Sometimes in the morning, me and my girlfriend ride the redline together. Only when she’s running late. (She’s running late a lot). Our eyelids are heavy, hair frizzy. She always looks different than she did an hour ago, her arms around me, warm. It’s not that her hair wasn’t frizzy- it’s that she’s vibrating now, winding up for the day. She looks beautiful, chewing on her chapped lips. We wait for my train, that comes at 7:12 everyday. I check my email. She sneezes. Somebody else on the platform says bless you. I keep reading my email. It smells like piss. I don’t reach for her hand. We sit together on the train. I smile at her, put my headphones in, pull a book out. I sneak peaks at her, sometimes, like a kid with a crush. Count the freckles on her cheek. Laugh at the way her hair is sticking up. Quick though, always quick, when nobody is looking. I promise you, when nobody is looking.

When the train pulls up at my stop, I pause. I always pause. Sometimes, I just tell her to have a good day. “Bye, Beth,” I say. “Have a good day!” Nothing else. Barely a smile. On the way home, I see other lesbians on the train. Other people see them too. Handsome, butch. People stare. They are unmistakable. Loud, vibrant, visible. They cannot hide. Still, they smile at me, in my patchwork jean jackets and long, floral skirts. They see me when nobody else can. I wonder if they can hear me too. If they could, I’d say this: Let me hide us both. Only for a moment, only until the woman with the pursed lips and sharp perfume gets off at Thorndale, or the man in the Cubs jersey glaring at you finds something else to be mad about. I can make it so we only see each other. I can make it so you’re safe. But I can’t. I’m not sure you’d want me too anyways. I just smile back. I love you, I say. And you say it back. It’s not enough. I get to say “Bye Beth! Have a good day!” Sometimes, I am so lucky, it makes my bones sticky, like a kid who’s gotten away with sneaking candy late at night, no chocolate mustache or grimy fingers. I get away. Bye Beth! Have a good day!

Sometimes, have a good day isn’t enough. Sometimes, I test my luck. I say I love you, squeeze her hand. I do it quick. I’m scared. I’m not brave. I made a call on the train, late at night. I said, “my girlfriend” on the phone. The man across from me licked his lips. When I hung up, he asked me if I was a lesbo, or something. I pretended I couldn’t hear him. He said it louder. I shook, slightly, closed my eyes. The seat seemed smaller, like it was trying to suffocate me, stained and still. He got up, sat next to me. Wanted to know if I heard him. Put his hand on my leg, calloused fingers. My heart was in my throat, heavy, strangling me. He gave up. Thank God, he gave up. I give up too. I just squeeze her hand, calloused, in a way I know, in a way that’s soft. I tell her I love her. She’s the only one who hears me.

Sometimes, I cup her face. I’m chicken. I don’t kiss her. I say I love you. I say it braver. I say it with everything in me. I look at her, so she can see all of me. The wrinkles in my heart and creases in my soul. She says it back. Once, a man pushed me, while I waited on the platform at Harrison. I was chatting with a friend. “I’m so gay,” I said. I think. Something. Had a stupid pin on, big letters. Something that broadcasted myself to the world. I was young, soul smooth, unblemished. I thought I was made of steel, the way I did when I was a child- skipping, running, shouting. I wanted to say excuse me, I wanted to say, what the fuck, but I couldn’t find my voice. I stared instead, misty eyed. “Fuck you, dyke, “ he said. I crawled into myself, walked back up the stairs, forgot where I was going. I felt like the little girl who stopped running and skipping and shouting when she fell on the sidewalk, two kneecaps scraped, the pain hissing and boiling. He got on the train, not a scratch on him.