Happy Anniversary Again | Steve Harrington x Byers!reader
Summary: After finding out that Steve was hiding things from you and breaking up over it, you try to find out what exactly this secret was. You nearly end up losing your life in the process.
Warnings: canon-typical violence, not proof-read, some swearing here and there.
a/n: I'm very nervous about this part y'all so please let me know if you guys like it!
w.c: 7.4k
dividers by @uzmacchiato
Part 1
It has been two weeks since that night.
Since then, Steve has called your house multiple times a day to try to talk to you and make up for the first three days. You answered at first, listening to him apologize for not being there enough, for missing out on dates and calls, for missing your anniversary dinner, and promising to do better. But every time it would end in the same way: “Are you finally willing to tell me the truth?” you’d whisper. He’d sigh sadly. “You know, I can’t do that, doll. It's too dangerous,” and you’d hear the genuine sadness in his voice, as if not telling you was killing him, too. You’d come close to relenting so many times because hearing Steve Harrington sound sad was more than your mind, body, and heart could handle. The ache that already gripped your chest would tighten its hold at his tone, squeezing until it was difficult to keep your voice steady. But then the stubbornness would kick in, the reminder that you were hurting, too, and you had to think about yourself here first because you refused to be an afterthought in your relationship. So you’d say calmly, “Then this conversation is over,” and slam the receiver down before the tears came.
After you stopped taking his calls altogether, Steve resorted to climbing up to your window, hoping you’d be more willing to talk if you saw that being away from you was tearing him apart. You’d hear the familiar three taps on your window near midnight, and your eyes would snap open in the darkness; you’d stop breathing for a minute, waiting, hoping he’d take the hint and leave. They’d come again, but you just couldn’t bring yourself to let him in, no matter how much it killed you knowing he was outside, probably with a disappointed, heartbroken expression because his grapevine wasn’t long enough to cover the distance between you two. He lied to you, remember? He kept things from you. He hurt you. He doesn’t deserve to be let in; you’d tell yourself to stop yourself from giving in.
This went on for the first week.
While you were sad over the breakup, a bigger part of you was just angry. Whatever this secret was had cost you the best thing in your life. You deserved to know what it was. So for that first week, you focused all your energy on getting answers, obsessed over it, listening to Joyce’s calls sneakily, trying to figure out what she was talking about. When that failed to get you any answers, you resorted to cornering people.
Steve had said your brothers and your mom were in on it, so you resorted to questioning them. Your first target: Will.
You planned a movie night with him, as you two used to do when he was younger, before he went missing. Beetlejuice was both of your all-time favourite movie, and you used to watch it at least twice a month when he was younger. So, you asked him to watch it with you one night. He was super excited and had enthusiastically accepted your offer.
You made popcorn for the both of you, bought tons of candy: Twizzlers, Three Musketeers bars, chocolate-covered almonds, gummy bears, basically all the confectionery sold at Melvald’s. Also pizza in case you weren’t adequately nauseated by the end of the night. You two were going to go to bed feeling sick to your stomachs, for sure. You smiled at the thought. It would be just like the old days.
Will came in excitedly, plopped down on the couch, already snacking from the bowl of popcorn. You looked at him and realised that in the three years since the two of you had done this, Will hadn’t changed at all. Personality-wise, obviously. Physically, he looked like a different person. Older than a 15-year-old should be, you thought to yourself, as if he had faced some unimaginable trauma in his short life that had aged him at an accelerated pace.
Once again, you wondered what exactly had happened when Will went missing. What had happened that your baby brother looked and acted more mature than a boy his age should, that your mother had stopped being a mother to you, focusing almost all of her energy on Will and the remaining on Jonathan? However, he was still quiet and docile as ever, never wanting to be a bother, always polite and mannerly, so unlike the group of heathens he hung out with. You had always loved that about him.
You settled next to him with a smile, offering him the bowl of popcorn. The movie started in the background, but you weren’t really paying attention to it. Your mind was too preoccupied with ways to question him without having him run away.
You cleared your throat. “Steve and I broke up,” you started quietly.
He turned to look at you, an empathetic sadness on his face. He mumbled, looking down at his lap with his lips pressed together. “I’m sorry about that. It must suck.”
“Yeah,” you whispered. “I really liked him.” You looked off distractedly, eyes slightly misting over as you let the pain of the breakup fully wash over you for the first time that week.
“...why did you break up?” He turned to look at you.
