Andreil

even broken hearts may have their doubts by exyjunkies (T | Incomplete | 7/?)

Neil says no to Andrew, who takes it a lot harder than he wants to.

[Breakup AU, Post-TKM | Updates (supposedly) every Sunday]

slipping in and out by coveryoureyes (T | Incomplete | 4/?)

Neil was just the newest Alex, Stefan, Chris. Neil had arrived with dyed hair, false eyes, and an American accent. ‘Neil’ was a skin he’d slipped on as easily as ‘James’ in England or ‘Jacques’ in Montreal. He wasn’t anyone, really. ‘Abram’ might be the common denominator, maybe the neutral label for the conundrum of a human he’d always been, but even that person didn’t exist.

Abram didn’t know if he had ever really existed.

where did we go wrong by lilypaws (G | 560 | 1/1)

It doesn’t matter who the guy was. What mattered was that Neil had done it. That Neil had betrayed Andrew and destroyed everything they had. What mattered was that he broke both their hearts and there was no going back.

only by jemejem (G | 10,212 | 3/3)

There’s only so much you can do.

paralyzed by nnooorraa (G | 7,976 | 2/2)

He felt nothing. He was nothing. He had given the last bits and pieces he had left of himself to Neil a long time ago and now everything was gone.

//

The breakup fic literally no one asked for but that I wrote anyway

solivagant by playmaker (Not Rated | 1,902 | 1/1)

Some days, Neil was reminded that no matter how hard he tried to bleed the Wesninski from himself, he was still his fathers son, and Nathaniel Wesninski could burn down cities with the wildfires in his veins.

Series: Part 1 of liminal spaces

idfc by icyvanity (T | Incomplete | 1/?)

Andrew and Neil break up in the wake of Aaron's trial, and neither are handling it well.

Don't Let Me Go by EwDontTouchMe (Not Rated | 1,765 | 1/1)

All Andrew's life, he's been drowning. Every new obstacle life has thrown his way has only dragged him further below the surface. Neil was his first taste of blissful oxygen, and he wasn't ready to let him go.

shadows fill my mind up by drunklesbian (G | 1,136 | 1/1)

Neil hasn't seen Andrew in over three years. At least in person. He still watched every game he played since he transferred to another team; since the day he broke up with Neil. If one could call it a break up as they never established whether the thing between them was a relationship in first place.

Or: another one where Andrew calls things off with Neil and they haven't seen each other in over three years.

Series: Part 1 of i lost you not long ago

and i'm falling, falling into the deep end now by drunklesbian (G | 1,376 | 1/1)

companion fic to shadows fill my mind up

Or: another one where Andrew calls things off with Neil and they haven't seen each other in over three years. This time from Andrew's POV.

Series: Part 2 of i lost you not long ago

a phone booth i somehow stumbled into by fuzzballsheltiepants (G | 1,283 | 1/1)

I can’t take the silence. Those five words, written in Neil’s jagged scrawl.But silence was all he had left.

Secrets by yourwritersblock (tumblr fic)

Renison

sore-ring to cope by flybbfly (T | 5,810 | 1/1)

Far-future fic. Nicky and Erik are finally getting married, which means the Foxes are about to have a mini-reunion in Germany. That'd be great, except that Allison hasn't talked to Renee in nearly a year.

Jerejean

he promised. by lilaliacs (Not Rated | 914 | 1/1)

(Jeremy misses him.)

I Miss You by wheezyboys (Not Rated | 5,598 | 1/1)

"You’re supposed to break up with someone because you’re not in love with them. Not because you’re completely in love with them." — If I Stay

Nicky/Erik

Party boys don't get hurt by AgapantoBlu (M | 3,593 | 1/1)

In one reality, Nicky and Erik break up.

[...] At the airport, Erik kisses him one last time and Nicky smiles a tremulous thing before boarding. On his plane, he erases Erik’s number before the hostess asks him to turn his phone off.

Kevin/Thea

True, But Irrelevant by exyjunkies (T | Incomplete | 1/?)