Why do you think that so many people ship StarCat?
I donât have any numbers on this, soIâm definitely just guessing, but StarKat to me has all of the usualfeatures of a standard creator-designated ship. The stories writtenby Brian Bendis and Sam Humphries desperately want readers to shipPeter Quill with Kitty Pryde, and Quill and Kitty are two characterswho lend themselves naturally towards that treatment anyway (Kittyhad already spent twenty years suffering in silence as the designatedgirlfriend of the X-Men; and following the increase of popularityheâs received from appearing in a movie, Quillâs comic book counterpart has been turned into a modernHollywood leading man).
And you can see with the language thatMarvel has used to promote the cosmic books of late (for example,âthe engagement of the galaxy [âŚ]!â, â#Starkat livesforever!â, âPeter Quill battles the Badoon, fights to savean orphanage, and still finds time for some flirting with KittyPrydeâbut itâs all in a dayâs work for the STAR-LORD!â)âcoupledwith all of the covers  emphasizing the two of them as together(for both the Star-Lord ongoing magazines, Guardians of theGalaxy itself, and in a number of the spin off and sidetitles)âthat editorial is invested in making sure that readersunderstand that this is a designated ship. Add to that the creatorsfrequently emphasizing Quill and Kittyâs status as a package romanticdeal rather than as individuals who can function without each other,and the soap opera tactics of the alleged romance itself (aborteddates; adrenaline fueled attraction; perpetual fear of cheating;breaking up over misunderstandings and a lack of trust; situationallyinappropriate crying, lots of crying, being strong in the face oflots of crying; the engagement, breakup, and subsequent secondengagement, with a looming third breakup inside of less than a yearof in-story time, etc.) and you have a forced atmosphere of âthisrelationship is a big dealâ and âwe want you to know that thisrelationship is very dynamic and interesting, a fertile playgroundfor creative fans.â The sophomoricway theyâre written together (rebellious attention seeking frat-boypickup artist with cool toys, and compassionate poorly-coordinatedingenue thatâs shy around men) further helps with establishingMarvelâs intended tone of âthis is a standard easily relatableromance, we invited you to please become invested with it.â
So I donât mean to make light of thefans who seriously enjoy Peter Quill with Kitty Pryde on its ownstorytelling merits, and I do absolutely believe that they exist, andjust want to throw that out there so it doesnât look like Iâm makingfun of them. I am gladtheyâre having fun, I mean. But regardlessâand to your questionâmypast experience in online fandom, and with comic book fandom inparticular, strongly suggests to me that the atmosphere that Marvelcreated just lent itself to shippersâ preference.
Thereare people who go with rare ships, people who go with alternateships, and people who go with the designated ships, and a lot oftimes what fans end up shipping has a lot more to do with theatmosphere of the fan spaces they end up in than what the sourcematerial basis for the relationship is. Â That thereâs so littlesubstance to the relationship, to the point that we donât even know(as readers) why they like each other, is itâs own strength in fandomcontexts where fans are going to have more fun making up their ownanswers anyway.
So inthe end, I think Marvelâthrough a range of factors both intentionaland completely accidentalâ made it very easy for casual fans topicture Quill and Kitty together as a romantic pairing, and thenlucked out with the resulting subset of X-Men/Cosmic fandom not being overly hostile tonewcomers.