Touch aversion ask.
is it guilt ? some kind of punishment or is it a protection.
OK SO it's interesting because it's not really any of those things in either verse - with the exception of protection, actually, I guess that comes into it a lot now I think about it. But let me explain my thoughts on it in each au:
So in Campervan AU, the Doctor's touch aversion is a messy combination of things. A lot of it is actually because she's lowkey autistic, and so touch is very intense for her and she just finds the sensation of skin on skin to be somewhat overwhelming. But then you combine THAT with her fundamental problem with control and it becomes more of an issue. Because she likes to be in control, doesn't like people grabbing her unexpectedly, doesn't like people touching her at ALL - but she can touch other people, if she wants to. We see it in part 4 with Jack, when she gives him a hug because she knows he won't try and hug her back. She has enough control that she's comfortable with it. But she doesn't find much comfort in touch, and thus later in part 4, when Jack seems to want to hug HER, he doesn't because he knows it wouldn't actually help her at all and would probably just overwhelm her more. Of course, her issues with control stem from her childhood (and people who've read this au will probably have clocked that control, or lack of it, is a key theme in this story, and that a lot of Koschei's issues are all about control too). So then when she is expecting touch or feels completely in control (or on very rare ocassions, actually seeking it out) then she can touch people and it's ok. Case in point - Jack grounding her whilst at the hospital, and Ryan at the end of part 3 with the ambulance. It works because touch is intense for her, so it cuts through the noise of her panic attack and provides her an anchor that she trusts, is in control of, and also knows isn't going to grab at her or unexpectedly do something that freaks her out further.
But then in Zombie AU, Theo's touch aversion is all about trauma. She actually liked touch before everything went down - case in point, the flash memories where Koschei touches her show her having zero issue with it and very much being relaxed about it. It's less obvious at this point because we're only four chapters in but as the fic goes on you'll see that Theo's touch aversion means she can't stand touch AT ALL. Even if she was initiating it and completely in control. And it's because of 1) everything that happened in the lab after the isolation chamber exploded and 2) everything that happened in general after the pandemic regarding lots of incidents where she got grabbed or touched in a Bad Way because zombies and desperate survivors but in particular 3) the mass grave incident. Which means when she gets touched? That's a trigger. Unlike for campervan 13 who just has an aversion to it, Theo is very traumatised. She cannot deal with it. She gets vivid flashbacks. And she discusses this a bit with Dan in chapter 3, but it'll become more obvious as thing goes on how it's categorically different to campervan 13's issues - especially when people actually touch Theo hahaha (because of course it's going to happen). I mainly noticed this difference because I read back on some of campervan after finishing zombie au and was just...wigged out by the fact that she actually DOES touch people sometimes! And she can deal with it haha whereas when I was writing Theo, I definitely got into her head a bit and suddenly saw that a LOT of the ways that she approaches things is like...with an extra step that goes in first before EVERYTHING which is "how do I make sure no one is touching me". Campervan 13 does this a little, but she's much more reactionary - if someone reaches out for her, she flinches back. Whereas Theo was already standing out of reach.
And then both of them are then interesting to play off against characters like Grace - who, in both verses, I characterise as being someone who seeks out comfort via touch, and shows/feels love and affection via touch. And it's just fascinating to play with that.















