not-even-even replied to your post “Time Travel Activism”
?? you have linked today to a freddie deboer post, and one of the things he hates in activist culture is the inability to build coalition. Do you propose to care even less about convincing others and building movements? maybe I don't get some irony.
"dude, what would help us with out goals is gettign even more atomized and uncooeprative :)"?Â
There’s no reason to think because one agrees with one thing deBoer writes, one MUST AGREE WITH ALL THINGS HE HAS SAID EVER (or any other author) . In fact that fallacy of that assumption is one of his main themes. And dear Lord, is there is a lot to object about Freddie. But there’s also a lot of good analysis, and one should without fear refer to the good analysis for the value it is in of itself.
I think you misunderstand both his, and my points about coalitions, since I think we are in agreement on them.
You should absolutely form tactical coalitions on specific issues, as a method of gaining power to achieve your ethical objectives. You should work with social conservatives to support a union. You should work with libertarian techbros to get climate change. You should work with centrist operatives to win national elections. You should work with right wing populists to reign in finance capitalism. For no specific fight should you be too pure, or too elitist, or too vengeful to not form a coalition for this specific goal.
What is misleading is trying to form one, all purpose, overarching Coalition of the Ascendent that make all your allies “comfortable” and “aware” with no specific, concrete objective. And then you limit yourself to only working with those allies on every particular fight, rendering yourself impotent and puritanical. That is not what a Time Traveler would do. and it’s also the exact sort of social-status-oriented activism performance that deBoer is so against as well.
If you were from the future, and you were absolutely certain that too low a minimum wage ended up destroying society, then when you came back you would work with anyone, with the devil’s own grandmother, to raise the minimum wage. This is... exactly not how modern liberalism operates anymore (at least in the online sphere. Most IRL activists are not as dumb as their tumblr warrior counterparts.)