Let's say I really wanted to reduce the number of children who die in car accidents. Car accidents are really bad, right? Nobody disagrees about that. And it would be much better for both the environment and the kids' health if they spent more time walking, or taking the bus. Perfectly reasonable. More cars off the road, safer roads, fewer kids getting hurt, healthier kids. A win-win!
Therefore, let's ban children from traveling by car and require all cars to have a scanner on the door that scans the government ID of everyone who gets in the car to make sure no kids are in there. After all, kids get hurt in car accidents all the time! We need to ban this right away!
i know this is a hypothetical but i'm still going to explain why this is bad. for fun. keep in mind this is still an analogy for why kids need internet access.
"it would be much better for both the environment and the kids' health if they spent more time walking, or taking the bus."
the problem is there isn't anywhere (in america) for kids TO walk. everything is miles and miles apart, so kids simply can't walk anywhere, and instead will spend more time isolated at home. or, if they want to take the bus, it means either
1) they take the school bus to and from school, and have no time to do after-school activities
2) they or their parents have to pay tons of money every year to take the city bus, which is unreliable, or impossible due to bus stops being far from houses
and before you say "oh, people care about kids! they'll put a stop to that!" no. no they won't. children are a marginalized class of people, and the danger associated with walking everywhere in america will just be another thing that gets added onto "the experience" of being under 18.
children will be hit by cars while walking, or commit suicide because they're isolated all summer away from everyone they know.
children will also just. get fake ids in order to go places in cars, and this in turn creates more danger, because no trusted adults will have any idea where they go, and they'll feel unsafe bringing up anything that felt wrong while in that car.
I know this is about children, but it's just bringing up something I've been bitter about for sometime.
America is build centered around cars. I watched several videos about it, and I mean, I see it everywhere: sidewalks stop randomly, wide roads, crazy drivers, not easy to get on a bus.
It's why I miss going to college where you can walk everywhere to meet your needs: places for food and store convenience, and all that.
I also hate driving. I'd rather walk everywhere.
The main consensus of OP is the stupid laws not getting to the core of the problem, or they DO know, but they would ruin a capitalists agenda for profits and no, we can't have that!
This issue is attached to things like losing 3rd places, people being buttfaces about kids "loitering" around or doing something heinus like being a kid, but turns around and says, "kids should go out more, and stop looking at those gosh darn phones!"

















