Prize
Description: After winning a quidditch match against Gryffindor. Theo and Mattheo want to claim a prize for their hard work. Which just so happens to be their bold Gryffindor.
Pairing: Theodore Nott x Gryffindor! Reader x Matheo Riddle
Warnings: Smut! 18+, P in V, Threesome, Female reader, degradation, praise, cursing, and female reader. MDNI
Authors Note: This is my first time writing something of this nature so please let me know if I miss any warnings or what I can improve upon. Thank you so much for reading! Enjoy!
Masterlist
You sighed getting ready for what will likely be a lot of gloating. You looked at yourself in the mirror. For someone who had just lost you certainly didn’t look like it. Your confidence grows the longer you admire yourself. “Are you seriously going?” You turn towards Ginny raising an eyebrow. “Of course. We may not have won and this may be a Slytherin party. However, as you know I am friends with a lot of them. Pansy is one of my closest friends.” Ginny sighs out of concern. She knew how these parties could get however normally her brothers would be there to assist if anything happened to either of them. However, they wouldn’t be at this one.
You smiled at her “I mean I thought you’d be willing to go. A good time to get to know Pansy rather than questioning me every chance you get.” She sends you a scowl making you laugh. “You’re one to talk I only look at one Slytherin while you look at two.” You roll your eyes before making your way to the door. “At least I talk to them.” You quickly leave the door as you see her chuck a pillow at you. Avoiding the hit. It was true that you often found yourself admiring two of your friends. However, you knew it was unlikely either of them saw you that way. Maybe.
You make your way towards the Slytherin common room before reaching the entrance and saying the password. As you walk in you look around for your friend. Struggling to find her past the grinding bodies and already drunk figures. Finally, you see Pansy standing next to the rest of the group. You look next to her and can’t help but look at the two and notice just how good they look tonight. However, before you could lose yourself in admiring the two you notice Pansy waving you over. You work your way through the crowd before finally reaching her.
“There’s our loser for tonight. I told you we’d obliterate you!” You roll your eyes yet hug her once you approach. Before you greet her in a more defeated tone “Yes the loser has arrived.” She grabs you and leans in “You look hot.” You smile confidently “I know.” You both laugh a little before you hear movement from behind her. “How does it feel to see your team be destroyed so badly?” You flick Lorenzo on the back of his head causing him to flinch. “How did that feel?” You feel Pansy start to snort at the action. Before you feel a presence behind you. You turn slightly only to see Theo as he wraps his arm around your waist. “You look beautiful, Tesoro.” You watch as his eyes look up and down your figure.
You slightly turn away to avoid him seeing your reaction. Only to see Mattheo approaching from your other side. “Yeah, beautiful where’ve you been hiding this from us?” You watch his eyes staring at you with so much of something you can’t read. You feel your hand get grabbed before you’re dragged away. “Nope, this is my best friend. You are not taking her before we get a dance in.” You smile before following Pansy to the dance floor.
After a while, you haven’t drunk too much only enough to give you a light buzz. Unlike Pansy who seems completely gone as she dances alongside you. You follow the beat of the music and her movement. And as your eyes wander they make eye contact with two boys in the corner. Both are looking directly at you. You don’t know what encouraged you to do it but you wanted to see how they’d react. You begin to make your movements clearer and less shy. Knowing people were enjoying what you were doing. You knew how you looked in your tight dress. How that could make them feel and you knew where their minds could go. After a while, you thought perhaps they had looked away or gotten bored with your show. Until you felt an arm go around your waist. You turn only to see Theo behind you.
“Come on Tesoro.” His voice is low and you feel something rub up against your back as he speaks. You look over at Pansy seeing that she was in safe hands talking with Lorenzo about who knows what. Before turning and following him as he held your hand. He brings you up into the boys’ dormitory where you see Mattheo smoking. Before he turns to quickly put it out knowing you don’t like the smell. He walks up to you and grabs your chin. “We want you and we know you want us too.” You look at him shocked and slightly confused before wrapping your head around his words. “Just say the word and we won’t do anything you don’t want us to do. Got it? You nod before Theo grabs your chin to look at him. “Say it, Tesoro.” You look at him with wide eyes. “Yes, I got it.”
