Thank you Frances for this RumChata cupcake recipe! I followed the directions and they came out a little overcooked and my kitchen turned out a mess but they're not too bad. Â Here is a link to the original recipe in case you don't trust mine.Â
For the cupcakes you will need:
1/2 cup butter, room temperature
To begin, preheat the oven to 350 degrees. Â Make sure your stick of butter is room temperature (cutting it into small pieces will help move it along quicker) and combine it with the 1 1/2 cups of sugar. Â Beat the two until the mixture is fluffy.Â
Next, mix together the dry ingredients (flour, baking powder, salt and cinnamon). Set aside (not pictured). Â Then mix together the RumChata and vanilla extract:
Next you're going to alternate adding the dry mixture and RumChata mixture to your butter and sugar. Â Start by adding 1/3 of the dry mixture to the butter/sugar, then 1/2 of the RumChata/vanilla, another 1/3 dry mixture, second 1/2 of RumChata/vanilla followed by the last 1/3 of the dry mixture. Â
Now in a separate bowl separate your egg whites. Â This is a total pain and for a clever trick that absolutely failed for me, visit this link for a video of how to do it using a pop/water bottle. Â I attempted the bottle trick and it just broke the yolk so I gave up and separated the egg whites the old-fashioned way with the shells and scooped out the little bit of yolk that escaped. Â Good luck with whatever you decide to do.
 Next, "beat the egg whites until soft peaks form." I'm not really sure what this means but I used my mixer to beat the eggs for maybe 20 seconds until they looked like this:
Fold the egg whites into your batter (DON'T use your mixer for this part) and then fill cupcake liners. Â The recipe says to bake for 20 minutes or until the cupcakes "bounce back" when you touch them. Â If I made these again I'd probably cook them for 16 or 17 minutes instead of 20. Â
Now for the cream cheese/RumChata frosting:
(Make sure your cupcakes are cooled before frosting).
12 ounces cream cheese, room temperature
1/2 cup butter, also room temperature
1 package (2 lbs.) powdered sugar
I was really excited for this part because I randomly bought this bad boy at Walmart for like, $2 and have been waiting for a reason to use it:
Back to business. Â Combine the butter and cream cheese until they are smooth:
Next, add in the vanilla and SLOWLY add the powdered sugar. I emphasize the word slowly because I did this "slowly" (I added the bag of sugar in 5 parts) and still had a cloud of sugar EVERYWHERE. Â You might possibly change the genre of your background music to classical to calm your nerves as I had to at this point. Â After this step, add in 4-5 tablespoons of RumChata based on the thickness of the frosting.Â
I definitely recommend taste-testing at this point because the frosting is AMAZING. Â Now, get out your frosting tool and have at it, OR do what I ended up having to do and use a teaspoon to frost your cupcakes. Â I attempted the frost-er I had purchased and the amount of frosting that fit in it was about enough for 2 cupcakes and made a mess everywhere. Â
OH YEAH AND MY CUPCAKES LOOKED LIKE THIS:
It's been a while since my cake-decorating days, clearly. Â Using a teaspoon won't make your cupcakes look amazing, but they will be much better than my first three:
At this point I finally tried one and as I said before, it was a little overcooked and stuck to the paper, but wasn't too bad. Â The RumChata taste was pretty subtle and overall tasted like a recipe for pumpkin muffins that I make but you should try these at least once. After eating one and looking back at how ugly the rest of them are, I cried for a second before I realized I'm not meant to be a confectioner and at least I have content for this blog, leading to a good grade in the class this is for, thus, hopefully (keep your fingers crossed!) contributing to me getting my master's degree next year! And I have a bottle of RumChata (minus 1 cup and 4 tablespoons) now!