You shook your head, swallowing before answering. “Because he was keeping things from me. Things that he said I couldn’t know about because they’re dangerous and life-threatening,” you looked at his face for any reaction to that.
“Oh,” was all he muttered.
So you pushed further. “And he said that you and Jonathan and Mom are somehow part of it?”
Will sucked in a sharp breath. “I-I don't know why he would say that,” he turned his face away, eyes trained on the TV.
“So it's not true?” you questioned, eyebrows raised in curiosity. You could see him getting more and more nervous, bottom lip caught between his teeth as he scratched at his thumb absently in his lap. You were losing him. When he didn’t respond for a while, you called softly. “Will?”
He looked scared then, as if he had said something he shouldn’t have, calculating every word in his head before he uttered another. “I-I have to go,” he mumbled, getting up frantically from the couch before you could stop him and running out of the house.
You watched as the front door slammed shut, wanting to call out to him, to ask what had happened, but knew it was useless. He wasn’t going to tell you. He wasn’t allowed to tell you, you realized. You huffed in irritation. If Will wouldn’t give you any answers, your next best bet was Jonathan.
He was basically never at home, always either out with Nancy or clicking photos to build his portfolio. It was difficult to catch him, so when the opportunity presented itself, you didn’t waste time snatching it up. He was by the front door, tying his shoes, his usual cross-body camera bag hanging by his side as he was kneeling down.
“Where are you going?” you asked detachedly, approaching him from behind.
He yelped in surprise, turning to look at you with wide eyes. “Jesus, n/n,” he muttered before turning back. You repeated your question when he didn’t respond. “Just going to see Nance,” he responded nonchalantly without looking at you.
“Oh,” you hummed, walking closer slowly. “You two up to something you shouldn’t be?”
He had turned towards you then with a perplexed expression. “What?”
You shrugged. “You’ve been going to see her an awful lot lately.”
Jonathan stood up, adjusting his bag, and turned to face you. “Well, yeah, she’s my girlfriend.”
You nodded. “I know. Just making sure you two haven’t…I don’t know, gotten yourselves mixed up in something dangerous,” you tried to sound cool, but you watched his face closely for any reactions, any hint that he gets what you’re talking about.
He sighed. “Even if we did, it's none of your concern,” he rolled his eyes and walked out.
You stood there for a second, staring at the door that had just slammed shut. That hurt, honestly. Having him just dismiss you like that. But you couldn’t say you didn’t see that coming. It had been your whole family’s attitude for a while now. You dragged your hands down your face, sighing tiredly. You were nowhere close to getting answers, and the fight was physically leaving you now. One last try, you decided, before you allowed yourself to fall apart. Another person who could maybe give you answers now was Robin.
You and Robin had been best friends since middle school, and now, as a bonus, she was working with Steve at Family Video. You knew they were close. Hell, Robin was how you and Steve met when they worked together at Scoops Ahoy. Surely she’d be able to tell you if he had been acting suspiciously there too, if there were sketchy people who were coming to see him, anything that would hint at whatever the mess was that your family and Steve had gotten themselves into.
On Friday, you dialed Robin’s home phone number. Her shift didn’t start until 12 PM, if you remembered correctly, so she should be available to speak. It was only 10 AM right now. After a few rings, she picked up.
“Hello?”
“Robin!” You grinned for the first time in ages.
“Y/n! I haven’t heard from you in so long! How are you doing? I heard about the breakup; I’m so sorry. Steve is a dingus! I told him not to mess it up with you; otherwise, I’d have him by the balls,” she rambled.
You only smiled harder the more she talked. You loved her capacity to ramble, but you especially appreciated it today. After feeling so alone and lonely for the past few days, it was a major relief to hear a voice that wasn’t shunning you. Moreover, Robin had always had that effect. Her hyperactivity seemed like a ray of sunshine in your darkest hours. After all, you called her your best friend for a reason.
“Yeah,” you chuckled softly. “He is an idiot.”
“Totally, babe! Don’t you blame yourself for a second!”
You smiled to yourself. “Hey, listen, can I ask you something?”
“Yeah, go ahead.”
You paused for a second, considering how best to phrase it. “H-has Steve been acting suspicious lately?”
“What do you mean?” she asked confusedly.
“I mean-” you shrugged. “I don’t know, like are there any sketchy people coming in to see him or he’s been acting shady or keeping things from you?”
Robin stayed silent for a moment as if mulling it over. “No, nothing of the sort. Why?”
