When Caitlin Clark injured her right groin in mid-July, many doubted whether the Indiana Fever could stay relevant this season. But instead of crumbling, the team rallied. Without their star and fresh off multiple setbacks, they shocked the basketball world with an 87-85 upset over the Atlanta Dream in Game 3, earning their first playoff series win in a decade. Coach, role players, and injured leaders showed that resilience doesn’t need a full roster to make noise.

Clark’s Injury & What She Meant to the Fever

Caitlin Clark’s year started full of promise: Rookie of the Year honors, leading the league in assists, being an All-Star, and breaking records. But a right groin injury suffered on July 15 forced her to the sidelines. Along with other ailments—a bone bruise in her left ankle, issues in her groin, quad strains—she was officially ruled out for the rest of the 2025 season. Though she’d only played in 13 games, her impact on and off the court was already deep.

Her absence meant more than missing points or assists—it meant missing energy, media attention, and expectations. But it also opened space for others to step up.

The Upset That Turned Heads

Despite being underdogs, the Fever outlasted the Dream in Game 3, pulling off an 87-85 win in Atlanta in a tight, electric finish. It was their first playoff series win since 2015, breaking nearly a decade of disappointment.

Kelsey Mitchell led the charge with a hot scoring night; Aliyah Boston capped the game with a dramatic game-winning basket. Lexie Hull, Natasha Howard, and Odyssey Sims contributed big plays when they mattered. These are the moments that rewarded a team believing in itself against all odds.

Leadership from the Bench & the Heart

Even though Clark couldn’t play, she didn’t disappear. She was seen cheering, holding up “W” signs, and supporting teammates during and after the game. Sophie Cunningham—also injured—was visible in the crowd. The energy underlined that while physical presence matters, leadership isn’t contained to who’s on the court.

Head Coach Stephanie White emphasized qualities like fight, scrappiness, and togetherness. Her message, combined with the players who rose up, turned a cliffhanger into a statement: the Fever won’t quit simply because someone said they were out.

The Season’s Wounds & Unexpected Strengths

The roster was battered by injuries. Alongside Clark, key players like Sophie Cunningham, Aari McDonald, and others missed significant time. But adversity forced depth: players who’d often been in supporting roles had to fill gaps.

Kelsey Mitchell emerged as a scoring star, averaging over 20 points per game in Clark’s absence. Aliyah Boston kept anchoring rebounding and defense. These moments revealed that even a team that loses its star can build enough trust and momentum to make an impact.

Critics, Fans & the Narrative Shift

Some fans have questioned whether Indiana is “better without” Clark given their recent success—an unfair framing, many argue. Clark’s value, both in performance and in drawing attention to the league, is enormous. Still, the hope is that the team’s current resilience complements what she brings when healthy.

Similarly, the finale in Atlanta was packed with tension: boos from fans, a charged atmosphere, and dramatic finishing moments. The Fever not only earned a win—they earned respect.

What’s Next

The Fever move into the semifinals to face the Las Vegas Aces. Clark will not return this season, so the team has to continue without her. Can they sustain this level of fight against arguably the toughest opponent left? That question looms large.

Players like Mitchell, Boston, Hull, Howard, and Sims will need to keep making big plays. Coach White’s strategy of belief and grit will be under pressure. And the Fever will want to carry this moment—this upset—rather than letting it become just another headline.

fever vs storm