Aside from Toast (tragically not Omelette), all of the Clawthorne’s Palismen have names that are a pun. Owlbert and Hawksley— even Flapjack could be seen as a pun because “flap”.

Corvelius (corvus + Cornelius; means ‘horn’)

Corvwin (Corvus + Corwin; a name which means “heart’s friend”)

Corventin (Corvus + Corentin; means ‘tempest/hurricane’)

Edgar

Aside from Toast (tragically not Omelette), all of the Clawthorne’s Palismen have names that are a pun. Owlbert and Hawksley— even Flapjack could be seen as a pun because “flap”.

Corvelius (corvus + Cornelius; means ‘horn’)

Corvwin (Corvus + Corwin; a name which means “heart’s friend”)

Corventin (Corvus + Corentin; means ‘tempest/hurricane’)

Edgar

Aside from Toast (tragically not Omelette), all of the Clawthorne’s Palismen have names that are a pun. Owlbert and Hawksley— even Flapjack could be seen as a pun because “flap”.

Corvelius (corvus + Cornelius; means ‘horn’)

Corvwin (Corvus + Corwin; a name which means “heart’s friend”)

Corventin (Corvus + Corentin; means ‘tempest/hurricane’)

Edgar

Also, I think the odds of Lilith calling her Palisman Mike Socks, even as a nickname, seems out of character for her. Unless the Palisman named itself that and she had no say— we need to remember that Lilith’s “nicknames” for people are as follows:

Hootcifier. The only ‘official’ nickname Lilith has really given. Arguably more ‘regal’ than Hooty. I think Hooty might be the only person Lilith has actually given a nickname too.

Edalyn. The unshortened version of Eda’s name, which I only count as a nickname because I think Lilith might be the only character who calls her it

Sister. Also a “nickname” Lilith has given Eda.

As a general, Lilith speaks very formally. I do think if “Mike Socks” was a nickname of her Palisman, it would be one Eda used if anything.

Aside from Toast (tragically not Omelette), all of the Clawthorne’s Palismen have names that are a pun. Owlbert and Hawksley— even Flapjack could be seen as a pun because “flap”.

Corvelius (corvus + Cornelius; means ‘horn’)

Corvwin (Corvus + Corwin; a name which means “heart’s friend”)

Corventin (Corvus + Corentin; means ‘tempest/hurricane’)

Edgar

Aside from Toast (tragically not Omelette), all of the Clawthorne’s Palismen have names that are a pun. Owlbert and Hawksley— even Flapjack could be seen as a pun because “flap”.

Corvelius (corvus + Cornelius; means ‘horn’)

Corvwin (Corvus + Corwin; a name which means “heart’s friend”)

Corventin (Corvus + Corentin; means ‘tempest/hurricane’)

Edgar

Katara was a fundamentally good person from the start bc she had the means and the opportunity, and she was never afraid of anything as long as she had hope. Katara never did anything remotely similar to Zuko’s actions, let alone betrayed someone willing to give them a chance, so she had the right to make that speech to Zuko. Especially bc Zuko kinda helped his sister kill Aang and sent an assassin after them.

yes, Hunter threatened Luz and made Amity give up the key, but Amity was in a similar situation before. she let her “friends” bully Willow for years, and bullied Willow herself in their shared debut episode, because she was scared of her parents and failure. She almost had Luz dissected.

Amity is not some perfect person who’d be in the position to judge his actions, and she knows that. She’s been rebuilding the scraps of her friendship with Willow, and Willow and Luz both seem to trust Hunter in some way or another. I don’t think she’d be too shy about giving him a second chance if he showed he wanted to change. I can see her being hesitant that he might hurt her friends but all it would take is for her friends to say “well trust me on this” and she’d be like “okay I’ll try”

even if she was suspicious of him, chances are Hunter would be more suspicious of her being nice to him.

like Amity would be frustrated with him in the way she’s frustrated at her past self. she won’t exactly be giving a speech about how she’ll kill him if he hurts Luz.

We initially thought of Amity as a mean rich girl who bullies everyone, including Willow; however, as the series went on, we didn't see her as such, and after watching episodes beginning with "Lost in Language" and ending with "Understanding Willow", it all made WAY TOO MUCH sense on who she REALLY is and WHY she behaved the way she did:

Amity has a complex trauma (C-PTSD) from her upbringing; she was emotionally abused by Odalia, emotionally neglected by Alador who enables Odalia's abusive behavior, and even teased and pushed away by Emira and Edric. Because of that, Amity was raised as a miserable loner with no love or respect, and under Odalia's influence, she had been living a lie and putting on an act and façade (such as being bully to everyone, faking her desire of joining the coven which was forced upon by Odalia, associating with Boscha and her gang which was also forced upon by Odalia, etc).

