content warnings: angst with fluff, bittersweet ending, no y/n, use of nicknames (bunny, baby, darling), unwanted touch of another man, accusations of cheating, fighting, gator is a mean, insecure and jealous bitch, oral (f and m receiving), nipple play, p in v sex, creampie, switch!gator and reader, love confessions, gator becomes soft.
ethel cain – mondays
When you and Gator decided to go to the club together, you didn't think it'd end up with him throwing a tantrum—embarrassing you in front of everyone and making you feel like shit.
"Y'all were flirtin' in front of my face!" he raised his voice as you argued in your car, your face scrunching in disbelief at his words.
"Are you hearing yourself? I was not flirting with him!"
And you really weren't.
Earlier, at the club, Gator went to the bathroom and left you alone for a while, so you decided to wait by the bar and order a cup of water. When you drank, exhausted from all the dancing, you heard someone shouting your name—it was your old colleague from uni, Jack.
He came up to you, giving you an awkward hug, but you smiled at him nonetheless, keeping a light conversation about what you've been up to these past years.
It was brief, not really going into detail—just two people who used to know each other catching up.
But then he asked for your number, his hand sneaking up around your waist. You smiled uncomfortably, though still polite, because fuck...you really didn't want to cause a scene in case he tried to do something.
"Sorry, I have a boyfriend." you said, slowly freeing yourself from his grip. "But it was real nice seeing you."
It's like he didn't hear you at all, because his other hand landed on you too, his face inching closer as he said "I always liked you, you know? Such a pretty face."
But before you could do anything, his body was ripped apart from yours, almost falling over in the process.
"Get the fuck away from my girl."
Gator's voice was cold, but so powerful at the same time. You could swear the veins in his neck looked like they might pop any time, his hand latching onto the collar of Jack's shirt.
"Didn't know she was taken, dude." he said, lying like a bitch.
Gator's eyes found yours, his cheeks reddening with anger. "You didn't tell him?"
Was he really that dumb?
"Of course I told him!" you screamed, hands forming into fists. "He just didn't want to listen."
Jack was able to free himself, slowly stepping away from both of you, but not before he looked at you and said:
"It was nice seeing you again."
Oh, that made Gator furious.
He caught up to Jack in seconds, punching him two, maybe three times before some people forcefully took Gator away from him.
Jack's nose was bleeding, some of it spilling onto his shirt. He looked at you one more time and fucking smiled, before turning away and disappearing into the crowd of people that formed around you.
"You fuckin' serious? Flirtin' with that jackass when I was gone for five fuckin' minutes?"
Jackass. How fitting.
"I wasn't! He threw himself all over me!"
But he wasn't listening, spewing some bullshit accusations with anger.
"Gator, please." you stepped closer, catching his hand. "Not here."
He shook his hand away from yours, turning around and heading to the door.
When you caught up to him, he was leaning against your car, smoking a cigarette.
"You promised you wouldn't do that anymore." you said, standing before him.
"I can smoke if I want to."
You scoffed, pulling the cigarette from his mouth and taking a puff. "I'm not talking 'bout smoking."
He raised his brows, trying to get his cigarette back, but you threw in on the ground, your boot stomping on it as you looked at him.
"You promised you wouldn't cause more scenes. Wouldn't throw tantrums over the wrong things."
"And how the fuck was this wrong of me, huh?"
"Are you serious? He practically assaulted me and you took his side!" you screamed, stepping away and unlocking the car, slipping into the driver seat and taking a long, calming breath.
You turned on the engine when the passenger door opened, Gator flopping into the seat with a thud.
"I'm not talking to you right now." you said, overwhelmed with all that's happened.
It was one thing to get assaulted, and another to have your boyfriend, someone who was supposed to trust you, believe that you just let it happen.
"Great. Didn't want to anyway."
And that's how you got here, arguing while you drove through the highway.
"How long since ya been seein that guy?"
"Oh my god, what are you even talking about?"
He took his cap off, throwing it with unnecessary force. "That guy said "again", so obviously y'all know each other."
You exhaled, exhausted with his baseless accusations.
"We know each other from uni, used to have classes together. That's why he came up to me, tried to get my number."
"And?" Gator said, his tone filled with annoyance.
"And, I fucking told him that I have a boyfriend."
"Yeah, that's why your faces were inches away. Stop lyin' to me." he rolled his eyes, turning away from you and looking out the window. "Should've known it'd be like this."
"What the fuck is that supposed to mean?"
Annoyed, he ran a hand through his hair, messing up the usual, neat slicked-back style.
"You think I'm not good enough for ya, yeah? Have to get with another man."
He was actually insane. You couldn't believe that he would stoop so low, accusing you of cheating when you've always been loyal, staying by his side throughout all these months—the good and the bad.
"You're such a bitch, Gator."
You gripped the steering wheel harder, rage flooding through your whole body.
It shouldn't even be surprising, you two fought a whole lot. At this point it was your routine—meet up, have a good time for a while, then argue about something meaningless.
