#most of the time...

This poor girls gift is also a curse. When she is transformed she is physically incapable of unhappiness. When shes in "boy mode" she's incapable of *being* happy. She can only ever be one or the other, never both.

Magical girls exist as the manifestations of happiness. They all get gifts, and dreams come true. But are they happy? What is happiness? What happens when their happiness puts them at odds with one another?

customer: "I don't mean to shoot the messenger..."

I also noticed that Moon at the start was more feral then in chap 4 is it becuse he is realising time is running out that he is more tame? (Same goes for sun)

How do the Witches intend to share them? Will Yn also become immortal in the process?

The boys in Charm Brought it Back are inspired by the witches from Hocus Pocus but they're not like them exactly. You might notice some similarities in their personalities, like how both Sun and Sarah are both flirts. But no their outfits don't match visually, they do wear handsome cloaks though!

I would need @naffeclipse approval on this next answer but the boys just came back from the dead in the first chapter, so they're rather excited at being alive again. But I also don't think they become that much more tame. Moon definitely seems more tame after hunting down his little mouse in the first chapter, but he was just excited. Being alive for longer might help all the boys even out some more. Being dead for centuries, you tend to forget your manners (if the witches had any to begin with).

Oh god, don't get me started on this. I hate it, and I'll admit that I used to participate in it, but I think the majority of it may actually come from the TimSteph fandom of ole.

Look, a lot of Tim fans like to baby Tim. I do it to an extent too, but he's not helpless or naïve in any way. I've discussed it in another post regarding the fandoms hypersexualization of Steph but it's genuinely a part of keeping his perfect, goody-goody image all coming from a place of projecting something, who tf knows what. It comes off very weird to me because like...is he less pure and baby and good if he fucks or just knows what sex is??? Nefarious if you ask me.

And this just isn't true. Tim obviously knows what sex is, and discussed it with Ariana as a step he wanted to take with her, likely after marriage. Which, some may say that him wanting to wait is part of it, but he's 14 here and I just don't think it's a priority for him really, not yet.

A lot of fans act as if Tim was mortified or terrified during the above panels, and he just...wasn't? He was surprised, but he handled it very maturely and respectfully. He obviously knows what she's asking for and how serious of a step it is. He's NOT naïve.

And I discussed further regarding this panel which is the most popular "damning evidence of Tim being baby":

Is just a straight up stupid reading of this.

Tim is trying to process this very large shock that's been put on him and on Steph who he has only been on one official date with at this point. If you understand Steph's character at all, which most who play into this fanon BS do not, you will understand that she deflects by making jokes and light teasing. She knows Tim knows he's not the father, she isn't suggesting that he is stupid, she's trying to ease the very palpable tension that has just been dropped into her new relationship with Tim. To assume that Tim ACTUALLY thinks that babies come from making out, is just...I don't know where to start anon...

It doesn't help that fanfics and fanart have often showed Steph "scaring" Tim by showing him her boobies, which partially may come from her very OOC tactic of distracting The General by pretending she was going to show him her tits...nice, DC.

And then you have the gross misconception that the reason Tim is scared in this panel, isn't because he's about to be raped, but "ahhhh titties!!!" -_-...

So fans just...rolled with that dynamic and we have very good art, but also highly OOC like this piece by gabzilla:

Timmy is too precious, he's too scared of boobies and sex and he needs to be coddled.

It's just very bizarre and I could rant in length about how just being a virgin doesn't make you naïve and that would be me self projecting, or how being a virgin doesn't make you more good and pure than anyone else but like...I'm lazy.