Seth

Toby laid slack on top of you, nuzzling his face into your chest as you applied pressure to the back of his neck. His tears slowly dripped onto your skin and absorbed into the fabric of your night gown. You tightened your embrace around him.

Recently, too many arguments had risen back at the mansion. Every day became a constant reminder for Toby that he had nothing, nothing besides being Slenderman's favored proxy.

Toby knew the other proxies didn't like him. Tim and Brian could only put up with him for so long before snapping.

But then the day came that Toby ended up snapping instead.

He had gone to his room and began packing whatever he could fit into a backpack. You came in and tried to stop him from leaving, he was the only person who even tried to understand you, how could you just let a connection like that run away?

You two discussed. He convinced you to join him.

Then, you two had set up a pretty cozy home inside this abandoned cottage. It wasn't much, but it worked.

At least now you were both away from where you weren't wanted.

Slenderman didn't mind, as long as you both still worked for him, he didn't care. He never really cared.

Some days were more painful than others, earlier today Slenderman had forced Toby to join a group mission and all the others just kept making snide remarks along the way.

More reminders. More heartbreak.

Weren't they supposed to be a family?

After the mission, he ran to the cottage and collapsed onto the bed.

He sobbed until his nose was red and his eyes puffy.

Then you came home.

You quickly sat next to him and dragged him onto your lap, he wouldn't stop shaking until you gently combed his hair with your hands.

Eventually he slowly went limp, slack against your body.

You both fell asleep in each others warm presence.....

Toby woke up first, he gently shifted out of your embrace and sat himself up besides you.

Then he playfully poked at your sides, causing you to stir slightly but overall stay asleep.

He giggled to himself and flopped back down on you like a massive dog.

His hands roamed against the thin fabric of your night gown, you looked so soft and beautiful to him. You were always beautiful in his eyes, no matter what you said or thought about yourself. No matter what you even actually looked like.

Then, his hands found your soft breasts, he gave them a nice squeeze, feeling the plush tender flesh.

He wanted more, and he felt his cock begin to stir.

Toby shucked off his jeans and tossed them to the ground, leaving himself in his boxers. A tent forming in the fabric.

He mounted onto your sleeping form and began to gently rut his hips into you, he gritted his teeth and tried to keep any sort of resolve, but you just felt too good.

Too good. Too good for him. You were his precious bunny.

Then, he leaned up to your exposed, plush neck.

He couldn't help himself, he opened his jaw and clamped down.

You immediately woke up in a daze, scared and shocked.

Toby released and quickly lapped at your skin to soothe you.

"It's okay bunny, go back to sleep..." He gently whispered to you.

"Why would you bite me?..." You groggily whined.

"Shhhh, that's enough..." He cooed lovingly.

As you drifted back to sleep, he continued to mount and cuddle you roughly.

Toby palmed his own cock through his boxers, emitting a low groan from himself.

He reached down and grabbed at your soft plush thighs, squeezing your flesh and then scooping his hands underneath. He pushed your thighs up to your shoulders and inserted his body between your legs.

His throbbing erection pressed warmly against you now.

You woke up fully and looked at him.

"If you were feeling needy you could've just said so..." You questioned.

"Y-Yeah but I just....Shut up..." He pouted.

"So sensitive." You rolled your eyes.

"Sensitive?" Toby squeezed your thighs, causing you to moan quite loudly.

"I'm not the sensitive one here." He scoffed.

You whined softly, looking up at him for more. Toby just smirked stupidly.

You reached and tugged his boxers down.

His cock sprang out, pink and leaking, a bead of precum dripping down the side.

You sat up and grabbed it in your hands, feeling the weight and squeezing the tip.

After feeling him a bit, you flopped down and opened your thighs.

"Oh you're such a slut for me~." He teased.

You scrunched up your brows and kicked his thigh.

"Okay damn..." He mumbled.

Toby brought himself closer to you, he dipped his hand down gently and rubbed the outside of your panties, feeling between your flesh and prepping you.

"Off. Take them off." He asked.

You raised your hips and slid your panties off, discarding them somewhere on the bed.

Toby didn't waste any time.

He shoved a finger into your wet cunt and curled it upwards, digging into the soft spongy tissue inside of you. you began to squirm and he used his other hand to press your hips down.

"Don't be difficult now, come on bunny." He cooed.

He shoved in two extra fingers, stuffing your tight cunt with more of a stretch. He smeared his fingers around and just kept on stimulating you.

After feeling you were ready, he lathered his hand in your arousal and used it to lubricate his cock.

He pumped himself a couple times before diving in between your thighs and rubbing his tip into your cunt, letting the fluids mix.

He slowly pushed in his wide mushroomed tip, your cunt stretched around it.

"Come on Bunny you got this, biggg stretch come on..." He encourage.

Eventually, he was fully seated inside of you, his hands found their home on your hips and he began slowly thrusting, humping himself onto you.

He leaned forwards and pushed your legs up higher, shifting into a mating press. You gasped once you were fully sandwiched between him and the mattress.

He kept you trapped underneath him and began humping you even harder. His cock making obscene noises with every thrust.

As his cock pumped you deeply, his head rested in the crook of your neck and gently lapped at your flesh. Then he suddenly bit down onto your flesh. Almost as if he was trying to latch onto you.

He got more violent with his thrusts and would pull his cock all the way out just to slam it back in. Your hips began to ache but he just keep going, just kept hitting your cervix.

His hand reached down to rub your throbbing clit and his other hand rolled your nipples between the pads of his fingers. The dual stimulation made your eyes widen and your walls pulsate around him.

Toby huffed roughly and began slamming in and out at an obscene pace, he pulled out entirely and slammed back in to fill your womb with his seed.

He stilled inside of you and went limp, pinning you against the bed.

He stayed there for a few minutes before peeling his body off of you and heading to grab a wet towel for you.

He came back and gently opened your legs to clean up the sticky mess he made.

After wiping you down, he pressed a loving kiss to your clitoris and curled up next to you in bed, spooning you and peppering kisses to your neck.

"I love you, R-Reader..."

"I love you too, Toby."

Bare Backing- Sex without protection.

Now, this one is really depends if you are on the pill or not. Tobys biggest fear is becoming a dad and being just like his father. So unless you are on that pill and he KNOWS you won't get pregnant, you are gonna get creampied.

Face Fucking- A really Rough blow job.

What a perfect way to get rid of pent-up stress? He would gladly fuck your face rough, and might be too rough in certain moments cause of his tics but immeaditly after, you know he's gonna worry over you and make sure you are okay.

Loud Sex- Being loud as fuck so everyone can hear

pretty self explanatory, wouldn't you think? He wants to make sure that everyone knows your his and he is yours, so what better way of doing that is letting them hear? But be careful cuz this man will think you are telling people that you're his and then start thinking you want people to hear your moans so they can fantasize about it

Rough Sex- Includes Biting, Scratching, Power play and ETC

yeah, his tics COULD be a bit of a problem... If for once you guys are having a gentle moment and his tics hitted randomly, scratching you? Yeah, that would be annoying for him and you. BUT, he loves rough sex in general, he sees it as a way to be in control AND a way to mark you. Seeing you with HIS bitemarks, and HIS scratches that were intentional? Ohh, it just turns him on even more.

Light Bondage- Restraining/restricting someones movement