I like what you said about Apollo and Reyna helping each other. They're my number one ship and I hope they become cannon. How do you feel about this ship? Are they good for each other ? Do you think it has the chance to become cannon?
Sorry for taking so long to answer btw. I already had a draft talking about this very thing and I had to rewrite it in a way that not only answers your questions but also gives my insight into the ship and the fandomâs (overexaggerated) reactions, if you donât mind. You wanted my opinion, so I had to make sure itâs detailed enough and conveyed everything I had in mind. I wanted to write a post about these two for so long after all. I hope itâs a satisfying answer ^^
So here is my draft (with some modifications) :
Warning : donât read this if this ship is your utlimate NOTP and/or cannot handle different opinions.
So, Iâve seen a few posts talking about how bad and horrible this pairing is and what I noticed is that it gets far more hate than it does deserve. It actually has so much potential and they both can be GREAT for each other even without overlooking the entire mortal/god issue. You might dislike what Iâll say, but Iâll say it anyways. At first, I disliked the ship with a burning passion too, but my fav character x my fav god appealed to me later on.
So, the first thing a certain part of the fandom seems to believe in is that Apollo, being bi, âis better off with guysâ which is blatant bi erasure, guys. Apollo x Any-mortal-guy-he-had-the-slightest-crush-on doesnât steer any outrage, their âmortalityâ takes the backseat and no one seems to mind. Yet the moment heâs shipped with a girl, this part of the fandom seems to *loudly* disagree. I really get it, LGBTQ+ rep is very much needed, and Iâm tired of heteronormativity just as much as the next person, but guys, this is not âstraight repâ. Dating someone of the opposite gender doesnât suddenly turn the bisexual part involved âstraightâ. Bisexuals have every right to date any of the two (or more) genders (or lack thereof) they feel attracted to. Bisexual guys are a rare species in fiction, even rarer than bi girls, yet once we have one, we turn him gay. This is not different from the usual belief that bi girls âchoose campsâ at some point. But guess what? There is no camp to choose from. Apollo is and remains as bi as he was in all 3 previous book and will date the person he feels attracted to, regardless of their gender. Sorry if this came off as rude or preachy, but being bi myself, I just couldnât help it.
The second thing held against the ship is Apolloâs godhood. Itâs believed that once he goes back to Olympus, heâll return to his frivolous ways⌠Seriously? After all the emotional maturation he went through in the last book? After all the whining he does over Daphne and Hyacinthus? This guy literally craves being loved and actually deserves it. And also, I do not think Reyna needs/craves an everlasting love story, or a promise of permanence alltogether. And no, I do NOT want her to face heartbreak or be used by a god for a few months and then thrown away. On the contrary, I believe sheâll get the most âseriousâ and emotionally poignant relationship in the entire books, BUT, not in the way most canon ships are. The fandomâs main problem with the relationship is that many seem to need each and every character to get into a happily-ever-after everlasting relationship that ride into the sunset, grow old and live forever together in elysium. They canât stand seeing characters break up, much less characters entering relationships that have a slight âforbiddenâ flair, forbidden as in âNot gonna last forever, people, thatâs some seriously rocky road youâre stepping inâ. But what most forget is that Reyna is NOT another Annabeth. Her fatal flaw is probably independance imo. And hey, even in case she wishes for a long-term relationship, she does not seem to be the overly possessive and jealous type. You catch my drift right (and my craving for poly -or just an open relationship- rep) ? And you know, relationship or not, Reyna will always be Reyna. Sheâs not a princess in need of a prince, sheâs a queen. Sheâs so aptly named. Sheâs complete all by herself. But guess what? She has the right to wish for a relationship, lasting or not. A relationship wonât wonât change her core or the way she is.
Now onto Venusâ prophecy. Reynaâs heart healing is gonna be a tough process. It wonât be through âsomeone saving/protecting herâ but through being heard and helped and loads of sharing and caring and advice. And why tf not have the literal god of healing help her? Whyyy? xD
The third issue is mortality⌠huh? sorry? This issue is ridiculous for it can be mended through Reyna becoming immortal which is, mark my word, so going to happen because of Bellonaâs bloodline prophecy. Reyna is an even better goddess than the actual divinities. She has all the required qualities, kindness, authority, bravery, brains, beauty, maturity, leadership, diplomatic skills. She has values the gods seem to lack of. And guys, thatâs REYNA weâre talking about. Rick respects her far too much to turn her into another Annabeth ((and before you ask, yes, I do have many things to say about the way Annabeth turned in HoO)). I mean, heâs the one who said that sheâs her own better half and he only ever speaks highly of her. Do you really think he left her relationship in last only to put her into another I-just-had-to-pair-everyone pairing like some other canon couples I wonât even bother to state?  If anything, itâll be the âpower coupleâ of the whole series.. And honestly, it was pretty obvious sheâll end up with someone immortal or at least Someone "Important". Venus did not appear in person to give her a prophecy for her to end up with a legacy or a mortal. Meh. It was obvious (or so I hope) that her love story will be every bit as beautiful as..say, Psyche and Eros. And a god/mortal relationship is basically the entire sub-theme (or sub-plot name it as you please) of the books, yet never had one ever happened in-screen. So.. why not?