You sighed, leaning against the wall while you twirled the wire anxiously between your fingers. “Well, he said there were just some things he couldn’t tell me because they were dangerous and life-threatening and he wanted to keep me safe. I said that it wasn’t his decision to make and then he said he promised my mom something. I asked him what he meant by that, but he wouldn’t tell me.”
“...oh.”
Your brows furrowed, dread pooling in your chest. That wasn’t how the normal Robin would respond. She’d be cussing him out normally, telling him he was an idiot and didn’t know his place if he was colluding with your mom.
Your eyes narrowed at her tone. “Robin?” you asked suspiciously.
“Yes?” she answered too quickly, sounding nervous.
“You wouldn’t happen to know what he was talking about, would you?”
She sputtered. “What? No, of course not. It's probably some popular people stuff.”
“Robin, don’t lie to me,” your voice took a warning tone. “If you know something, as my best friend, you’re obligated to tell me.”
“Uh, have to get to work; talk to you later!” she said quickly and ended the call.
“ROBIN!” you shouted once, but the line was already dead.
You slammed the receiver down in pure anger. Your best friend, the one person who was supposed to be on your side, was also hiding things from you. Was there anyone left on your side anymore? You don’t know if the cracking sound had come from how hard you had slammed the phone down or from your chest, because your heart definitely felt like it was breaking all over again.
A fresh wave of helplessness washed over you as you realised you truly had no one left whom you could trust to tell you the truth. It was all making you feel crazy. You knew you weren’t chasing after nothing given all their sketchy, avoidant behaviour, but it was driving you mad why they wouldn’t just tell you. Did they not trust you to keep it quiet? Were you too stupid to be involved in it?
You sighed tiredly. Maybe it was all bullshit anyway. Why were you trying so hard to figure out whatever this secret was? If they all wanted to hide from you, fine. They could all fuck off.
All you wanted to do was to crawl into bed and wallow in self-pity. There was nobody left to ask. You weren’t in favour of asking your mother. The woman who had successfully avoided parenting for the past three years would surely avoid a conversation effortlessly. It was evident from the conversation with Will that they were clearly told not to spill anything to you, so why bother trying?
A sudden wave of exhaustion washed over you and you stumbled a little, catching yourself on the wall at the last second. Your head was spinning. How long had it been since you’d eaten? Did it matter? You decided to just head into your room and climb under the covers. Trivial matters like eating could wait until after you took a nap or something.
You fell asleep in a blink, and the next morning, you were too tired to get out of bed. In the afternoon, you debated getting up to eat, but the kitchen was too far away. By dinner time, the growling in your stomach had disappeared on its own, so there was no point in getting out of bed.
You had tried to be okay after the breakup, pretending everything was fine, and focusing all of your energy on figuring out this secret. But it was like your body sensed something was amiss. So even when you forced your mind to focus elsewhere, your body had protested by quashing your appetite, being constantly fidgety, subconsciously reaching out to the empty space next to you on the bed, and your heart skipping a beat every time the phone rang or there was a knock on the door, hoping for Steve to walk through. To tell you that it was alright, that you weren't crazy and there was nothing wrong with you.
But that wasn't happening, obviously.
Eventually, you gave up forcing yourself to be okay. You’d have to deal with this breakup the old-fashioned way: locking yourself in your room, playing sad music, and crying till you physically couldn’t produce more tears.
At least there was ice cream in the process somewhere.
You noticed Joyce acting differently towards you during that second week. She seemed more caring than usual, greeting you with a good morning if you came out of your room, informing you before leaving for work. She hadn’t shown such consideration in at least three years. But you were heartbroken and hurting, so the care wasn’t unwelcome. Once, you had even broken down in front of her, crying about how much you loved Steve and missed him. “Why don’t you get back together with him?” she had asked, and you had cried in response, “Because he lied to me. He keeps lying to me and hiding things from me.” She had simply responded with, “It’s probably for the best,” and you had known then that she knew why you two separated.
Of course she did. She and Steve were, after all, in this bullshit secret society together. Her care was not for you. It was for Steve.
It was confirmed when she said, “You made a mistake breaking up with him. He’s a good kid,” the next day, to which you had rolled your eyes while walking away and grumbled a quiet, “Everyone but me is a good kid to you,” under your breath. It all suddenly made sense to you: why she had been saying good morning and interacting more than normal. She was baiting you into a conversation with her to steer it towards Steve, so she could somehow get you to get back together with him. You appreciated the sentiment. You only wished it had come from love for you, not your ex-boyfriend.
