Pip's is Prime
Er and I have never done a joint post, but this afternoon I was walking through midtown and decided that it was time to try out Pip's Place on East 37th Street between Park & Lex. They have an uptown location, as well, but since I'm rarely on the upper east and frequently in midtown, I opted for the closer location. I should note that maybe it would have been better if I never knew they existed. I blame Er, naturally, as she heard about the place a few months back.
If you've been following us here you know that Er and I take our jobs as taste testers of all things gf very seriously. We love food and we believe our food--gf food--should taste just like the real thing. We know that many of you settle for an okay version of whatever sweet you're craving and we understand. But as we've stated before, we are on a quest to not feel deprived by our lack of delicious baked goods. We believe that good gf food is not only possible, but our right. And in our search for truly delicious things, Pip's did not disappoint.
I state all of this, in part, to explain the gluttony you are about to witness (ed. note i.e. Er note: Ha!). See, it isn't enough just to have a good cupcake option, we want ALL. OF. THE. OPTIONS. So when I walked into Pip's and there was a wide array of sweet things, I took it as my duty to sample widely. The result is that Er and I succumbed to a rather serious sugar high, but we did so in the name of science and dessert. We made ourselves nearly ill for you. Aren't you grateful? You will be. Unless you don't live in NYC, in which case you're going to be jealous. Sorry about that.
I asked the helpful gentleman at Pip's what his favorite gf items were and he started naming things off, and then ended with "pretty much all of the cookies." I'm not one to contradict a specialist with intimate knowledge of the products, so I just sort of said "yes" to most things, and this is what we ended up with. When he asked if I needed a bag, I just laughed and said, "No, I'm taking these to share with a friend, right now." Like any of these delicacies were going to survive an Em and Er taste test.
Here is what we tried.
Heath Bar Square (upper left)
Raspberry Pinwheel (lower left)
Gingersnap (lower center)
Blueberry Fairy Cake (upper right)
Mini Oatmeal Raisin Cookie Sandwiches w/ frosting (lower right)
Please believe my shock and pleasure when I tell you that all of them were delicious. ALL. If you've been gf for any amount of time, you know what an amazing statement that is. In retrospect, I showed tremendous restraint in not ordering more things to try. Thankfully, there is always next time.
On to the reviews. I'm listing these in the order we tried them.
Gingersnap
Hello People! Er here. As Em so brilliantly and enthusiastically explained (I just realized we're pretty much 30-something year old Beliebers, except we're fangirls for food), what makes Pip's treats so delicious is that they just taste so real. Like, you could put this cookie in front of anyone and they would never know it was gf. In fact, we noticed that we couldn't even taste xanthan gum, which is normally the telltale sign of a gf product. And yet, the texture. Em and I are both ginger lovers so this was probably our favorite of the bunch, but the others were close behind. Note that we also tried each with a sip of coffee to test it's cappatibility (that would be its compatibility with a cappuccino duh) so trust that each has been thoroughly analyzed.
Raspberry Pinwheel
Delicious. Subtle. Not too sweet. Good texture; a bit chewy.
Blueberry Fairy Cake
First of all, this cake just has excellent hold. Like, it just feels good and heavy in your hand. Again, not too sweet, but the blueberries add a delicious tartness and it seems that they've added quite a bit of orange zest as well. Super moist on the inside. Only gripe is that, when I have it to do over again, I will take it home and pop it in the oven. And then slather it in butter, because duh butter.
Em's note: Agree with all above, but would like to point out that the name is perfect. The magic of fairies is contained within this moist mini-bundt cake, which is a cross between a good blueberry muffin and a pound cake.
Mini-Oatmeal Raisin Cookie Sandwiches w/ Frosting
Em and I are big oatmeal fans too so we loved these yummy little cookies.
Heath Bar Square
Aaahhhh the heath bar square... This guy was definitely in a tight battle with that gingersnap for first place. I don't know about you, but as much as I love the flavor of heath, I find candy bars to be way too sweet, which is why this square is such a revelation. It features all the flavors of heath and chocolate that we love, but ingeniously set upon a flaky, buttery, delicious shortbread, so the sweetness is tempered by its subtle base. Fact--I could probably eat anything on top of this crust, it's that good. It also passed the cappatability test with flying colors.
Em's note: Yes to all of this. I want to point out that we tried the Heath Bar Square last and were already well on our way to a sweet overdose (we should have interspersed some savory in our tasting). We judiciously decided to split one tiny bit of the bar--maybe 1/8 of it. However, we loved the flavor so much that we proceeded to eat several more bites even though our blood sugar levels were dangerously high.
xoEm xoEr















