NO NO NO NO NO NO WRONG.Â
I always see this post and it always irritates the shit out of me.Â
JK Rowling did not offer Evanna the part if she got better. And Evanna CERTAINLY didnât beg for it.Thatâs not what happened at all. While Evanna was doing inpatient therapy for her disorder she wrote to JK Rowling expressing her admiration for the author. She continued to write back and forth with JK Rowling from the age of eleven onward. That much is true. And JK Rowling did encourage and help her to fight the disease.
But Evanna stood in line with all of the REST of those FIFTEEN THOUSAND hopeful girls and won the part based on her TALENT ALONE. JK Rowling wasnât even aware that Evanna was the girl sheâd been exchanging letters with until AFTER she was already cast! Hereâs a quote from a Q&A with Evanna about this very subject
I wrote to her when I was 11, and I was sick at the time. I had an eating disorder. I wrote to her because Harry Potter was the only other thing I really cared about and that helped me take my mind off it, and I just wanted to thank her for that and say how much it helped me. Especially how much Luna helped me. It was basically just a big fat, âthank you, I love youâ letter.
I kept expecting her not to write back, but sheâs just such a caring person that she really wants to help with whatever wisdom she has. We wrote for years, and she helped me through recovery and everything.Â
I was still writing to her when I got the part of Luna. But it happened in such a short space of time that I didnât get to tell her. The producers told her because they just mentioned the names of people. She was really shocked. We still keep in touch.
So please for the love of god, stop reducing this fantastic actress and woman and human being to her disease. She didnât get better so she could play Luna. She got better just to get better. To have a wonderful life. And she probably worked incredibly fucking hard to do so. It was because she got better that she got the opportunity to play Luna and played her so beautifully, that JK Rowling wrote the character to be more like Evanna. Not the other way around.
Evanna Lynchâs story holds an incredible message for those fighting their respective eating disorders: 1. You donât have to starve yourself to be successful or even considered beautiful and 2. The only way to discover your potential, to fully live your life, is if youâre healthy and around to live it.Â
JK Rowling is a wonderful woman and she supported Evanna with her words and her stories. Sheâs done much the same for many of us. But Evanna Lynchâs recovery is not about JK Rowling.Â
Evanna is strong and capable and talented on her own. Everybody needs support now and again. But please, please, please DONâT praise JK Rowling for Evanna Lynchâs recovery. Thatâs not how it works. And the idea that you need someone else to come and fix you, to bribe you into recovering is dangerous and wrong. Recovery comes from within. Itâs about changing the way you think about yourself and food. The only way to recover is to make those difficult choices inside your own head, your own body. Nothing can change that.Â
This woman is proof that all of us, nerdy or bullied or odd like Luna, have the power to take control of our lives and conquer our demons. This woman is proof that hope is not silly. Finding solace in fiction is not frivolous.Â
Evanna Lynch is the hero of this story.Â