The entire week went by with you holed up in your room, barely eating, barely sleeping, abundantly crying, definitely wallowing. You decided something had to change after a week of that. Nobody else could be held responsible for your happiness; you’d simply have to do it yourself.
Friday night, the house was empty once again. Everyone was out, and you hadn’t bothered asking them where they were going. Ever since your argument with Steve, none of them could meet your eyes, always talking to you with their gazes elsewhere and giving vague, halfhearted responses to your inquiries. They all obviously saw how much you were hurting, why you two had broken up, and still none of them had the guts to just spill it. You didn’t have enough fight left in you to pressure any of them for answers anymore. If they wanted to exclude you, so be it. They could fuck off. Steve could fuck off. Robin could fuck off.
You didn’t give two shits where they were going or if they were coming back.
You took this opportunity to have a movie night for yourself. You turned off all the lights in the house except for the one in the kitchen, then settled on the couch with a bowl of popcorn. You played Beetlejuice since it was still queued up from the night you questioned Will. However, you were too distracted to actually pay attention to the movie. Having it on in the background did a decent job of keeping you from sinking too far deep into the pain, though. You couldn’t help but keep recalling the conversation from that night, the weeks leading up to it, wondering what exactly your brothers, mom, Steve, and Nancy had in common, what quality they all had that you seemingly lacked that kept you out of the loop.
You brought your knees to your chest as you recounted everything while snacking from the bowl sitting next to you. Your eyes, which were trained on the TV, snapped up when you noticed the kitchen light flickering to your right, plunging the living room into and out of darkness. You groaned to yourself. The bulb was probably about to go out. You sighed, turning your attention back to the movie.
But the light kept flickering, a faint, constant buzzing coming from the kitchen. Finally, it got on your nerves.
You got up from the sofa and went to the kitchen to turn the light off, carrying the popcorn bowl with you absentmindedly. Just then, the front door burst open, blasted off its hinges. You turned with wide eyes just in time to see the giant, grey, slimy creature walking towards you. It had no eyes and freakishly long limbs. Its mouth opened up like a disturbing flower showing rows upon rows of teeth covering every single spot in the disturbing, gaping chasm. You stood rooted in the spot, frozen in fear as you struggled to process the sight before you. It slowly stalked towards you and you trembled in fear, not breathing. It wasn’t until the popcorn bowl slipped from your grip and smashed to the ground tha you broke out of your stupor. It let out the most animalistic sound you had ever heard. You screamed at the top of your lungs when it started charging towards you. You sprinted in the opposite direction, towards your room, heart beating out of your chest, tearing up from the fear and adrenaline coursing through you.
I’m gonna die, I’m gonna die, I’m gonna die, I’m gonna die, was all that played in your head as you ran into your room and slammed the door shut, locking it. You frantically looked around the room for anything that could be used as a weapon and landed on the mirror propped against the wall. You pushed the mirror to the floor and watched it get smashed to bits, then picked up one of the big shards, gripping it so tight it was cutting into your hand. You raised it over your head, standing a bit back from the door, bracing for that thing to barge in.
Your heart pounded in your chest, trying to free itself somehow from the prison of your chest and escape the fate that awaited it. That was all you could hear. It was ironic, you realised, that your death would come to collect you while you were alone, nobody around to care or help or try to save you. For the longest time, you had imagined it would be that way. Made peace with it. And then Steve had happened, and you had thought maybe not. Maybe there’d be someone to hold your hand, after all.
You were wrong.
You gasped as something heavy threw itself against your door, over and over. It was right outside your door. You readied your stance and took a deep breath. You refused to go down without a fight. The door to your room blasted open, splinters flying everywhere, and there the creature stood.
“Stay back,” you shouted, backing up slowly. It roared before charging towards you. You ran towards it, stabbing it with the shard over and over and over with all the energy and strength your body could muster, screaming as you did. Its blood squirted all over you the more you stabbed it, splashing all over your clothes and your face. The creature stumbled as you kept barraging it with the shard. You didn’t notice when your own blood had started to drip down your arm from how hard you were gripping it, until you winced from how deeply it cut into your palm.
