Consider also the other way.
A family has a child who is born strong in the force- it almost ripples off her when she screams and cries as infants do. The Jedi are waiting by the door when the parents bring her home, her arrival having sent ripples in the force weeks before.
Please, they say. We know you love her. We know she is your first born, and that she is special to you the way that all children are special to their parents. But this gift comes with itâs own costs. She will be strange, she will be destructive without meaning to, she will see and know things that will frighten her and will frighten you. she may even accidentally kill without proper training. Please, for your sake and hers, let us raise her where she will not harm others and be understood by her peers.
And the family says no. She is OURS, and ours to raise.
And the Jedi can do nothing. To force the issue is tantamount to kidnapping, and inexcusable.
The problems begin before she reaches her first birthday. A baby with the power of the cosmos at her command is a dangerous thing- objects shatter and splinter when she cries, there is no place out of reach to her- if she wants a cookie, she can pull the whole jar off the shelf. But they try. She is their child, after all.
It gets worse when she starts to speak. Secrets are thrown into the light of day, disturbing questions asked, and she still cries- not from her own distress now, but from horrors seen across time and space, too large and fraught for such a small being to handle alone, but there is nothing her parents can say to comfort her. She develops means of protecting herself on her own- unpredictable aversions and triggers, hiding away from the too-loud feelings of others, rituals to stave off the horrors that never work but the compulsion is there the same. They try, but her parents know they are failing now. She isnât growing up like the child they expected and planned for, she isnât growing up like any child they know, she hardly seems like a child at all some days-
-And just like that, she goes from being their child, to their burden.
They still try- but theyâre trying to manage her now, not raise her. Doctors are called in, Medications are tried, and then âalternativeâ treatments and therapies and then 'unlicensed professionalsâ and eventually for the sake of their sanity and the safety of her siblings, she is sent away. Not to the temple, but to camps and then retreats and then institutions. Only ever for a few weeks at a time, she is still theirs and they canât burden anyone else with her, and each time she comes back less aggressively bizarre, so the treatments must be working right? Itâs not like weâve trained her that sheâll be punished with isolation and torture for 'acting outâ, right?
And it goes like this, until she is twelve and alone at home- her family is away so that her sibling scan have a âNormal vacation, for onceâ, and a documentary comes on.
They donât do documentaries often, but sometimes its good to let the public see how the mysterious organization operates. There is a live interview with a girl her age, who has just become the 'apprenticeâ to another Jedi, and she is bubbly and excited and rambles on and stammers as her mind outruns her mouth in a way frieghteningly familiar to the girl, and she tenses as the Master approaches, anticpating punishment- she always gets yelled at or smacked or worse when she gets like this.
An affectionate hand is put on her shoulder, assuring her of his presence and letting her continue to speak. She babbles on, and the camera pans upward to her assigned guardian.
He is looking down at this girl with such affection, such pride, such LOVE-
A whole alternate future spins out before her at once, where her parents had relented and admitted they didnât know what they were doing, and given her up. A future where there wasnât such breakable furniture around. A future where her nightmares were met with sypmathy and understanding, a future where shew as encouraged to move the furniture hands-free or make the flowers bloom or predict next weekâs news- a future where-
-where she could have been LOVED.
The resulting explosion takes out two of the walls and the nearest transformer, plunging the county into darkness while she flees into the night.
She doesnât see the rest of the interview, where apprentice and master alike flinch, at the sound of a breaking heart and the apprentice sobs, trying to reach out after the shadow vanishing into the night, and her master reaches immediately to comfort her.
Attatchment is forbidden, because of the suffering caused when attatchment binds and strangles, and because of the destruction caused when it inevitably breaks.