#max mutchnick

I've finally figured out how to make gifs

When Mid Century Modern premiered on Hulu in March 2025, it seemed like a guaranteed hit. Created by Max Mutchnick and David Kohan (Will & Grace) and produced by Ryan Murphy (American Horror Story, Glee, Pose), the series also reunited legendary sitcom director James Burrows with a powerhouse cast that included Nathan Lane, Matt Bomer, Nathan Lee Graham, and Linda Lavin.

The story followed three older gay friends, Bunny, Jerry, and Arthur, who, after a tragedy, decide to retire together in Palm Springs, where Bunny’s mother soon joins them. The show explored themes of aging, friendship, chosen family, and reinvention, all within the framework of a traditional multi-camera sitcom filmed before a live audience. The result was both nostalgic and refreshingly genuine, offering viewers humor and heart in equal measure.

Critics responded enthusiastically. Mid Century Modern scored an 88 percent "fresh" rating on Rotten Tomatoes and earned praise on Metacritic for its sharp writing, classic pacing, and standout performances. It received several Emmy nominations, including recognition for directing, production design, and picture editing. Reviewers celebrated it as a sincere, funny, and emotionally grounded return to the warmth of traditional sitcom storytelling.

Why It Was Cancelled Despite Strong Reviews?

Despite critical acclaim and a loyal core audience, Hulu announced in September 2025 that Mid Century Modern would not return for a second season. Co-creator Max Mutchnick acknowledged the decision publicly, writing, "Ten great episodes. Not enough. But we loved making every single one of them. We’re going to miss our very special show."

According to industry insiders, the reason was not quality but numbers. While critics praised the series, Hulu's internal metrics showed low overall viewership. The show simply did not attract enough consistent watchers to justify the cost of production, a common challenge for comedies in the streaming age, especially those when there isn't enough advertising being done.

Several factors likely contributed to its early end:

Niche Subject Matter: Centering on older gay men and the dynamics of friendship and aging, the series resonated deeply with specific audiences but struggled to reach broader demographics.

Traditional Format: In an era dominated by single-camera comedies and prestige dramas, a live-audience sitcom can appear dated to modern viewers, even when executed with skill.

Limited Marketing: Many fans and critics argued that Hulu did not promote the show adequately, allowing it to get lost among flashier releases.

Production Setbacks: The loss of Linda Lavin during production forced creative changes that may have disrupted its momentum.

What It Means

Mid Century Modern stands as a rare blend of old-school sitcom charm and meaningful representation, a series that managed to honor classic television while giving visibility to stories often left untold. Ryan Murphy’s influence gave the show its polished visual style and emotional depth, bridging traditional sitcom storytelling with his signature focus on identity and community.

Its cancellation highlights a growing challenge for streaming platforms: balancing artistic and cultural value against cold audience data. For fans, the loss is significant. The series offered a witty, heartfelt portrayal of chosen family and aging within the LGBTQ+ community, delivered with warmth and authenticity that few shows match today.

maxmutchnick I was blown away by the new John Oliver children’s book, “A Day in the Life of Marlon Bundo.” With Easter upon us, I wanted to not only support the brilliance of John Oliver, but also celebrate the Gayest Bunny of Them All: The Easter Bunny. So I decided to buy a copy of Oliver’s “Bundo” (written by Jill Twiss) for every public grammar school in Indiana. All 1,121 of them. Here’s why: Mike Pence has had an enormous platform in Indiana, and as it relates to gay people, he’s used it to spread a message of intolerance. By donating these books, I hope to counter those efforts and provide positive role models and a story of inclusion for children in Pence’s home state. If this book can help one boy or girl in Indiana love and accept who they are, I know both Marlon Bundos would be proud—even though one of them is on the downlow.