The creature roared in pain before it raised one of its hands. Sharp claws dug into your side, and you gasped as pain, hot and blinding, shot through your side. Its other arm raised, and its claws found your neck, slashing across it. You choked as the breath was snatched from your throat, hands automatically flying up to your neck. You pulled your hand back to see it dripping with blood. The shard slipped from your grip, and you stumbled to the ground. The room was spinning violently, the ground was pulled from under your feet, and there was a loud ringing in your ears. Black dots started dancing in your vision, and you started hallucinating.
You started hallucinating Steve. He was there. He looked ridiculously good. He also looked angry, and he was swinging at the creature with what looked like a baseball bat with nails hammered into it. You heard the creature's ugly shrieks of pain, and you smiled to yourself quietly. Goodbye, Stevie, you thought to yourself.
And then everything went black.
You woke up slowly, a white ceiling slowly coming into your view as you roused. The first thing you noticed was that there was pain…everywhere. You couldn’t pin it down to one place. Next thing you noticed was that there was something on your face. A something clear covering your nose and mouth. There was a beeping to your left. A constant, steady, annoying, and persistent sound that was making your pounding headache worse. You were in a hospital, you realised. You had lived somehow. Had that not been a hallucination? You thought to yourself. Was Steve really there? And that's when you noticed that there was something in your hand. You squeezed it once, trying to determine what it was.
A hand. Warm and big and calloused and familiar. And it squeezed back.
“Hey, baby,” you heard that familiar, soft voice from beside you.
Steve.
You turned your head slowly to see him, eyes squinting to adjust to the bright lights of the room. He was leaning forward in a small, wooden chair, hair looking annoyingly good still. His face, however, looked exhausted. There were bags under his eyes, cuts on his eyebrow, lip, and cheek, and he looked pale like he hadn’t slept or eaten properly in days.
“S-” you tried to say but started coughing immediately. Your throat was too dry.
“Easy there,” he whispered soothingly, thumb brushing your knuckles. “Water?”
When you nodded, Steve immediately stood up. He gently slid the oxygen mask off your face, then put his hand under your head to help you drink as he held the glass to your lips while you slowly drank from it. Afterwards, you squeezed his hand in gratitude.
You cleared your throat and tried again. “What happened?” you croaked.
“You passed out,” he whispered, stroking your hair back from your forehead. His hand rested on your head, his thumb gently stroking back and forth on your forehead. It helped more than you’d like to admit because, as much as it sucked, you were scared. Some scary, too-many-toothed, pitcher plant looking creature had attacked you, and the last thing you remembered was being slashed on your abdomen and neck, and now you were waking up in a hospital hooked to wires.
You looked at his face for a second, tears welling in your eyes as you recalled the fear from seeing that thing. “What was that?” you whispered, voice cracking. “W-why did it come after me?” the tears were threatening to spill over. The beeping from the heart monitor quickened its pace as you recalled the horrifying event.
“Hey, hey, it's okay, you’re safe now,” he murmured reassuringly. “I’ve got you. It can’t hurt you anymore. I killed it,” he assured you. He kept stroking your hair and murmuring soft assurances to you until your heart rate went back to normal.
You sniffled quietly, looking to him expectantly. Steve sighed, looking away for a second as if debating whether to tell you or not. In the end, he relented. “It's called a demogorgon.”
You furrowed your brows. “Like the thing from Dungeons & Dragons?”
Steve chuckled humourlessly. “Exactly like that.”
“But how’s that possible? It's a game,” you protested weakly.
Steve moved his hand from your forehead to your shoulder, rubbing soothingly. “Look, there’s a lot you don’t know. We thought not telling you would keep you safe, but you ended up getting hurt anyway. So, I promise you, once you get out of here, I’m going to tell you everything and answer all of your questions. But for now, just focus on getting better, okay?”
“Why did it come after me?” you asked.
Steve shook his head, running a hand through his hair. “We don’t know.” He paused for a minute, simply taking you in. “You were so brave though, fighting it off with just a shard of glass like that.”
He caressed your cheek lovingly, and you smiled imperceptibly. “Thanks,” you whispered.
You wanted to ask more questions, but you were too tired, your head spinning and pounding too much at the moment to voice all your queries. One stayed, however.
“I-is my mom here?” you asked quietly.
Steve nodded. “They went to the cafeteria to get some food. We’ve all been here a while.”
“How long?” you asked.
Steve inhaled deeply. “You’ve been out for about 4 days,” he responded quietly.
Your head started spinning even more. Four whole days? You looked at Steve again, taking in his haggard appearance, and asked, “Have you been here this entire time?”
