I see the Tolkien's quote abt "evil being unable to create" so often that it slowly stops being about "AI is just a rehash of training data" and becomes "anti AI crowd is just quoting the same piece of text", which is... ironic, IMHO.
Also, the COSMIC IRONY of leftish crowd quoting cryptofascist [see Moorcook's Epic Pooh on it, though even if cleaned of bait-ish parts, toryism of Tolkien is relatively open] to combat technofascistic tendencies is not lost on me too.
The layers of irony that are uncovered at the very moment we consider that "Last Ringbearer", Tolkin-based fic with "good techies of Mordor" by Russian author played it's role in Thiel's Reign Of Darkness called Palantir, are even worse.
(Do I have stance on AI? Yeah, basically "Pope is right that unchecked AI is dangerous, but AI can be immensely useful, and yeah, I doubt the take on AI having no moral agency - for all it's worth, we may be overselling the amount of such agency in humans, like it was with vitalism in biology long time ago")
So, remember, folks, it's not applied math algorithms with sophisticated simulacra of consciousness who are your enemy - it's fascists and good-for-nothing capitalistic crooks; for all it goes, neither Tolkien's vision nor "Last Ringbearer"' are good places to be, because it's either enlightened monarchy (which is... bad) or enlightened technocratic monarchy with CEO-king (which is also bad, but also stupid). Stop using Middle-Earth shaped frame to describe world that is increasingly unlike Middle-Earth











