I must start by admitting that this is speculation, as is anything that tries to explain the mind of God. However, I believe this is a useful exercise in imagination that may teach us a bit about the world we live in, what it is good for, and how the Church should think about reality and our relationship with its Creator, who is Triune, independent, omniscient, omnipotent, and omnipresent. (Many other resources deal with defending those attributes, if you wish to read defenses of them.) That being said, letās delve into reimagining how it all started.
Before time and space were brought into being, God existed. Father, Son, and Holy Spirit live in perfect love, outside of time, and unbound by space. (The miracles of the incarnation and the cross are the only departures from this, and are not particularly relevant for this essay.)Ā They are all that existed in that frame of reference, which I must refer to as before creation though it is timeless, as I am human and have no other way to fathom or communicate it. Complete happiness and full actualization of all that is good is contained and manifested in the Triune God. So the question is, why create the world? Why allow suffering? I will answer these shortly, by following what I believe to be the commentary God thinks about the world through Biblical history. Although all the contemplation has always existed in Godās mind, I will present it linearly so we humans can ponder it and I can coherently express it on paper.
First God considered his glory, possibly by each Person being in awe of the other two. All good things are fully there, unchanging, and countless angels understand and worship God continually. Then God considered beings that did not know everything and learned by experience and unique relationships, humans. He decided it would be good to create beings that would know Him within a context of particular time and place. Thus they would have to appreciate different aspects of Him in different magnitudes. In this way, by creating different places and beings, he created an ever-increasing diversity of ways to worship and understand God, the sum of which is the total Goodness that exists in eternity.
This is why the first command was be fruitful and multiply. Be fruitful and find, discover, or imagine ways to understand and enjoy God. Multiply and propagate more sources of learning to be in relationship with and to create endless combinations of these ways of understanding God. These specific ways of understanding and worshipping God are what we would call our unique experiences. So creation came to be. And it was good. And then it wasnāt. But God did not destroy the failure and start over, as an omnipotent God would not allow something to exist if it did not further his purposes. And so it must not have been a failure. Indeed, sin is evil, but Godās purpose of having a plethora of ways us human beings can find and appreciate him is still happening.
The Fall did make it much more of a challenge for humans to find and worship God, as he deserves. Eventually, God saw that it was difficult (if not impossible) for everyone to find him in their own unique way and humanity began to give up all together, save for a few who clung to serving the Creator God. So God decided to align himself with a single people and single context as an example of how we should find God and worship him. I am of course referring to Israel. This was never meant to be exclusive, as God regularly disciplined them and allowed other nations to prosper, and several Gentiles were allowed to relate to God. In fact, Abraham was told that his descendants (Israel) will be blessed, and through them the whole world would be blessed. First humanity must be shown how to relate to God from a specific context, and then we could know how to find God from other contexts.
Then Jesus came along, Praise God! He died, and then rose from the dead, and ascended into Heaven. He sent the Spirit to the disciples who formed the Church, which came to be known as the Body. This metaphor is the crux of my argument. All have their specific context, set of abilities, and combination of relationships, and so each personās role in the Church will be different. Everyone has their own opinion about which characteristics of God are important, and through our diversity (not just racial diversity, but class, education, personality traits, and other kinds), we see a more complete picture of who the God we worship is. This is why Christ told his disciples to go to all nations, for now that Godās alignment with humanity shifted from the people who worship God (Israel) to the people who follow Jesus (the Church), a greater diversity has come into play, shifting from a whole nation to the whole world.Ā
In conclusion, Godās purpose in creating the world was to share his love through specific relationships that will glorify him. This is reflected in the original command to sinless people. Since the world still exists that purpose must still be possible and we should pursue it. I believe that purpose is to celebrate diversity and work together in the Church to build as complete a picture possible of who God is through our unique experiences and viewpoints, in order to better share that picture with others and enjoy this fellowship that we enter into. This is done through validating the specificity of each person while also seeking and appreciating the whole. Both of these must be accepted in the time of tension we followers of Jesus live, already redeemed but not yet perfected. This is my specific take on the hope that we pursue with all that we are.