“Of course,” Steve looked at you as if you were crazy for even asking the question. “Where else would I be?”
“We broke up,” you whispered as if that explained it.
Steve swallowed, looking away. “Doesn’t mean I stopped loving you.”
You were discharged the next day. You could barely walk due to the immense pain in your side and neck, despite the painkillers, and the doctors had recommended you not speak a lot due to the damage to your vocal cords in the attack. If you must, though, they said you should try to only whisper to avoid risking permanent damage to your vocal cords. They said you should be able to talk properly in about a month, but until then, the less you talked, the better.
Steve helped you into your mother's car, more bandage than skin on your body. There were bandages wrapped around the entirety of your torso, around your neck, and around your hand where the shard of glass had dug into your palm. You’d ended up getting stitches everywhere, so movement was also pretty restricted for the next little bit. Yet you weren’t going home. You were going straight to the Wheelers’ house to get the answers you wanted. Your mom had not been in favour of putting all that strain on you just today, but you had argued that after almost losing your life, you deserved to know what exactly that thing was, where it came from, and why it wanted you. And so, she had relented.
You sat in the backseat with Will, sitting stiffly and awkwardly to avoid putting pressure on your wounds. Joyce drove, and Jonathan sat in the passenger seat quietly. The air was thick with guilt as if they were all silently blaming themselves for this incident, and a part of you wanted to blame them as well. Tell them that maybe, if they had just told you whenever this shit started that you wouldn’t have been in the house alone that night. That maybe, you could have gone with them, that you wouldn’t be Gauze-Girl right now. But you knew, deep down, that this wasn’t their fault. They were as shocked by this as you were; you could tell from their lack of sleep and fear-stricken faces when you had woken up. All three of them looked every bit as wrecked as Steve had, with the eye bags and dark circles and the pale skin.
“Are you feeling alright, honey?” Joyce kept asking every couple of minutes.
You only mutely nodded in response.
Will kept glancing at you every few seconds. You could tell he felt guilty for not telling you when you had asked about it. You gave him a small, tight-lipped smile when he looked at you to let him know you weren’t mad at him. He leaned his head against your shoulder in a silent display of support, and your heart squeezed in your chest. You couldn’t remember the last time you even had a proper conversation with him, and you felt like a shitty sister for not being there for him. After all, going missing for a week had to have left some scars that maybe you could have helped with. Which you now knew was connected to this. This fucked up world where such monsters existed, and your baby brother had gone missing in such a place at 12 years old.
You put your arm around his shoulders slowly, careful of your injuries, squeezing his arm gently. “I’m going to be fine,” you whispered to him.
He nodded. “Yeah, you will be.”
When you got there, Steve, who had been trailing in his beamer behind your mom's car, and Jonathan together helped you get out of the car carefully and inside the house.
At the Wheelers’ house, everyone was there, waiting for you: Nancy and Mike, of course, all of Will’s friends, so Lucas, Dustin, and Max. Lucas’ little sister, Erica, Robin, Hopper (“God, is there anyone who isn’t in this shit?” you thought), and a girl whom you didn’t recognize. Her head was shaved, and she dressed as if still learning how clothes work.
“Eleven,” she had introduced herself.
You averted your gaze from everyone else's. You didn’t want to see the looks of pity they kept sending you.
“Come sit,” Nancy said with a kind smile while gesturing to the sofa.
Steve sat next to you, keeping your hand in his for support while everyone else settled in front of you.
“We’re going to explain everything to you. From the beginning,” Nancy stated.
And so the next couple of hours were spent with them explaining everything. Starting with Will’s disappearance and how he technically wasn’t in Hawkins at all but an Upside Down version of it (you had looked to Will in horror, tears welling in your eyes, and he had nodded in confirmation), how Eleven was telekinetic and connected to the Upside Down (you noted how she stuck close to Mike), how there were these monsters that they’d dubbed Demogorgons who were like the soldiers of the Upside Down and the ring master was something called the Mind Flayer and they were battling his army general named Vecna at the moment, who was actually 001 and was raised in the same facility as Eleven.
It all sounded like the most psychedelic story you’d ever heard, and you briefly considered asking if their dealer was supplying them authentic shit because what the hell were they talking about? But then the image of the creature – the Demogorgon – flashed in front of your eyes once again and you stayed quiet. You believed every word they said. And if there was any doubt left in your mind, it vanished the second Eleven made a pen hover midair with just her mind.
Consider yourself converted to worship the Lord and Saviour of this cult: Eleven.
