Shout out to the (many) times I got called an elitist gatekeeper for saying that the only real way to fully understand a work of fiction is to experience it firsthand and that summaries and reviews are not a replacement for that
Me, reading the first 80% of the post: What do you mean, "experience it firsthand"? How am I supposed to join the Hunger Games or go on the Odyssey?
Me, reading the final clause of the post: Oh, you literally meant that people have to read the book/listen to the audiobook in order to fully understand it. And people got mad. Oh dear.
To quote what a friend of mine said after she watched Jerry Maguire (1996) for the first time, having thought she knew what it was about because of its cultural ubiquity: “you miss a lot of a movie when you don’t watch it”
Also summaries can be misleading.
Here. Don't look this up. Don't put it in the comments if you know. Read this and tell me what movie it describes:
Transported to a surreal landscape, a young girl kills the first person she meets and then teams up with three strangers to kill again.
Got a guess?
You're locked in?
You're sure?
You don't want a genre hint?
Okay. You're probably gonna feel really silly in a minute, just as a word of warning.
This is a real summary written by Rick Polito.
It was used by Turner Classic Movies in 1998 and was printed in TVGuide. If you're too young to know what that means, it was a staple in most households--if TVGuide said it, you could be pretty sure it was accurate.
Did you guess The Wizard of Oz?
Yeah, I told you it was misleading. Technically it's true, but it misses everything the movie is about.
And if that doesn't explain it for you, I'm not sure anything will.
I've got another example for you!:
An old married man meets up with a much younger woman for sex. After they are caught and he is arrested, he realizes the state isn't as bad as he originally thought.
You know what it is? No?
It's Nineteen Eighty-Four by George Orwell! Admittedly, it's a bit of a stretch, but it shows how much you can distort the most important pieces of media. Those that people actually have a motif for misrepresenting.











