Gonna drop a bomb into the reactor but can someone tell me why "people just hate women/girls who are anything less than perfect" is exclusively a Marinette defense? Can someone tell me this defense has never been for Alya, a character who has gotten bashed to hell and back with salt as early as Season Three? Can someone tell me why misogyny is exclusively called out when it targets Marinette (or Chloe)?
(Small addition bc this post blew up more than I thought it would: I understand the impulse to hyperfocus on the racial elements to Alya's writing andβas is the focus of this postβher reception to the fandom, but I also don't think the gendered elements should be ignored either. This isn't me asking anyone to prioritize one over the over, but to point out that seeing Alya exclusively as a black character victimized for their blackness as opposed to a black girl victimized for her blackness and her femininity risks denying her gender and her treatment for her gender in a patriarchal world.
Alya deals with misogynoir, but only focusing on the second part and not the first falsely implies that she doesn't deal with the first, and thus isn't "actually a girl," the very mentality that this post is attempting to call out.)
I think the difference is who most people perceive as the main critics of these characters
Most people assume the Marinette critics are men so that leads to the assumption that her hate is mostly misogyny
Same with Chloe, especially with Austruc's behavior
Most Alya salt I personally see is from women, so it's easier to assume it's more racism than sexism
For comparison, Avatar Korra is also a dark-skinned woman and gets the "you just hate women" defense because her critics are mostly assumed male
So while Alya definitely gets sexist hate too, since her detractors are assumed female, people see the racism first and the sexism second despite both of them deserving equal attention














