#casitel preference

Requested by Anon~ Enjoy!!

A/N: Crowley and Benny are included in this one. This is my first time writing for Benny, so I hope it’s okay!

Dean:

You notice Dean stir in his sleep about an hour into research. He had fallen fast asleep, for he was just running on fumes, so his random pass out was warranted. Soon after he begins to stir, you notice him clench his eyes tighter and his fists ball together tightly. You gently stir him, cringing when you see his emerald eyes look at you with panic. 

“It’s okay, Dean. I’m here, it was just a dream”, you comfort him, placing soft kisses on his forehead. When he calms down enough, you both head to bed where you wrap your shorter arms around his taller frame. Dean thinks it’s humorous that you’re the big spoon, but he can’t resist how safe it makes him feel.

Sam:

It’s around 3:00 AM when you notice Sam tossing and turning. His face was contorted into a grimace as he tirelessly fidgeted in his sleep. You shook him awake softly and eyed him with worry when he shot his eyes open and took in deep breaths. You rested your head against his racing heart while your hands gently held onto his shaking ones. After you felt his heart rate slow, you motioned for him to lay back down with him facing away from you. You could almost sense his disappointment before your arms made their way around his huge frame. Sure, you weren’t usually the big spoon, but Sam loved the comfort of your body pressed against his. 

Cas:

Normally, Cas wouldn’t sleep. But, when he was human for a brief time, he had to sleep. When he did sleep, it was riddled with hundreds of nightmares. When he awoke one night from an especially bad one, Cas reached over to you hesitantly. When you roused, you noticed the fear in his normally brave blue eyes. You let him relax in your arms as you held him, brushing through his brown locks with your fingers. When he was ready to sleep again, you lay behind him, snaking your arms around his tired figure. With the warmth and comfort your supplied him, Cas fell into a deep, peaceful sleep in a matter of seconds.

Crowley:

Crowley had no need for sleep. Thus, he never had “nightmares”, but instead lived with the guilt of what he had done. One night, you noticed the absence of your boyfriend and got up to find him. When you did locate him, he was on his knees, pulling at his hair as tears leaked out of his eyes. You quickly knelt beside him, shushing him and cradling his head. These episodes occurred fairly often, but your comfort always seemed to calm him down. Eventually, you both made it back into your bed, where you wrapped your arms from behind him. He found peace from your tight embrace and the soft breaths you exhaled as you dozed off again.

Benny:

Because of Benny’s vampire status, he slept during the day. Even though you still slept at night, you would both cuddle for a couple hours while each other were sleeping. You noticed Benny clutch onto you harder as he grimaced in his sleep. You gently coaxed him awake, comfortingly running your hands along his face as he caught his breath. After reassuring him that it was just a dream and you were here, he calmed down enough to sleep again. He allowed you to be a big spoon (which didn’t occur often), basking in the warmth and security being in your arms brought him.

Feedback is appreciated!

(So, since this is my first time writing for Benny, I don’t have a tag list for him. Anyone interested on being on it?)

Requested by @kickasscas67. Thanks for requesting! i hope it was worth the wait.

A/N: Hey guys! Great news! I’m expanding preference requests until 4/21! Make sure to send in your ideas!

Dean:

You hadn’t meant for Dean to know about your insecurity. But, it still seeped through, no matter how hard you tried to hide it. He saw the pain in your eyes when there was an attractive bartender or waitress, the baggy clothes you’d wear, the shyness when he asked to see your body. It pains him to see you hurting, so he does what he does best. Not only does he show you with actions (oh, so many actions), but he also describes to you what he sees in you- absolute beauty.

Sam:

Sam didn’t know about your body image issues until one passionate night. He immediately noticed when you used your arms to cover yourself, something he hadn’t seen before. When Sam asked you about it, you broke down crying, telling him about how ugly you thought you were. Sam just held you close, whispering sweet praise and reassurance until you slowly fell asleep, safe and loved in his arms.

Cas:

You kept your insecurities hidden from your blue-eyed angel as long as you could. However, you didn’t expect him to fly in when you were judging your form in the mirror. Curious, he asked what you were doing, but he could obviously tell you were lying when you said ‘nothing’. Of course, Cas was utterly confused, simply because he saw you as the most beautiful thing his father created. Oh, but did he make sure you knew that by the end of the night.