Both "Lost in Language" and "Understanding Willow" made crystal clear without a shadow of a doubt that Amity was NEVER a bully she appeared to be; her selfish and harsh behavior was simply a reaction to how she was treated as a child, as well as her coping with not only her childhood trauma she had endured in years, but also her loneliness and misery as a result of Odalia forcing her to end her friendship with Willow. She never wanted to hurt Willow and was forced to do so; she was just pretending to dislike Willow and acting as a bully to protect her from Odalia and that's all. Compared with her favorite children's book character Odiban; Amity never had real friends and her friendship with Willow was forcefully cut off by Odalia, who bullied her into associating with Boscha, who was a real bully. She never considered Boscha and her gang as her real friends and never called them "her friends" at all. Odalia compelled Amity to get green hair because she wanted her children to be "color coordinated", despite the fact that Amity inherited her father Alador's hair color. All she wanted was love, respect, and a real friends who she can laugh with and grow together with, but they keep being taken away.

And here's more, Amity never wanted to join the Emperor's Coven; her seeming excitement to join it was, IN FACT, forced upon her by Odalia. Amity also hoped that if she will have to participate in something she dislikes, she might as well try to get something out of it for herself such as love and respect from her family and the others. Amity was expecting for a better future since, according to her sister Emira, the former wasn't happy in the past and it wasn't denied by Amity who was looking for a future that would make her happy, which ironically wouldn't have happened at all.

But when Luz came around (despite taking some time), Amity finally began to come out of the shell that Odalia forced her in and Amity became a better person for it.

Amity deserved to be mean to Luz? What the hell does that mean? You aren’t owed the pleasure of being mean to someone. If you aren’t happy with someone, that’s fair. You’re not obligated to be nice— being mean is a different subject.

Not being nice is like, refusing to swap pleasantries. Refusing to be polite.

Being mean is squashing the cupcake that belongs what you think is a pet, and is really an 8-year-old child. Being mean is, needlessly, posting something online you don’t think someone [Luz] will ever see and insulting them. (“#humanscanbiteit”)

Luz didn’t have a scroll or a penstragram. That was mean for the sake of mean. Does that mean Amity is a bad person? No, it means she’s 14 and traumatized. She was still a bully, and she was still mean.

Also, Amity may not have ever wanted to join the Emperor’s Coven— but she had, at that point, convinced herself she had. Self-gaslighting, if you will. At the end of Season 1, she had still “wanted” to join.

The point of my post was that Amity is in no place to judge Hunter, and she isn’t. She isn’t in any position to distrust him anymore than anyone else is, because a few months ago she was willing to dissect Luz. (And, objectively, Hunter was in a worse situation.)

Amity DIDNT try to dissect Luz. She was just trying to force Luz into revealing she wasn't an abomination. What she wanted was to prove Willow cheated. Luz wasn't tied up or anything, if she didn't want to get stabbed all she had to do was... move out of the way.

Amity didn't burn Willow's mind on purpose, she just didn't wanted Boscha and her gang to find out about her true friendship with Willow and especially Luz.

While in Willow's mind, the real reason Amity didn't wanted to fix the memory of her friendship with Willow is that she didn't want Luz to find out, because she was afraid Luz would judge her especially without the proper context and thought she'd end up losing another real friend.

In Hooty's Moving Hassle, the "humans can bite it" and the other mean comments were actually posted by Boscha, not Amity. You can figure that out because of how Amity was acting all throughout that episode with how indifferent she was being, so it's pretty easy to guess Amity wasn't the one who was posting those. And the other one where Amity's doing the peace sign duck lips pose was just a general post. Amity took that pic, but the comments and the actual posting of the pic were all Boscha.

Like I said before, Understanding Willow proves without a shadow of a doubt that Amity was never a bully: She only and I mean ONLY acted like that because Odalia forced her to. Everything we saw early on was Amity just putting on an act she was always just pretending to not care about Willow to make sure she didn't get kicked out of Hexside, cause Odalia said she'd do it if Amity maintained her friendship with Willow or being friendly with her. The point is Amity is not and never was a bully. This episode makes it clear that Amity never wanted to hurt Willow and was just forced into it, she always loved and cared about her best friend, because like I said before she was just putting on an act to protect Willow from Odalia and that's it. That's all it ever was.

