I could totally see Fireheart not being clan born being a sort of Open Secret in Windclan (like, his clan knows but none of the other clans because Tallstar is just "MY SON" so none of the other clans question how this tall disaster gay man suddenly has a ginger son and assumes a queen might have passed) then Bluestar gets the prophecy and is just "Shit, Firepaw adores his dad how would I convince him to defect?????"
I have NOT stopped thinking about this ask for 2 days



