“So,” Robin started. “Any questions?”
Steve’s still held onto your hand, his thumb tenderly gliding over your knuckles. You were obviously struggling to process everything. This was a lot to take in, so you were grateful for his support, regardless of how upset you were with him for keeping all of this from you. That was a later problem, though.
“I think I might need a lorazepam,” you mumbled, earning a quiet snort from Steve, who was the only one who could hear you.
Joyce leaned forward. “Look, honey, I know this is a lot to take in, but please, know that just because you all of this now doesn’t mean you have to help us or be a part of fighting these monsters. I have been trying to keep you safe from all of this because it’s incredibly dangerous and I didn’t want your life to be ruined because of this.”
“Of course I want to help,” you whispered.
Steve said it louder for you.
“I’m just disappointed that I was kept out of it for so long. I mean, Will is my brother, too. I was scared of losing him, too. Hell, my boyfriend-” you cut yourself off. “Ex-boyfriend,” you corrected and felt Steve’s body freeze up. “Is a part of it. My best friend,” you looked at Robin, “is a part of it. My mother is a part of it; both my brothers are a part of it,” you spoke in exasperation, still keeping your voice quiet.
Steve obediently relayed every word, eyes downcast as he felt the meaning and horror of your words wash over him.
“How did you guys expect me to live after you all died risking your lives to save Hawkins?” you questioned, voice growing louder. “How did you expect me to continue after having quite literally no one left?” You felt yourself growing emotional, your throat closing up. You cleared your throat, collecting yourself before continuing. “I understand that this is very hard for all of you considering you’ve been doing all the fighting so far, but did none of you ever think about me? About how your deaths would be justified to me?” you sniffled. “And-and I would have to live with the knowledge that maybe I could have done something to help. At the very least I could have fucking been there when you died!”
“I could tell you one last time that I love you, but no! You were all okay with taking that chance away from me because who cares about me, right? All the people you love are around you already.” Your voice was rising now, and Steve quieted down.
“Baby, please, keep your voice down,” your mom tried, but you ignored her.
Your hand slipped from his as you stood up on shaky legs. “Because what do you care, Mom, when the two kids you actually want would be there when you died? Because you don’t care enough to say goodbye to me.”
She looked so utterly hurt at that, tears freely running down her cheeks as she brought her hands up to her mouth to muffle the sounds.
You knew, to some degree, that you were sounding selfish. That you were making this about yourself, even when it wasn’t necessarily. But how could it not be when you were quite literally the only person in your group who didn’t know?
Steve, Robin, Jonathan, and Will were crying now too, as well as you, but you wiped your tears angrily.
“You were okay with leaving me,” you stated as your face crumpled and you started sobbing. “You left me 3 years ago. You left me all alone.”
These words were directed at your family, and they knew. Joyce sprang up at once, wrapping her arms around you tightly. You didn’t care about your injuries as you let yourself be held by your mom in three whole years.
“I’m sorry, baby. I’m so, so sorry,” she cried. “I was only trying to protect you,” she kept whispering while stroking your hair.
You shook your head, burying your face in her shoulder. “You left me alone. I thought you just didn’t want to be my mother anymore. That I’d done something wrong and you decided I wasn’t your daughter anymore.”
She kept hugging you and crying with you. The hug was soon joined by both of your brothers, who were also crying and profusely apologizing, and the three of you were so wrapped up in this that you didn’t realise when the others quietly exited the living room to give you more privacy.
Afterwards, you three stayed in the living room and talked some more about how you have been feeling like an afterthought to your family, how you weren’t their sister anymore, just a roommate, and they apologized, explained themselves, and promised to do better. After some more conversations about the Upside Down and clarifications, the three of you had headed home.
It seemed that in the time you had been passed out in the hospital, someone had come home and cleaned up the mess in your room. There were no signs of any struggle here, no broken mirror shards on the floor, no blood. Only the strong scent of bleach and the space left on your wall to remind you of the worst experience of your life. You were beyond happy to lie down in your bed after a long day of craziness and emotional taxing.
You didn’t realise when you fell asleep, but you woke up a few hours later. It was completely dark outside now, the house silent, meaning everyone had gone to bed. You got out of the room, heading to the kitchen to grab some water. Your steps were wobbly, and you had to keep your uninjured hand on the wall so you wouldn’t fall. Afterwards, you came back to your room and just sat on the bed, breathing deeply to abate the pain.
