I am not a person given to disagreeing with Mark Evanier about... well, much of anything. The man has forgotten more than I will ever know in the first place on almost any topic I'd be inclined to discuss. However, I've seen this same kind of "R.I.P." to Saturday Morning Cartoons/Programming for Kids on Broadcast Networks in a lot of places.
And I'm inclined to echo it, because I grew up loving Saturday Morning Cartoons... only... well... it's not actually true.
Let's ignore PBS, which (at least where I live) broadcasts hours of cartoons on Saturday mornings. I mean, it's there and those cartoons exist, but we're pretending they don't, because... um... of a reason. Let's also ignore all paid tv -- all cable and satellite channels. For a good reason, mind. Not everyone has those or the Internet. Let's just look at commercial broadcast television.
NBC. 8:30. "Noodle and Doodle." 9am. "Astroblast." 9:30. "The Chica Show." 10am. "Tree Fu Tom." Â 10:30. "Lazy Town." 11am. "Poppy Cat." Repurposed? Yeah, sure -- but to a kid who doesn't get Sprout, it's new. And if they do get Sprout, they almost certainly get Cartoon Network, Nick or Disney, and I'm not worried about them.
CBS: 10am. "Lucky Dog." 10:30. "Dr. Chris: Pet Vet." 11am. "Innovation Nation." 11:30. "Recipe Rehab." All live action E-I content, sure, but targeted to kids. And mostly new stuff, too (and our local station doesn't carry all that CBS broadcasts).
ABC: 9am: "Jack Hanna's Wild Countdown." 9:30am: "Ocean Mysteries with Jeff Corwin," 10am: "Sea Rescue. 10:30. "The Wildlife Docs." 11am: "Outback Adventures with Tim Faukner." 11:30: "Born to Explore."Â
FOX: 7am "Xploration: Awesome Planet." 7:30 "Xploration: Outer Space," 8am "XPloration: Earth 2050." 8:30 "XPloration: Animal Science." 9am "Career Day." (Which is actually targeted to freaking teenagers. Points to Fox).Â
The CW may not have cartoons anymore, it's true, but they also have a bunch of E-I content on the subject of nature -- albeit repackaged from other sources. I won't bother typing it in.
I'm a little surprised our local "My TV" affiliate doesn't have anything but paid programming and NWA Wrestling... but on the other hand they have freaking NWA Wrestling. I didn't even know NWA still had television programming. I swear to God, I wonder if this is a local NWA affiliate putting on shows in high schools or what. I'm so tempted to record it.
If you're seeing a dearth of non-cartoon programming above... well, I specifically excluded PBS, which is freaking loaded with cartoons. If you're seeing a dearth of awesome above... I agree with you. Lots of Educational Content, very little Birdman and the Galaxy Trio. (Why in God's name doesn't My TV run the old Hanna Barbara cartoons? They can't cost that much and the level of awesome they provide is monumental.) But there are cartoons, above (mostly on NBC) and all of the above's content produced for and pitched towards kids.
And, a good amount of it's actually being produced by said networks, which is more than I can say for the CW's fare. (I love Justice League Unlimited more than the next guy, but seeing it on the CW with edits for broadcast standards -- including I swear to God dubbing in stock laser sounds every time a gun is fired because of... um... reasons? Was not cartoons being produced for Saturday Morning. It was cartoons being shown on Saturday Morning. Not the same thing.)
And... well, if we're going to restrict it to broadcast networks... I really should mention the quarter-ton of religious networks broadcasting over the air essentially nation wide. Love TBN or hate TBN -- they are loaded with cartoons and puppet shows on Saturday Morning, and so are all their ilk. 3-2-1 Penguins! Gina D's [horrible] Kid's Club, Mary Rice Hopkins and Puppets With a Heart, Davey and Goliath, The Lads, The Storykeepers, VeggieTales, Greatest Heroes and Legends of the Bible and Monster Truck Adventures may have Biblical messages, but they're still cartoons, puppet shows and the like, and some of them rival the production values of stuff currently running on Cartoon Network. And Lassie... is just straight up Lassie, no Jesus involved.
There is something to mourn in the above, sure. But it's not the end of Saturday Morning Cartoons or Saturday Morning Kids' Shows on Broadcast TV. And if there isn't a Smurfs, Fat Albert, Space Ghost and Dino Boy, X-Men or, yes indeed, Garfield and Friends among them... well, I'm sad too. But then, I was sad when ABC was reruns of Kim Possible and repackaged Mighty Morphin' Power Rangers, too.
And I would have been sad regardless, because nothing could recreate the Saturday Mornings of my youth, because the conditions no longer exist. In the 70's, we had little to no choices. I had more than most kids my age, in fact, because I had CHSJ (the New Brunswick Television System) and various French stations to go along with the cartoons you all had. Say what you want, but having extra bonus Barbapapa andAlbator (which the rest of you learned about as Captain Harlock some time later) made for significant awesome in my life.
And yet, despite the massive amount of Saturday Morning Cool I had... I also ended up watching a whole bunch of Mutual of Omaha's Wild Kingdom and ABC's Wide World of Sports, because sometimes that's what there was.
Kids will survive. Even the ones who don't have cable or the internet. And they will look back on their childhood with nostalgia, too. Even if it's nowhere near as cool as our nostalgia.
But then, we would have thought that anyway.
Let us not mourn the death of kids' Saturday morning. Let us instead bemoan the lack of cool to be found in it, and let us figure out what if anything can be done about that.