Luz DID deserve for Amity to be mean to her though she wasn't ACTUALLY bullying her, she was just VERY ANGRY at her for helping Willow cheat in school, and as for King, she was only mean to him by ASSOCIATION because he knows Luz.

Willow did learned that Amity was never a bully and was just faking it to protect her and never wanted to betray or hurt her. They had reconciled in Understanding Willow and rekindled their friendship in Wing it Like Witches.

In Follies at the Coven Day Parade, when Amity said "I'm glad we can be like this again", Willow stopped smiling, now knowing that what she and Amity had before isn't the same as it was and she feels like it won't ever be that way again, even though she'd like it to be, but they are at the very least back to being friends again. Willow does trusts and forgives Amity.

Amity never had any social life after what happened with Willow, she couldn't stand Boscha and her gang and didn't have any actual friends until Luz. Once Luz befriended her, Amity's life got a million times better and she was actually happy for the first time in literal years.

Amity never wanted to join the Emperor's Coven; her seeming excitement to join it was, IN FACT, forced upon her by Odalia. Amity also hoped that if she will have to participate in something she dislikes, she might as well try to get something out of it for herself such as love and respect from her family and the others. Amity was expecting for a better future since, according to her sister Emira, the former wasn't happy in the past and it wasn't denied by Amity who was looking for a future that would make her happy, which ironically wouldn't have happened at all.

You are clearly an Amity Stan. I don’t have a problem with Amity as a character, but I hate just about any type of character stans to begin with, because— as demonstrated here— they are generally incapable of letting their faves have flaws.

Maybe one day you will recognize it is good for characters to have flaws, because without flaws, there is nothing to grow from.

It’s fine to headcanon Boscha posted and captioned those pictures on Amity’s scroll, but from a literary standpoint you have to understand there’s a rule in writing. Two, actually, that I think could apply: Show, don’t tell and Chekhov’s Gun.

If Boscha had really been the one to post or caption those pictures, there would have to be a verbal or visible nod to this for it to be considered canon. They would have to show it. An example would be, having Boscha ask if she can caption another photo for Amity.

Amity’s distant behaviour isn’t a sign she didn’t write the posts, it’s just a sign she is generally unhappy.

Additionally— the photos are used to motivate Willow to act recklessly because Amity used to be her friend. The significance of the photos in the first place is the rift between Willow and Amity. Willow doesn’t mention Boscha at all. It’d essentially be retconning it by having it be Boscha who wrote the posts all along.

As for the “humans can bite it” comment— Boscha literally wasn’t present for that. That scene happens after they’ve animated the house and Luz is expressing hesitance in showing off to Amity.

And it happens directly after we see Boscha on her way to Amity’s house. (They prank Boscha with the house and Boscha screams and runs off terrified.)

Boscha couldn’t have had anything to do with that. She couldn’t have posted on Amity’s penstagram, and she just got threatened by what she thinks is a talking, walking house that could crush her— bullying Luz is low on her priority list.

Also, don’t write threateningly-worded messages, especially if they’re in response to something you don’t understand.

Essentially: Hunter and Amity are character parallels. The show drew that parallel for a reason. Amity was able to see herself in Hunter’s struggles. That’s why she extends sympathy in the first place.

But Hunter saw an opportunity to go home, and his illusions weren’t shattered enough for him to accept her lifeline. That’s fine.

It took Amity more than once to accept Luz’s lifeline. If she didn’t at least try to give Hunter a second chance after he rejected her first lifeline, she would be hypocritical by definition.

The show didn’t do that, thankfully, because they didn’t want to make Amity a hypocrite— nor did they have the time for that drama.

also, just a p.s: TVTropes classifies Amity squashing King’s cupcake as Evil is Petty, in which “taking candy from a baby” falls under. In which a character who is a antagonist, minor or major, does some things solely for the sake of being a dick. That was absolutely Amity lashing out, and since King did nothing to deserve it, it was bullying.

You seem like someone who would argue with calling Amity an antagonist, so here’s the definition: “The principal character in opposition to the protagonist or hero of a narrative or drama”

Katara was a fundamentally good person from the start bc she had the means and the opportunity, and she was never afraid of anything as long as she had hope. Katara never did anything remotely similar to Zuko’s actions, let alone betrayed someone willing to give them a chance, so she had the right to make that speech to Zuko. Especially bc Zuko kinda helped his sister kill Aang and sent an assassin after them.

yes, Hunter threatened Luz and made Amity give up the key, but Amity was in a similar situation before. she let her “friends” bully Willow for years, and bullied Willow herself in their shared debut episode, because she was scared of her parents and failure. She almost had Luz dissected.