So to sum up these last few points, what Iâm really implying is that Reynaâs not seeking to crush on someone and feel butterflies, she seeks companionship. She needs something akin to a confidante, not that cheesy romance most of the canon couples seem to involve. And a hormonal 17 yo teen CANâT give her that, sorry. She needs, as stated in the prophecy, to HEAL her heart. She needs all the help she can get over her awful past, and grow into a better version of herself. Help in any shape or form. She deserves a happy ending, but her own ending involves her being happy in the first place, finding help, and a relationship is just going to be an external element contributing to that happiness, not the root of it. She deserves to be loved, adored, worshipped, and no, it doesnât mean sheâll sacrifice her independant self. Quite on the contrary, sheâs definitely one for being the âdominantâ of her relationship. Though I totally see why people wish for her to stay single. Relationships in MG/YA novels often involve females that unexpectedly turn from powerful role models to damsels in distress (this concerns hetero or heternormative pairings especially, not to say only.) which is frustrating and oh so wrong and itâs sole purpose is to stroke some very fragile masculine ego. So yeah, the fandom wanting her single is very understandable because after reading so many books were a relationship equates losing your strength and your independance, you unconsciously start to think that a relationship MEANS losing what makes you who you are to become another personâs subordinate. And hell, we have some examples in the Riordanverse, the most blatant being Percabeth (I know that Percy aka th masculine part is being subordinated and disrespected most of the time, which is just as wrong as the other way around, but some excrutiating âmanlyâ stereotypes start to show up in HoO), so why not change the grounds? Why not stop making romantic pursuits the most important thing ever to the point where EVEN staying single is a mere rebellion against it? Why not treat it like.. idk.. a freaking normal concept that happens every once in a while and thatâs all? Reyna dating someone is just that. Reyna dating someone. Not Reyna losing her identity. Not Reyna becoming someoneâs âhalfâ *cringes and shudders with disgust*. Am I drifting off-side again? Very much, yes. Now back to the actual topic. Oh.. Reynaâs type seems to be another âissueâ, right? Well guess what.. Reynaâs type is stated nowhere in the books. Headcanons =/= canon. Think about it, she was canonically attracted to two guys. Jason and Percy. And, hello, these two are everything but carbon copies of each other (I'm a Jercy shipper for a reason, buddy). They are exact opposites. Just because they both are heroic, loyal and âpowerfulâ does not mean they are alike. So here, if she was attracted to both, that means she has MORE than just a type. And even if Apollo isnât her type, thatâll only make it better. Because thatâs one very realistic message the readers would get. You donât have to end up with âyour typeâ, if you ever have one. Donât limit yourself to a few options when the world has so many different kinds of people to offer. Anyway, back to topic. Reyna is a not only a leader, she can also lend people her power. Sheâs like.. a human powerbase. And not only that, she can see/send emotions when sharing her strength with someone. Thatâs how she bonded with Nico in BoO. That means she sees the more emotional, inner side of people. Their emotions, how they actually feel, what they are like on the inside. Do you think a girl like her would be superficial and only focus on what appears on the outside? PfffffftâŚNow that Iâve talked enough about Reyna, letâs talk about Apollo. Mythologically speaking, he has been known to be ridiculously attracted to independant people. Cyrene is the one that reminds me the most of Reyna tbh, and she eventually turned immortal. Even if their relationship wasnât âeternalâ, it still lasted for a long while before she ditched him for another god, Ares. Also, something I deem as very important, is that in most myths, he doesnât âleaveâ his lovers. They do, they leave him (Cyrene, Coronis). That is, if he ever had his chance with them to begin with (Daphne, Cassandra). Or they die in a super tragic way or/and get turned into plants (Daphne again, Hyacinthus, Cyparissus, DryopĂŞ). And a few more example, but letâs stick to the famous ones. Way to make your personality more complex and hard to grasp. Which makes me wonder.. why is everyone convinced that Apollo is an utterly ridiculous, idiotic and happy-go-lucky god with close to no wisdom? Like heâs arrogant, kinda annoying and self-centered, but definitely not unwise or stupid. Canon-wise, Piper even asked him, I quote, âare you sure youâre not the god of wisdom?â, he also was the one who taught Chiron, and one of his many domains is knowledge and according to some sources, intelligence. The guy can be very mature and wise *when* he wants. So all in all, he does deserve a break, doesnât he? So even if these two might seem like opposites at first, underneath their differences, so many similarities can be found. Their backstories kinda overlap.
And, here, another one, remember the way he talked about Sally Jackson? Calling her one of the rare mortal woman who would treat a god like an equal, and seek their companionship instead of the privileges that come with dating a god? And how he would âhit on her for these qualitiesâ if he still was a god? Okay now tell me, how can you call him âsuperficialâ after reading that part? I mean..he has weird speaking manners and often come off as arrogant, but sometimes (very often) he does or says something that actually shows that he has a more mature side that needs and craves companionship above just youthful and good looks of some random mortal.And speaking about Sally Jackson.Donât you think the stated qualities apply to another person? Yeah, that girl. Reyna. And.. you know, that wonât be the first pairing involving mortal/god dynamics. Remember Sadie x Anubis (oh and btw, I headcanon Sadie as 17 because I refuse to ship them with her being j u s t 13. Itâs just..a big no) Itâs an example that shows that Rick can write a mortal-god pairing. Itâs not totally out of reach or god-awful. It would be, if rushed just to pair them up, or if they get struck by the OoC curse. But it wonât. Also, I feel like 2 books would be enough if they spans a long period (6 months/1 year) and if they get enough screen time. Donât forget that most romance books are not series but just a story or max. a trilogy haha.And yes I freaking adore this ship if you havenât noticed so far. Itâs like, part of my top 3, hehe. I used to actually hate it, like deep hatred and judged those who shipped it xD, but I gave it a chance, and here I am loving it so much I want it canon xD.