https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KO6ZRjhOozE
Yeah, yeah, yeah, another video with an earnest lady explaining why Christians should TOTES appropriate a Jewish holiday. But this one . . . I don’t know, man. Part of me wants to call it a comedy classic -- like, she completely blows the lid off the whole “Messianic Judaism is Christianity with Jew costumes” open secret in the first minute of the video, and it just gets weirder from there.
Part of me wants to point and laugh at her simultaneous claims that the Book of Esther is all about God’s care of people (the Book of Esther is, in fact, one of two books where there are only human characters, the other one being the Song of Songs) AND that she’s such an expert on Scripture and the Book of Esther from having done this so many times (though she seems to have missed a big aspect of it). Part of me also wants to point and laugh at the really quite shallow reasons that she gives for celebrating Purim -- like Mel Brooks’s original 1968 The Producers, part of what makes the fun work in a real Purim celebration is the undercurrent of boiling hot anger at the shit that the world wants to throw at the Jews -- this is the ur-type of the “they tried to kill us, they failed, let’s eat” holiday.
But then there’s another part of me that looks at this woman’s behavior and affect, and . . . I think I’m kind of worried about her, honestly. She has the big toothy smile, but she’s nervous, and she rambles, and you can see the facade crumbling as the video progresses. There are parts where she looks at the camera, and for an instant, she looks utterly terrified. What does she think is going to happen if she drops her smile or admits that she’s not feeling perky? Does she know that it’s antisemitism and she’s trying to avoid admitting that to herself? Is she afraid that her fundamental ignorance is going to show here? Is she even a real person at this point, or is she, much like her conception of Purim, nothing more than a frivolous confection of food and games and costumes and frantic partying desperate to distract you from the howling emptiness inside?
What is going on with this video?