percy never promised to keep bianca safe and we have failed as a fandom because so many people think he did.
this is page 119 of the titan's curse. it's definitely a matter of wordplay, but "ill do my best" is NOTHING close to a surefire promise. he never promised.
thats not to say i don't understand where the confusion came from. this is page 290 of house of hades.
rick riordan himself says it-- but it. just. isn't. like i NEED to talk about this cause i keep seeing "percy promised" thrown around the fandom. "i'll do my best" isn't a promise. percy never promised.
also the second excerpt is from Nicoâs POV. Percy promised he would do his best, and for young Nico it was equivalent to a promise to keep her safe. or maybe he remembers it wrong, which would be fair considering how young and emotional he was. already in the titanâs curse he said âyou promised!â because he believed he did. and to be fair, op, Percy DID promise something, Nico may just have forgotten what.
or maybe he didnât, and he was so impressed by Percy that he was sure that his best would be enough. but it wasnât. which meant that either Percy wasnât so great, or that he hadnât tried enough. but he had promised he would. Nico was a kid, he canât be blamed, but the fandom canât think like him.













