YukiNoFuyuko

First would you like to be a bit more openly xenophobic toward chinese language trainees ? Or what you're doing is enough ? Recycled uniformes, master being harder on them when they are abroad in a different language and a different culture, not mentioning a voting system that inherently disadvantages them ... and honestly in think the Planet C auditions were generally betters... they had more personnality... The treatment they get from the show disgust me

In general, I think the show lacks the personnality that the first seasons had (I'm not a fan of the first season by any means) Haruto, Keita, Rui, Jay Chang, Wumuti, Takuto Wongki, Junhyun ... Boys II Planet got some good trainees clearly but no one like that (not on them, clearly the mnet editing's fault)

In my opinion, the best performance were the Back door audition on Planet C and the Rising Sun by team 1 but it's not as good as some stuff from season one and even full performance doesn't come close to some auditions on Chuang Asia 2 (Super thai)

How am I only finding out now that some of my favorites boys from Chuang Asia 2 are a T-pop group which does fire music

Disclamers : No hate to any of them I hope they all succed in their project but I'm human I've got preferences. And I don't know any of them personnally obviously so any and all character judging is solely based on what can be seeing in the show. It's my opinion, not solely based on objective criterias.

My opinion on the final group

Technically I'm not unhappy about the final group (5 of my final 7 picks are in the group), they all have potential I just don't think everyone was ready. Also I'm a bit upset about the balance of chinese/non chinese members in the international group

My final pick were Dorn, Thi-o, YeTao, Xiong, Ninja, Shen, Tadalee (and if we could've add a spot for Koshin that would've been perfect)

I'll do every member in the order they were annonced on the final

N°6 Xiong : I'm glad he really deserved it he is one of the trainee who did the most progress in terms of performance (he was always good but he got better) and he got great chemistry with most of the other members. Altough I was surprised he got such a low ranking ! He deserves to be higher.

N°5 Shen : Really ?! I didn't think he was gonna make it but I'm glad ! I had my eyes on him since Still Monsters. I think it's great he getting to be on the same group as Xiong they seem to have a wholesome relationship.

N°4 Omar : Still don't get it, I'll probably never get it. I'm still genuinely open to someone trying to explain to me the why and how .... I will also note that I'm very much against debut such young trainees .... There should be law against debuting before 18. It's child labor.

N°7 Yao Zihao : Sooooo he was not a pick of mine.... when he was annonced I was really really really annoyed cause guessing who top3 was not difficult (it's not like it changed a lot ... ) and I really wanted this spot for Ninja. Apart from that : Zihao has the potential he is a good rapper and a good dancer (and the group needs rapper cause most of them are dancers) but I really don't think he is ready to be in a group he needs to learn to be in tune with other and to be smarter with his energy (like The8 said at the audition, he knows super high energy idols who are doing great he is a member of Seventeen, if I was Zihao I would take as many advice from him as I could) I hope he grows in the group.

N°3 Hu Yetao : Yes. I am happy he is in the top 3 he deserves it and that's the spot I would have chose for him. He clearly is one of the most skilled trainee but I think Dorn and Thi-o are a bit better on dancing and singing skills so it makes sense

N°2 Thi-o : Obviously. It's great nothing to add.

Disclamers : No hate to any of them I hope they all succed in their project but I'm human I've got preferences. And I don't know any of them personnally obviously so any and all character judging is solely based on what can be seeing in the show. It's my opinion, not solely based on objective criterias.

My personnal ranking of perfomance of the second public stage (Ep. 7 and 8)