#tabdee

Visiting A Sick Innovator – Shaykh Zayd Al-Madkhalee

Shaykh Zayd Al-Madkhalee said, “What is apparent to me in this issue [visiting a sick innovator who announces his innovation, calls to it and warns against Salafiyyah and Salafi scholars] is the permissibility of visiting him for whoever has knowledge of the Shariah (Islamic law).

Thus, his first priority for visiting him should be to extend advice to this sick [individual] using a good approach…

A Short Explanation Of The Principle “Whoever Does Not Make Tabdee Of An Innovator Is Themselves An Innovator” – Shaykh Abdul Muhsin Al-Abbaad

Shaykh Abdul Mohsin Al-Abbaad said, “There are people (Ahlu Bidah) whom their innovations are clear, they are far from the Sunnah and they are waging war against the Sunnah. The Sunnah is in a valley and they are in another valley! For such people, there is no doubt that whoever does not make tabdee* on them he is an innovator. As for people who are from Ahlu Sunnah and have fallen into an error…

Shaykh Ahmad Baazmool said, “…I said – today and always – that tabdee (declaring someone to be an innovator) is for the scholars, because tabdee is a description and a name which requires ijtihaad (scholarly research), and this is the concern of the scholars or the major students of knowledge whom the scholars consider to be in the first degrees of the ladder of the scholars. Ok? These are my…

Questioner: If one of the Shaikhs said about someone, ‘He is an innovator,’ is the student obliged to adopt this stance of calling that person an innovator? Or must he know why the person was called an innovator? Because this declaration of a person to be…

Tabdee is [only] for the Scholars &refuting falsehood is for the Scholars, students of knowledge & qualified -

This one says: “Now you have said that mistakes are not refuted except by the Scholars. And in a previous lecture – perhaps not in Kuwait – you said that these words are not correct.” So it is as if he is saying: “You contradict yourself.”

[Shaykh…