The familiar three taps on the window came again. You knew who it was, of course, and this time, opening the window didn’t feel like such a difficult decision. Knowing everything you did now, you understood, on Steve’s part, why he had chosen to keep all the information from you. You got up from the bed, movements incredibly slow.
Steve climbed inside your room, not as tightly wound as the last time he climbed through your window, but way more hesitant to touch you. Whether that was because of your wounds or earlier today, you didn’t know.
“Ex-boyfriend,” you had called him earlier today, and it had hurt enough to nearly bring him to tears.
“Hi, doll,” he whispered. “Just-uh, just wanted to see how you were doing.” He kept his hands in fists by his sides as if he had to physically hold himself back from reaching out to you. Your heart hurt at that realisation. Your body desperately craved his touch, especially in its weakened state.
“I’m horrible,” you responded equally quietly, and he immediately got worried.
“What can I do? Did you have your meds? Lie down, why are you standing?” he started frantically, moving closer, guiding you to the bed.
“I’m fine, Stevie, don’t worry,” you assured him, chuckling softly. “I only meant that my head is spinning from everything I learned today,” and he took a breath of relief.
You sat back down on the edge of your bed, right back where you two started. A silence fell over the room, thick with both of you having a million and one things to say but not nearly enough words in your dictionary to articulate them.
Finally, you broke the silence. “I see why you kept all that from me.”
“You do?” he whispered.
You nodded, looking down and fidgeting with your fingers. “I mean, my issues still made it hurt a lot, and I’m not happy that you kept it from me. But I get that you wanted to protect me. I would have done the same thing if I were in your place.”
Steve breathed a massive sigh of relief. He knelt in front of you, taking your hands in his.
“I am so, so sorry for keeping things from you, doll. I just couldn’t stand the thought of anything happening to you. I’d never forgive myself. I wouldn’t be able to live,” he pleaded.
“Well, that didn’t work out too well,” you joked.
Steve snorted softly, nodding in agreement. “Yeah, tell me about it.” You smiled slightly in response at your predicament. It was funny how they all went through so much to keep you safe. They hadn’t meant to hurt you; you knew that now. But you had ended up getting hurt anyway, both from their metaphorical and literal monsters.
“Please give me another chance,” he whispered.
You looked at him for a moment, considering it. “Promise to never keep things from me?”
He nodded immediately. “I promise, baby. Never keeping things from you. It only ever got me close to losing you, and I can’t have that.”
You swallowed, nodding finally.
His eyes widened at that. “So we can try again?”
You nodded with a small smile. “Yeah, we can.”
Steve grinned widely, sitting next to you on the bed and pulling you into a kiss. You happily kissed back, letting your entire body sink into it. Finally, all that accumulated pain in your chest from a Steve Harrington deficiency was dissipating, and you were more than happy to let it go.
“No more secrets,” he mumbled against your lips. “None at all.” He kissed you again.
When you two finally pulled away, Steve mumbled, “By the way, in the spirit of not keeping secrets, I’m wearing SpongeBob underwear.”
You burst into laughter immediately, swatting his chest. “You are an idiot, Steve Harrington.”
Steve grinned proudly, bringing the hand that swatted his chest up to his lips. “And you’re beautiful, Y/n Byers.”
You looked at him with a smitten smile for a second, and then he broke the silence again. “So, in the spirit of not keeping secrets, what about you?” he asked cheesily.
“Ew, Steve,” you shoved him away, laughing.
He pressed one last kiss to your forehead before going all mom mode on you, changing your bandages, giving you more painkillers, and adjusting blankets and pillows around you to make sure the pain was minimised as much as possible. At the end of the night, he lay down next to you, pulling you into his chest.
“I love you, doll,” he mumbled against your forehead.
“I love you, too, Stevie,” you responded. “Oh, by the way,” you pulled back a bit and reached onto your nightstand to grab the scrapbook. “Happy Anniversary.”
tags: @potion-keery @lili-tate @cciessuzi @keeryverse @jiniren @starrliyah @jorkingtodjo @padfoot9 @skkeletonns @sexyvixen7 @stoneyggirl2 @justdowntherabbithole @spideyphan @buckyscoolgf @bing72 @offbrandhandymanny @zithewarriorprincess @megaprincesscakes @flavorfullsteve @kurtsw7rld96 @swiftie-4-lifes-stuff @ninauh @hisparentsgallerryy @ladybugs96













