Maedhros: „Do what you want. I‘m not your dad“

Maedhros, running outside two minutes later:

BOY DO I. Not sure if these are “hot takes” or more just “reasons I didn’t like the film” but here we are. This is all fully biased, and I’ll make sure to tag it as anti cause its not gonna be very nice. Also I’ve only seen the movie once so my memory is a little fuzzy. I’ll stick to highlights cause a full run down would be a freaking ESSAY. I’ll also put it below the cut so those who don’t want to don’t have to read. 

The humor is awful. The movie starts with what is essentially a “yo mama” joke and just goes downhill from there. Luke throwing the lightsaber over his shoulder was just DUMB idk what R*an saw on the internet that made him think that would be funny in the actual movie is beyond me. Also there were a lot of moments that could have been heartfelt or moving and were ruined by bad humor (the “reach out” part comes to mind).

What was done with Finn and Poe’s characters, particularly Finn’s, IRKS me to no end. We didn’t get much of Poe in TFA but what we got showed that he was trusted highly by Leia and a respected leader. So you’re gonna tell me that someone of that caliber would be willing to lose the ENTIRE RESISTANCE BOMBING FLEET to take out ONE SHIP. Nah. And Finn, neither the character nor John Boyega deserved TLJ. Not only was his “I’m not here to fight” arc rehashed (we already went through that in TFA and he came out a HERO on the other side we didn’t need it again) but after that he was basically used as a joke and to make Rose look good and righteous (I liked Rose so that’s not hate towards her). 

The absolute character assassination of Luke was just NO. Now I can understand Luke feeling like a failure and running away. I can understand him questioning the Jedi (actually liked that part cause the Jedi are dumb). But you will never convince me that Luke Skywalker, who THREW AWAY his lightsaber in ROJ rather than fight Vader and FREAKING PALPY, would consider murdering his nephew, the son of his sister and best friend, to the point where he was in Ben’s hut with his lightsaber ignited, because he saw that Ben was being manipulated by Snoke???  No. NEVER.

Also what a waste of Snoke??? I to this day for bad for JJ when it comes to ROS cause Johnson left him with so much clean up. 

A waste of Captain Phasma too. She was so cool and definitely should have been kept around longer. 

Hondo should at least told everyone PART of her plan. I get taking Poe down a peg but why make everyone think they were going to die???

The throne room lightsaber duel was bad. Idk what happened but either the fight choreo was bad or Adam and Daisy were off cause it just didn’t work.

I felt like the editing was choppy. There were too many story lines and, because there were too many, none of them got the depth they should have which contributed to the movie feeling half baked. 

I have a picture of Freddie Mercury where my ID is meant to go in my wallet

I second the how old is anon, that is so childish

actualmermaid replied to your post “if you unfollowed don't come and peep my blog now, that is SO FAKE....”

Wowwwwwwww

thelioninmybedreplied to your post “if you unfollowed don't come and peep my blog now, that is SO FAKE....”

wowwwwwww

imindhowwelayinjunereplied to your post “if you unfollowed don't come and peep my blog now, that is SO FAKE....”

WHOA

ivanaskye replied to your post “if you unfollowed don't come and peep my blog now, that is SO FAKE....”

this is next level

valaraukars replied to your post “if you unfollowed don't come and peep my blog now, that is SO FAKE....”

God that makes me feel a little better about my 10000 drafts (unfortunately not an exaggeration, I don’t blog I....draft)

crocordile replied to your post “if you unfollowed don't come and peep my blog now, that is SO FAKE....”

Are we in a high school AU dsbhdjkdfhf HOW OLD IS ANON (also i have so much respect for your pile of drafts)

gurguliare replied to your post “if you unfollowed don't come and peep my blog now, that is SO FAKE....”

thank you for consistently always making me feel better about my drafts

ask about my bastards

well, Tuor definitely likes dogs, at least to the point where he got some of Lorgan’s to like him enough that they didn’t maul him when he escaped

I was halfway typing about how I love this trope where a person is made to sleep with the hunting dogs in order to humiliate or degrade them, but then they become friends with the dogs, and when they escape and their captors set the dogs on them the dogs just don’t attack

and then I remembered that aside from tuor I have only seen it one (1) other place and the escape part was just fanfic dsgvhdfhrfb

BUT IT SHOULD BE A TROPE

ncfan-1 replied to your post: today’s topic: is nienor a cat person? Is morwen?...

I think Turin is a cat person (Though he may like dogs just a little bit better).

I wonder what their religion was like pre-only semi freely chosen cultural assimilation.

the best places for info about this are the Tale of Adanel and the Athrabeth (which i haven’t read closely in a while because in-universe religion isn’t one my my main Tolkien interests tbh) but maybe read/reread them if you haven’t recently! my interests run primarily to the Edain in Beleriand, so idk if there are any other significant sources about their past, but maybe someone else reading this knows? there’s also not a ton of evidence of Edain religious practices in Beleriand, and there are a few indications that they don’t actively worship the Valar or even think about them very much except as the elves’ gods, so i mostly headcanon the Edain as not really having a standardized or organized religion. 

anyway i don’t have any detailed headcanons about this but @squirrelwrangler wrote an excellent fic about Edain history and religious-ish practices a while back, check it out if you haven’t already

maedhroswhy replied to your post “god i just wish. there was a significant part of the fandom that was...”

always been afraid to say it, but I’ve been thinking this for quite a while...the elves seriously are not the center of the entire universe and the only people that matter, but it’s difficult actually convincing people of that

it sure is :/ and i know some people aren’t interested and it’s fine! i just wish that everyone who wanted to write about human/elf relationships put more effort into thinking about the human side of things. i love these relationships too but i have read some real dumb shit

vardasvapors replied to your post “god i just wish. there was a significant part of the fandom that was...”

I know I’m v preoccupied by interspecies stuff re tolkien and also don’t produce much edain-only content, but god the lack of edain-only or edain-centric content makes EVERYTHING else worse too imo. it especially bugs me when people interpret ‘more edain’ as ‘be woke-ly mean about elves in a totally elf-centric way while generically mentioning the edain’

Legolas has probably been shipped with everyone at this point