“Good because tonight you’re our prize, Beautiful.” Before you can wrap your head around what he said Mattheo’s kissing you. Something you never thought would happen was happening. Not just with one of them but with both. You feel Theo approach you from behind and can’t help but breathe out a sigh as he begins to kiss your neck. You moan as he bites and sucks on it which will surely leave marks.
Mattheo pulls away only to pull off his shirt as he begins to kiss you again. While you start to feel Theo pull down your zipper. They both pull away to help you out of your dress before looking at you. They were mesmerized by the person in front of them. Before finally working their way towards you. Theo begins to kiss you while he starts to play with your tits. You moan into his mouth as he pinches them. You notice Mattheo lean down to your lower half before pulling off your panties only to groan at what’s in front of him. You feel two of his fingers begin to rub your clit. “All this for just us beautiful? How sweet.” You feel Theo pull away curious about what Mattheo had said before sighing as he saw just how wet you were. “Fuck.” He returns to kissing you significantly harder after that. Then focused on leaving marks on your chest. You feel two fingers begin to enter you causing you to moan out.
“Does that feel good? Is the Gryffindor all desperate for us now? How would the others feel if they knew you were doing this huh? If they knew just how much of a slut you are? Letting us play with you after losing. You wanted this didn’t you?” You can’t help but get turned on by Mattheo’s words. As he began to suck on your clit. Making you closer to finishing. “Cmon say it you wanted this.” You can’t help but give in to it lost in your pleasure. “Fuck yes, I wanted this. I wanted it so bad. Shit.” Theo looks up at you from where he’s leaving marks. “You’re doing so good Tesoro keep going.”
As you get closer and closer to finishing you grab Theo’s hair to ground yourself. “Fuck.” You feel your legs shake as you finish on Mattheo’s face before beginning to slow your breathing. They both begin to kiss you all over “You okay to keep going?” You eagerly nod “Yes just fuck me already.” Theo shakes his head at you “Manners Principessa.” You sigh at their stubbornness. “Please fuck me both of you. I need it.”
They seem satisfied as Mattheo turns you around so you’re in a crawl position. As he gets behind you he takes off his pants. “Let me know when you’re ready for me to move.” You feel his cock rub against you before he begins to enter. You moan out as Theo holds you up as you take it. After a few minutes, he’s fully in and you give the go-ahead that it is no longer uncomfortable. Almost as if he was holding himself back that he begins to pound into you. You turn to see Theo pulling out his cock encouraging you to suck it. You immediately get to work. Watching his face relax as he begins to feel pleasure. “Fuck keep taking it Beautiful like the slut you are. Shit. I’ve wanted to do this for a long time.” You moan at Mattheo’s words. As Theo grabs your face the vibrations make his pleasure double.
“Doing so good Amore. Keep going.” You bob your head back and forth flattening your tongue to rub on the bottom of his cock. And teasing the tip with it. He moans at your movement. As you watch him get closer to finishing. Not that anyone could judge as you felt yourself get closer to finishing for the second time. And you could tell by Mattheo’s movements he was too. “Shit” you feel your mouth get filled up with cum as Theo finishes pulling away once he’s done. Only to watch as you swallow it and open your mouth to show him. “You’re perfect Tesoro.”
Now that you’re mouth isn’t full your moans are heard as Theo encourages you and tells you how good you’re doing. “Fuck Theo I’m gonna-.” That’s all you get out before grabbing onto him as you finish for the second time. Mattheo's groans as you tighten around him. “You’re so tight beautiful. Shit.” You feel yourself get filled with Mattheo’s cum causing you to moan at the sensation. After a few minutes, you feel him pull out. Suddenly feeling empty.
The room is quiet as you all seem to catch your breath. They help you lie down before cleaning you up and getting you water. Theo lies next to you as Mattheo cleans up. Leaving pecks on your face telling you how you’re amazing and how well you did. Mattheo joins your other side before sighing into you. You weren’t sure what this was. All that you knew was that this definitely wouldn’t be the only time.














