Analysis: Non-Dust Electricity Generation (Fossil Fuels/Nuclear/Thermal Power) as an Alternative Source in RWBY's Remnant
Overview in Canon (from RWBY Wiki and Lore) In Remnant, Electricity Dust (a variant of Lightning Dust) directly produces electrical currents, powering lights, appliances, Paladins, androids (Penny), and grids without intermediate steps like turbines or generators. Dust is mined, refined, and distributed (SDC dominance), making traditional power plants unnecessary. No canon evidence of fossil fuel extraction, nuclear reactors, or large thermal stations exists. Resources like coal/oil/gas are never mentioned; focus is on Dust's elemental magic-like properties.
How Non-Dust Electricity Generation Could Work in Remnant
Mechanism: Burn fossil fuels (coal, oil, natural gas) in thermal plants to heat water into steam, driving turbines for electricity. Nuclear uses fission to heat water similarly.
https://letstalkscience.ca/sites/default/files/styles/width_800px/public/2020-12/Coal-fired-power-plant.gif?itok=9oHJit77
https://media.sciencephoto.com/c0/29/16/38/c0291638-800px-wm.jpg
Potential: High output for baseload power (coal/nuclear especially). Could free Dust for weapons/military, using mundane fuels for civilian grids. Fire Dust might catalyze combustion.
Many Issues with Non-Dust Electricity Generation in Remnant Context
Technical/Deployment Challenges:
Requires massive stationary plants and fuel supply chains (mining/drilling, transport) — inefficient compared to portable Dust crystals.
Fuel scarcity: No canon fossil deposits; exploration in Grimm wilderness suicidal. Nuclear needs uranium enrichment (advanced, risky tech).
Pollution: Emissions (CO₂, soot, radiation waste) irrelevant to Grimm attraction but harm health/air quality in walled cities.
Environmental and Societal Barriers:
Resource extraction exposes workers to Grimm; pipelines/rails vulnerable.
Dust lock-in: Kingdoms optimized for Dust (Aura activation); retrofitting wasteful.
Grimm/Salem's Group Sabotage Potential
Extremely high: Power plants are large, fixed targets with constant human activity (negative emotions from labor/stress). Grimm hordes easily overwhelm defenses.
Salem's faction prioritizes: Blackouts cause panic/despair (her goal). Watts hacks grids; Tyrian/Cinder assassinates engineers; directed Grimm (e.g., Goliath charges, flying swarms) destroy facilities. Likelihood very high — centralized plants are perfect for cascading failures.
Summary Table Fit (Adapted for Non-Dust Electricity)
Source: Electricity-Electric Power (Thermal/Fossil/Nuclear)
Type: Various (Chemical for fossils, Nuclear fission)
Renewability: Non-renewable (fossils finite; nuclear fuel limited)
Primary Use: Electricity generation
Efficiency: High (modern plants ~30-60%)
Energy Density/Issues: High density fuels, but massive infrastructure vulnerable to attack; pollution and fuel scarcity in Grimm world.
Non-Dust electricity is theoretically scalable but fundamentally mismatched to Remnant — Dust's direct, portable power avoids centralized vulnerabilities that Grimm/Salem exploit ruthlessly.