Unpopular opinion time: I honestly feel like Sensei Garmadon is overrated.
Don’t get me wrong, I love Sensei Garmadon, but I also love what they’ve done with Garmadon during the Oni Trilogy and onwards. And people are constantly begging for Sensei Garmadon back, while I feel like doing so - at least in the way most fans want - would be a disservice to his character.
Let’s be real, consequences are temporary when it comes to main characters. Zane dies? Nevermind, he’s rebuilt new and improved! Cole turns into a ghost? Don’t worry he’s human again a few months later! Nya merges with the sea? They get her back eventually! ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
The loss of Sensei Garmadon is like, the ONLY instance that feels permanent. Or at least, isn’t undone within a few seasons. Even after Garmadon is resurrected, he’s not the same as he was, and he probably never will be. And I love that! When it comes to bringing characters back from the dead, it’s important to have a consequence of some sort as to not cheapen the death itself.
It’s also our first time seeing Garmadon as a legitimately threatening villain. Let’s be real, in seasons 1-2 he was more of a saturday morning cartoon villain. He was more goofy than he was threatening. And when he wasn’t goofy he was just sad. He never feels actually threatening. (With the exception of the pilots).
Emperor Garmadon though? That mf was terrifying.
And the arc that comes afterwards is the most important thing. He has to relearn compassion, empathy, kindness. Relearn the meaning of life. He has to unearth the parts of him that Harumi buried when she resurrected him. (He was never split in half, he was brought back in full, only imbalanced).
We never had a redemption arc for Garmadon before. The first time wasn’t a redemption. He literally had the evil purged out of him. He was evil, then he wasn’t. All was forgiven. No bad blood between him or any of the other characters.
This time Garmadon has to work to better himself. To atone and redeem himself to those he’s hurt. Especially his son. And watching him trying to reclaim the humanity that was ripped from him is a compelling story. He’s come a long way from the emotionless husk that was revived in SOG.
So when people constantly beg for Sensei Garmadon back, it just- kinda irks me. It doesn’t feel like Garmadon gets much appreciation for who he is now. People chase the "perfect" version of him. The "good" version of him that never did anything bad ever. (While the whole letter situation alone made it clear that he was far from perfect).
Like, I was watching a TikTok appreciating Garmadon’s development post-Oni Trilogy, and people in the comments wouldn’t shut up about human/Sensei Garmadon.
I think that speaks for the issue itself.
People act like he’s still evil. They’ll say things like "I want him to be Sensei Garmadon again so he can be on the side of good!" as if he isn’t already on the side of good as of Crystalized. Yeah, he’s still learning, but he’s effectively on the good guy’s side now. He cares for his family and wants to do right by them, and himself. Yet, his progress is hardly acknowledged by this group that longs for Sensei Garmadon.
And then there’s the obsession with his human form. The amount of times I’ve seen "we need human Garmadon back" is too much to count on both my hands. It’s weird because Garmadon was never human to begin with. He’s always been a pure Dragoni hybrid. He just looks more Oni now.
So why do people act like his human form is this pure, perfect shape he needs to return to in order to properly be redeemed? Why is "human" Garmadon the only "good" Garmadon? Idk it just kinda bothers me.
The reason I think Sensei Garmadon should stay gone is not only the fact that having him remain in his Oni form be a good way to send the message that "no, Oni are not inherently evil" (a message the show itself struggles to send), but also because having him look like Sensei Garmadon again would make it too easy to treat him and Lord/Emperor Garmadon as two separate characters.
People would dismiss Garmadon’s character from SOG to Crystalized as "not really him" or "an empty shell". All of his character development? Doesn’t matter, it was never the "real" Garmadon anyway. We got the "real" Garmadon back so we can forget about that other guy! 😀 (Sarcasm).
Like, no. They’re the same person. Just changed.
It would be a huge waste. It would render both Sensei G’s initial sacrifice and Emperor Garmadon’s development meaningless.
Sensei Garmadon was a great character, but it feels like the fandom’s obsession with him stems from nostalgia at this point. Garmadon deserves to be respected and loved for who he is now.
A man trying to reclaim the humanity that was stolen from him. Who thrives in destruction, but uses it to protect. Who regards an ordinary man as among the wisest he’s met. Who loves his plant Christofern. Who has a childish streak towards his brother. Who loves to lounge around and eat pizza.
Who doesn’t know how to be "good", but tries anyway.
If he were to become Sensei Garmadon again, it has to be a natural transition and not a transformation of any kind. Like, if he decides to start teaching again, and becomes a kinder, more flexible teacher.
But he shouldn’t be the same character from seasons 3, 4, and 5. He should still be a bit of an asshole, as a treat. He should still embrace his Oni nature. And overall he should still feel like the character we’ve gotten to know since the Oni Trilogy.
I’d be fine with him shapeshifting to look like Sensei Garmadon as well (because that would be fucking funny), but ONLY if he alternates between his human and Oni forms regularly. I don’t want the human form to become the default.
Thank you for coming to my Ted Talk.