see, the thing is, i can’t see a twp where livvy is still here at the end. narratively speaking, the entire end conflict of tda would be moot if she is— ty & kit’s conflict involved whether or not it was smart to try to bring her back, and ty had a choice between kit & livvy and chose livvy. if he chooses livvy again, and brings her back for real this time, we’re just repeating tda again.
at the same time, given malcolm & annabel and ty & livvy’s parallels (namely, malcolm bringing annabel back is portrayed as a negative, and id argue so is ty bringing back livvy, even tho we don’t know quite where cc will take this), id be surprised if cc DOESNT end up having conflict with livvy and ty over this eventually. not to mention they were brought back in different ways— it was annabel’s body & annabel’s spirit, but this is just livvy’s spirit— we know she’s unchanging and 15 but not particularly how she works/functions beyond that.
it’s not a particularly satisfying conclusion for livvy’s story, really, but i’d prefer to see a ty who learns how to grieve and move on (& for livvy to be conflicted over staying or going & eventually choosing going (not a choice ty makes for her), bc she’s dead.), over one who never learns how to cope with this.
who’s to say where cc takes all this tho, bc while she does know her narratives, she’s not always the best on following thru because she tends to make softer endings for characters than is necessarily good for the story (see: her previous non-malcolm ‘necromancy’ plot)