Over the past couple of years I have been having portfolio reviews from many creative people such as; The Chase, Brian Grimwood (HOW LUCKY AM I!?), WeAreFlow, Beth Mills and more. Each review gave me an outsiders insight on my work. Overall, I am very happy with the responses I have been receiving and the constructive criticism has been so helpful in preparing my portfolio.
The first thing I will mention is to have your portfolio ready to show, you do not want to show someone, especially a professional an unfinished portfolio. It will reflect badly on you and be straight up embarrassing. Luckily, I haven't had to experience this yet apart from minor outdated information which has no been updated. I would also like to start of by saying people love handouts and physical portfolios, Flow called mine ‘an old school portfolio’. A well presented portfolio is a not just to show your work, it’s showcasing what you are about. A shoddy, juice soaked portfolio is not going to reflect well on you so keep it clean and professional. Neat, tidy and aligned, good paper stock and quality prints are all thing you need for a professional portfolio.
To summarise my reviews I can mention a few things that popped up a couple of times. The first being my use of colour, I feel that I struggle with colour however, after these portfolio reviews it turns out I’m not so bad after all. My last two reviews have said I have a great use of colour throughout my portfolio. One suggestion I got about the colour of my images was that a couple were too dark, they needed brightening up, which I did and now I haven’t had any negative criticisms on that. The next thing I heard a lot of was to make sure each page has alignment from one to another, there is nothing worse than a portfolio that is out of alignment on each page, it just looks unprofessional. Relating to layout I got one suggestion to be bolded with my layouts for example, my condiments page, the suggestion was to simply have one element like the ketchup bottle and place it on one whole page meanwhile the rest of them keep them on the next page. An interesting piece of feedback I got from Flow was that they would love to see sketches and processes in the back of my portfolio. I haven’t heard this from anyone before however, I really like the idea of it. Showing a client how I got to the final piece is just as important as the final piece.
I worry that my work doesn’t always look like it is from the same person. Now I’ve have both negative and positive feedback about this. Starting with the negative, as a portfolio consistency is key to advertising professionalism and advertising exactly who you are now I’ve also had feedback saying that it’s not bad to have variety, it’s a good thing because it shows I have versatility. A note I picked up on was that it all depends on who you are showing the portfolio too. Agencies, companies and clients all vary on their opinions on what a good portfolio is about. So stick to your guns and be confident in your decisions of what you are putting in your portfolio or have a mini portfolio they can keep to showcase all your work.
Another major thing to note down is context, always show your work in context even if it is a menu or a book cover. By doing this it is making it easier for whoever you’re showing your portfolio to understand how and where your work can be applied. This seems to be the most important piece of advice because I received it off everyone. I have images of my work in context in my portfolio but there never can be too much context!
I would also like to add that getting these portfolio really give you confidence, especially when Brian Grimwood likes your work! I have received so many tricks, tips, advice and constructive criticisms from these reviews.
http://www.briangrimwood.com
http://www.thechase.co.uk