Amity is not some perfect person who’d be in the position to judge his actions, and she knows that. She’s been rebuilding the scraps of her friendship with Willow, and Willow and Luz both seem to trust Hunter in some way or another. I don’t think she’d be too shy about giving him a second chance if he showed he wanted to change. I can see her being hesitant that he might hurt her friends but all it would take is for her friends to say “well trust me on this” and she’d be like “okay I’ll try”

even if she was suspicious of him, chances are Hunter would be more suspicious of her being nice to him.

like Amity would be frustrated with him in the way she’s frustrated at her past self. she won’t exactly be giving a speech about how she’ll kill him if he hurts Luz.

We initially thought of Amity as a mean rich girl who bullies everyone, including Willow; however, as the series went on, we didn't see her as such, and after watching episodes beginning with "Lost in Language" and ending with "Understanding Willow", it all made WAY TOO MUCH sense on who she REALLY is and WHY she behaved the way she did:

Amity has a complex trauma (C-PTSD) from her upbringing; she was emotionally abused by Odalia, emotionally neglected by Alador who enables Odalia's abusive behavior, and even teased and pushed away by Emira and Edric. Because of that, Amity was raised as a miserable loner with no love or respect, and under Odalia's influence, she had been living a lie and putting on an act and façade (such as being bully to everyone, faking her desire of joining the coven which was forced upon by Odalia, associating with Boscha and her gang which was also forced upon by Odalia, etc).

Both "Lost in Language" and "Understanding Willow" made crystal clear without a shadow of a doubt that Amity was NEVER a bully she appeared to be; her selfish and harsh behavior was simply a reaction to how she was treated as a child, as well as her coping with not only her childhood trauma she had endured in years, but also her loneliness and misery as a result of Odalia forcing her to end her friendship with Willow. She never wanted to hurt Willow and was forced to do so; she was just pretending to dislike Willow and acting as a bully to protect her from Odalia and that's all. Compared with her favorite children's book character Odiban; Amity never had real friends and her friendship with Willow was forcefully cut off by Odalia, who bullied her into associating with Boscha, who was a real bully. She never considered Boscha and her gang as her real friends and never called them "her friends" at all. Odalia compelled Amity to get green hair because she wanted her children to be "color coordinated", despite the fact that Amity inherited her father Alador's hair color. All she wanted was love, respect, and a real friends who she can laugh with and grow together with, but they keep being taken away.

And here's more, Amity never wanted to join the Emperor's Coven; her seeming excitement to join it was, IN FACT, forced upon her by Odalia. Amity also hoped that if she will have to participate in something she dislikes, she might as well try to get something out of it for herself such as love and respect from her family and the others. Amity was expecting for a better future since, according to her sister Emira, the former wasn't happy in the past and it wasn't denied by Amity who was looking for a future that would make her happy, which ironically wouldn't have happened at all.

But when Luz came around (despite taking some time), Amity finally began to come out of the shell that Odalia forced her in and Amity became a better person for it.

Amity deserved to be mean to Luz? What the hell does that mean? You aren’t owed the pleasure of being mean to someone. If you aren’t happy with someone, that’s fair. You’re not obligated to be nice— being mean is a different subject.

Not being nice is like, refusing to swap pleasantries. Refusing to be polite.

Being mean is squashing the cupcake that belongs what you think is a pet, and is really an 8-year-old child. Being mean is, needlessly, posting something online you don’t think someone [Luz] will ever see and insulting them. (“#humanscanbiteit”)

Luz didn’t have a scroll or a penstragram. That was mean for the sake of mean. Does that mean Amity is a bad person? No, it means she’s 14 and traumatized. She was still a bully, and she was still mean.

Also, Amity may not have ever wanted to join the Emperor’s Coven— but she had, at that point, convinced herself she had. Self-gaslighting, if you will. At the end of Season 1, she had still “wanted” to join.

The point of my post was that Amity is in no place to judge Hunter, and she isn’t. She isn’t in any position to distrust him anymore than anyone else is, because a few months ago she was willing to dissect Luz. (And, objectively, Hunter was in a worse situation.)