What if all the versions of Sherlock Holmes fought

There will be a one week period between this post and the beginning of the tournament for people to message me in the ask box about adaptations I have missed that you want to see included. After that, the bracket will be closed.

This is NOT a bracket to determine the "best" Holmes adaptation. Only who would win in a fight. Please vote accordingly.

This account will ONLY post tournament-related information. If you'd like to chat Sherlock Holmes, head on over to my main acct and hit me up.

Each poll will be open for a one week period in order to reach as many fans as possible. A new poll will be up every few days based on the winners of the previous poll. Please reblog and send to your Holmsian friends so that we can reach a large number of fans.

Happy voting! 🔎

Hello!!!

Wow I totally forgot about this to be honest.

My opinion was the Basil of Baker Street would absolutely wipe the floor with Sherlock Hound.

I firmly believe that that mouse could beat almost anyone in a fight, including humans or larger animals. He's got cartoon invincibility combined with super smarts and the fact that everyone would underestimate a mouse.

Proving that sometimes the classics really are the best, ACD Holmes takes the win!

Second prize goes to Sherlock from Moriarty the Patriot, and third goes to a tie between the Sherlock's from Sherlock and Co. and Sherlock Holmes in the 22nd Century.

Thank you all for a fun time! I will be leaving this blog open for the moment (I am pondering another bracket) and I am accepting asks/questions/comments!

If you'd like to chat and don't already, come follow me over at @veryfastnighuncatchable where I yap about Sherlock Holmes, Les Mis, Hazbin Hotel, and a whole bunch of other fandom nonsense.

Context:

Syder Holmes is from a 2010 steampunk movie called "Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes". In this version, Holmes' estranged evil cyborg brother Thorpe wants to kill Queen Victoria using a bomb contained within the body of his robot lover and then frame Lestrade for the murder.

Context:

Warlock Holmes is a book series where the titular protagonist is a magical warlock and uses magic and demonic means to solve crimes alongside Dr. Watson.

Context:

Moriarty the Patriot is an anime from the perspective of Moriarty as he fights to end class inequality while also engaging in a battle of wits with Sherlock Holmes. The Sherlock character in this adaptation is portrayed as eccentric and genius, yet also kind and conflicted about the actions of Moriarty.