Racial inequality in the criminal justice system
Though there exist persisting inequalities due to race in many countries, particularly white-majority nations like the USA, no disparities are as extreme as that of which exist in the criminal justice system; in which African Americans are 5.1 times more likely than Whites to be incarcerated. It has been clearly indicated that in cities across the United States, racial disparities have been documented throughout the criminal justice system, from routine police stops to long-term imprisonment for similar crimes as racial majorities.Â
Examples of such racial inequalities
1) Increased number of âroutineâ police stopsÂ
A team of Social Psychology Professors analyzed traffic and pedestrian stops made in Oakland, California, going on to uncover a consistent pattern of racial disparities. It was found that 60% of police stops were of Africans Americans, though they make up only 28% of the population of Oakland. Once stopped, African Americans were significantly more likely to be handcuffed, searched, and arrested. The team of Professors then went on to control these groups for more than two dozen factors relevant to officer decision making, including but not limited to crime rates and the underlying racial and socioeconomic demographics where the stop was made. However, despite making these controls to account for various factors at play, it was found that these disparities remained statistically significant. This social experiment of sorts was repeated in other places including Boston; Greensboro, North Carolina; Los Angeles; and New York City, and similar patterns were observed. These figures are extremely similar to others throughout St. Louis County. For example, in the town of Florissant, 71 percent of the motorists pulled over by police in 2013 were Black though they only made up 27 percent of the town at the time. Blacks were also twice as likely to be searched after a stop, even though white motorists were more likely to be found with contraband goods.
2) Unfair sentencing accorded to Black Americans in comparison to White AmericansÂ
Picture via: The Washington PostÂ
Perhaps the best example of this persisting problem is in how Black people are consistently arrested, charged and convicted of drug crimes including possession, distribution and conspiracy at far higher rates than white people. This, despite research showing that both races use and sell drugs at about the same rate. In what is termed as the âdrug warâ in America, A 2014 ACLU survey of SWAT teams across the country found that âdynamic entryâ and paramilitary police tactics are disproportionately used against black and Latino people. Most of these raids were on people suspected of low-level drug crimes. This is as compared to how White people are about 5 times less likely to go to prison for drug possession than Black people. According to exoneration data from the National Registry of Exonerations (NER), Black people are also 12 times more likely to be wrongly convicted of drug crimes. Black people comprise about 12.5 percent of drug users but 29 percent of arrests for drug crimes and 33 percent of those incarcerated. This data is significant as it is a very clear indicator of racism in the judicial system itself, and how Black people are stereotyped as more likely to be drug dealers, or involved with drug crimes. Due to the harmful profiling and stereotyping, the judicial system tends to give unfair sentences to Black Americans. Â
3) Disparities in Juries and Jury Selection
Although the Supreme Court has made it illegal for prosecutors to exclude prospective jurors because of race, that ruling has largely gone unenforced. A 2010 report by the Equal Justice Initiative documented cases in which courts upheld prosecutorsâ dismissal of jurors because of allegedly race-neutral factors such as affiliation with a historically black college, a son in an interracial marriage, living in a black-majority neighborhood or that a juror âshucked and jived [slang term for the behavior of joking and acting evasively]â. While there remains no comprehensive nation-wide data for America on this issue, there is regional data, with data from Caddo Parish, Los Angeles, finding that between 2003 and 2012, prosecutors struck 46 percent of prospective black jurors with preemptory challenges, vs. 15 percent of nonblacks. These disparities are so significant becuase of how they often result in unfair sentencing for Black Americans. A survey of data from the U.S. Sentencing Commission from 2017 found that when black men and white men commit the same crime, black men on average receive a sentence almost 20 percent longer. The research controlled for variables such as age and prior criminal history. A 2011 study of bail in five large U.S. counties found that blacks received $7,000 higher bail than whites for violent crimes, $13,000 higher for drug crimes and $10,000 higher for crimes related to public order. These disparities were calculated after adjusting for the seriousness of the crime, criminal history and other variables.
These examples just barely touch the surface of the sheer extent of racial inequality African Americans face in the judicial system in America. To find out even more about the inequality, you can read the attached article, via the Washington Post!
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/opinions/wp/2018/09/18/theres-overwhelming-evidence-that-the-criminal-justice-system-is-racist-heres-the-proof/?utm_term=.1a7c7d71de1c
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0963721418763931
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/opinions/wp/2018/09/18/theres-overwhelming-evidence-that-the-criminal-justice-system-is-racist-heres-the-proof/?utm_term=.1a7c7d71de1c
https://psmag.com/social-justice/a-report-to-the-un-reveals-deep-racial-disparities-in-american-criminal-justice-system