in light of recent comments concerning the new Hunt for Gollum movie, I feel I should call attention to this passage from the prologue in The Fellowship of the Ring
of course, one could argue that in the time of the war of the Ring, these lines have all but faded into one population of hobbits, meaning they should all look relatively similar (even this would imply that hobbits, being mostly comprised of the browner Harfoots, would have had a darker complection overall), however, in the passage above it states that the Fallohidish strain (the least numerous line) could still be noticed in certain hobbits. this implies that, however little, there is still a measurable distinction to found between these lines
I could go on with more examples of racial diversity in the Lord of the Rings books, of which there are several, but truthfully, I don't think that's the point.
the Shire, as said by Tolkien himself, has always been a reflection of the central Midlands English countryside
(clipping of a 1964 bbc interview for reference)
being someone who lives in these English countrysides, it has always meant a great deal to me that in Tolkien's brilliant mind, the Shire was as diverse as we still find this beautiful country to be today.
the comment made that the Shire seems a very white area is not only disingenuous to the original source material, but also a worrying, gatekeeping, and aggravating statement in a time where a concerning number of people from this country (and many other countries) will find every excuse they can to disregard and separate ourselves from our POC neighbours in collective spaces.
the Shire, the wider world of Middle Earth, the Lord of the Rings as a whole, has always been, and should always be a collective space for whoever enjoys epic fantasy, regardless of race, gender, and ethnicity, and it is insulting to all the fans to suggest otherwise
it is disheartening to see so many agree and condone the statements made by Andy Serkis and I hope in time the damage done to the POC fans will somehow be reversed
for now, I am rereading the Lord of the Rings to my younger siblings, I have been marking down many different things as I go through, one of those being the times Tolkien references the different races of the characters (hence the highlighted first passage), and if anyone was interested, I would be happy to share every instance I find once we have finished the books so that regardless of what is seen in these new medias, you can have the knowledge that you were represented in the original version of this beautiful story.









