some bits in aotc that feel a bit... harassment-y. At the same time, Anakin does somewhat respect Padmé's boundaries. When she tells him to back off here, he tends to back off. And when the moments are good, they're good:
The scenes in the grass talking together show Anakin being genuinely interested in Padmé's interests and work. He tells her his own views, and he doesn't hide his opinions or pretend to be somebody else to impress her. (And okay yes, maybe "A dictatorship would be cool" isn't the best opinion, but that's a different conversation). They just talk like two human beings who actually like each other for who they are.
The same thing can be said for, we've gotten there everyone: I don't like sand. Yes, Anakin's body language and tone are awkward. Maybe he's uncomfortable because he's thinking of home, maybe he's a turned-on teen who's not allowed to be interested in women and has never been taught how to be normal around one. But despite the awkwardness, he's talking genuinely to her; they both are. They're just talking about their lives and their feelings and being genuine. Just enjoying hearing each others thoughts, opinions, and stories. Guys, THAT is peak flirting.
Don't tell me some fancy pickup line, don't tell me how badly I must want you. Tell me who you are, what you think, what you like, and listen when I tell you about myself as well.
And when Anakin moves in for the kiss, he doesn't force it, he waits for her to reciprocate. Guys, this is peak flirting.
She sais no, explains why, and he accepts it. Only when they both express they want to try after al, do they get together.
We don't see a ton of Anakin and Padme in the clone wars, but guys, it is a battle let me tell you. We see Anakin becoming more confident, and we see that when he's not a nervous teen with his first crush, he's actually charismatic. But we also see him becoming very possesive and even dangerous.
Anakin's flirting with queen Miraj is often considered peak flirting. Personally, I think it's the best worst flirting in star wars. Guys, a little tip: DO NOT walk up to a woman you've never met, and say "Your beauty makes the brightest stars seem dull in comparison." UNLESS she's an arrogant slaver queen used to ridiculous flattery. Seriously, this line is ridiculous, over the top, and would be super creepy in normal circumstances. But it's the right line for this situation: Anakin knows what he's doing.
When it comes to Padme though... Anakin doesn't know what he's doing at all. The scenes we see them in, we can see they really like each other. They respect and admire a lot about one another. But it seems neither of them know what a healthy relationship looks like. Especially Anakin. It makes sense - raised as a slave with a singe parent, and then in an order without marriage, he has never really learnt what marriage is. Ani, I've got a tip for you.
Never say: as your husband, I forbid this.
That's not marriage, that's how ownership works. At the same time, Padmé could be a bit more considerate of Anakin's feelings at times. Going along with an undercover mission flirting with her ex, without taking your partner's concerns into account at all, isn't great either. Especially because she knows how insecure and protective Ani is. Personally I think it's her choice whether to do it, but at least take a moment to talk to your husband and ease his concerns. Padmé, you know who you married, you know he'd struggle with this.
That being said, Anakin's jealousy is... Beyond concerning. He tends to be possessive, overprotective, and then there's the scene where he beats up Clovis.
Now guys, I'm all for beating up Clovis there. He was trying to assault Padme. My issue is that when they're talking about it later, Anakin makes it clear he thought it was consensual. He wasn't protecting Padme, he was jealous. And he very nearly killed a guy over it.
But now here comes a point that I respect so much about Anakin: Padmé sais he's scaring her, she sais she needs space. And Anakin sais... Okay.
He doesn't just say he's sorry for his actions, he's willing to do what's needed to make amends, to give Padme what she needs. Even if that's not what he wants right now at all, he does it. This is an action that shows that he cares more about Padmé, about her as a person, than about just his chance to be with her. Respect Anakin.
Of course, it would help if you didn't end up choking her in the end on mustafar.
I'll note it real short here: the bits we see of Ani and Padme in ROTS, reuniting after their time apart, is sweet. But in the end, the problem isn't their relationship, it's Anakin himself. His issues get to him, combined with Palpatine's manipulations, and he loses himself to the dark. If i rated just based on relationships and not flirting, this one of course has to be the worst. He literally kills her. There's really nothing else to say that could weigh up to that.
Cute, but lost romance: Obi-Wan and Satine
So, I'll keep the next bits short cause I already wrote a full length essay on Anakin and Padmé by now...
When we first see Obi and Satine together, they are BICKERING. All. The. Time. But it never really feels hurtful; it feels superficial, hostile but at the same time almost playful. They go at each other like two people who know each other, but nobody goes for really low shot. They're trying to show their frustrations with each other with this little immature - but very ammusing - dance, but nobody is really trying to hurt one another.
And then, when it comes down to it, they discuss their real feelings in a hostage situation. Like every normal relationship.
What, that's not how you guys talk things out?
Obi-Wan and Satine is the relationship that never was. And after they've cleared the air about their... - break up? Separation? Whatever it was, after it's cleared up we once again see the love. It's a mature, loving relationship of two people that could have been, but that never was.
But maybe, next time don't want until there's a gun to your head or a bomb in the cargo to reveal your true feelings. Talking sincerely is allowed even when you're not under threat, you know. But I get it I get it, it's more fun with a plot.
The best we got: Hera and Kanan
We don't see all too much of their relationship. We don't really see the flirting phase in which it all starts, but we see the occasional flirty bits between them. The way they touch each other and talk to each other.
Here are two people who love and respect one another for who they are. They don't need fancy lines or false bravado. They can tease each other and in the end both be smiling. They can talk to each other and listen.
Got other relationships that should be in here? Feel free to share!