Untitled

I just finished reading the Kya solo comic, Kya and the Secret of the Sand, and I have questions.

And I’m deliberately comparing comic panels only here. If I started mixing ATLA, TLOK, the comics, and other official material, I could find even more examples. But seriously. Look at them.

So, naturally, I have a theory.

Kya is roughly four or five years younger than Bumi. I think Aang was absolutely obsessed with the idea that his firstborn would be an airbender. When Bumi showed no signs of airbending, I can imagine Aang taking it very badly—withdrawing emotionally and, at least to some extent, blaming Katara. Maybe he convinced himself that she wasn’t “spiritual enough,” and that this was somehow why their son had been born a nonbender.

And I think Zuko took Katara’s side.

He supported her. He cared about little Bumi. And honestly, that could even explain why Bumi seems to have such a good relationship with Uncle Zuko later on—and why he eventually became a Commander in the United Forces, apparently connected to the Fire Nation branch judging by his uniform.

And somewhere during that period, while Katara was hurt, isolated, and struggling with Aang, she and Zuko grew closer.

Something happened.

And then Kya was born.

Officially, completely, unquestionably presented to the world as Aang’s daughter.

And, incredibly fortunately for everyone involved, she turned out to be a waterbender.

Because realistically, what else could they have done?

The truth would have caused an unbelievable international scandal. The world had only recently recovered from a hundred-year war, and suddenly the Fire Lord had fathered a child with the Avatar’s wife? The leader of the Fire Nation “stealing” the Avatar’s wife would already have been politically catastrophic—but it would have been even worse because Aang was under enormous pressure to restore the Air Nomads and produce another airbender.

So they buried it.

And they never told anyone.

Zuko remained close to Katara’s children anyway—and, judging by TLOK, that relationship continued even into old age. But the truth itself stayed between two people.

Katara and Zuko.

And I wonder whether that could explain something else about Kya.

She has always seemed strangely disconnected from her family.

In the new comic, she literally hides the family photograph.

And in TLOK, inside the Fog of Lost Souls—a place that brings people’s deepest fears and emotional wounds to the surface—Kya screams that she has no family and runs away even when Tenzin tells her, “We’re your brothers.”

Obviously, Kya herself would never know any of this.

She would live her entire life believing she was Katara and Aang’s daughter, because that is the only version of the truth she was ever given.

And frankly, that might be for the best.

Because if she ever discovered the truth, I can’t imagine her reaction to finding out that her mother and beloved Uncle Zuko had lied to her for her entire life.

Anyway.

This entire theory started because I kept noticing how absurdly similar Kya and Zuko are visually—and then I realized I had accumulated an embarrassing number of screenshots.

What actually sent me down this rabbit hole was the character design.

Look at young Katara and older Katara. Her facial features remain recognizable, especially in profile: she has that distinctive short, slightly upturned nose.

Then look at Aang, Tenzin, and Bumi in profile. Look at their noses, their jawlines, the overall structure of their faces. Tenzin and Bumi very clearly inherited features from Aang—the resemblance between all three of them is obvious.

Kya stands out from that pattern.

Her face is longer and narrower, with a more pronounced nose, a different jawline, and a different eye shape. In profile especially, she looks noticeably unlike Aang, Tenzin, or Bumi.

What caught my attention is that those same features repeatedly appear in Zuko’s design: the elongated face, the shape and projection of the nose, the sharper jaw, the eyes. And the resemblance becomes even more interesting when Izumi is included in the comparison, because several of those features are present in her design as well.

So visually, there is a pretty clear family pattern in the character designs: Aang, Tenzin, and Bumi share one set of facial features; Zuko and Izumi share another.

And Kya fits surprisingly well into the second one.

At the same time, her coloring is entirely Katara’s.

What do you think?