Then fuck, but we don't have to get into that.
But this was too much. It wasn't meaningless anymore—it was about your safety, your loyalty and respect that he had for you.
Or rather didn't.
"Real big of ya, callin' me fuckin' names."
"You're making shit up and then getting mad at it! I'm so over your attitude." you countered, speeding up and passing some other car on the usually empty highway.
"Then don't give me reasons to." he said, crossing his arms and looking at you accusingly.
That was enough, you had enough.
You slowed down, pulling to the side of the road.
"Get the fuck out."
It was quiet, like he didn't fully understand what you were saying.
"What?"
You closed your eyes, tears threatening to spill from them.
But your voice didn't waver when you ordered again.
"Get out of my car. I don't even want to be near you."
You heard him exhale, and then there it was—a light touch of his fingers to your forearm.
"Bunny–" he started, but you didn't let him finish.
"Get. the. fuck. out."
Every word was delivered slowly, putting as much coldness into them as you could.
Gator had to feel that, because seconds later he was outside, closing the door after him with force.
And when you finally opened your eyes and looked at him through the window, he was looking right back at you, his expression so incredibly painful, almost like he wanted to cry.
But you didn't let that get to you, not this time.
So you drove away, leaving him in the middle of the highway, his "stark county sheriff" cap laying forgotten in the backseat.
Gator🐊: call me back
Gator🐊: let's talk about this
Gator🐊: you can't ignore me forever
These kind of texts were waiting for you every time you picked up your phone.
He was really adamant on winning you back—didn't stop for two whole days.
On day one he came up to your house, telling you to come talk to him, but you only stood there, listening to his ramblings trough the door. You didn't open it for him.
The second day, he sent you flowers. Sure, they were pretty, and you put them on display on your kitchen counter, but the note attached to them ended up in the trash.
"Forgive me, bunny"
It wasn't that easy.
His words and accusations hurt you so bad, you ended up crying for the rest of the night that you left him. You woke up the next day, eyes swollen and red, missing sixteen of his calls and twenty unread texts. All of them a variation of the same things.
And then came day three, the one where you actually answered his call.
"What do you want?" you said coldly, trying not to cry again.
"Just wanna talk. Make things right." he answered, though he didn't try to hide the worry in his tone.
"Yeah, should've thought about that before you accused me of cheating."
"Bunny, come on–" he exhaled, and you could practically see him pacing around while talking. "I talked to the guy."
It was like your whole body froze, and then immediately started to boil in anger.
"What the fuck do you mean?"
"Ran into him the other day, his nose was fuckin' broken, can ya believe that? Didn't know I hit that hard." he laughed, though with no humor behind it.
"Gator. The point."
"'Ight, well..." he replied, stopping for a second before spilling it all out. "He was scared shitless, thought I'd beat his ass again, so I ordered him to tell me the truth or I actually would. So now I know you told him 'bout havin' a boyfriend, and didn't want to give him your number."
You could feel a tear coming down your cheek, your hands shaking with frustration.
"So you only believed it when it came from him. Not your girlfriend, not the one you should actually trust."
"Bunny, I'm real sorry, I didn't mean to blow up like that."
Funny, the word "sorry" was something you didn't expect to hear from Gator. He usually avoided it like fire.
"Yeah, 'course you didn't." you said, tears running freely now.
"I'm coming over. Be there in ten."
And just like that, he ended the call, deciding for the both of you like always.
You sat there on your couch, crying until you heard the doorbell—Gator actually keeping his word, how surprising.
You opened for him on weak legs, tired from all the pain he put you through.
But when you saw his face...he looked almost worse than you.
Bags under his eyes, hair loose and messy, lacking the usual shininess from the gel he used. He wore his casual clothes, plain jeans and a white t-shirt.
"Baby..." he muttered, looking at you with softness that you didn't really expect from him.
How full of surprises he was today.
"Great, now that you're here you can take your shit and go. Think your shampoo is still in my shower."
You didn't have to add that you used it yesterday, just to remember his scent.
"Not 'till you listen to me." he said, walking through the door and closing it behind him, heading towards your couch.
"What the fuck do you think you're doing?" you asked with annoyance.
"Just sit next to me, will ya?"
You sighed, too tired to argue with him even more. With careful steps, you headed towards the couch and sat on the opposite side of where he was, keeping a safe distance.
He had a way of winning you back with his...touch. You had to be careful.
"I was jealous. So fuckin' much that I wasn't thinkin' straight. My head just...convinced me I wasn't enough for ya. I mean, I know I'm not...I'm a fucking asshole, sayin' shit I don't mean when something hurts."
"Why did you think I was lying?" you asked, your voice sad but steady, not giving away to his words yet.
"'Cause I'm fuckin'...insecure or some shit. Hard to believe you're actually still with me."
"Gator..."
"No, really. But it's like...just tell me ya don't want me, don't flirt with other people."
"I wasn't."
"No, no I know that. I was jus' too caught up in my jealousy, thought ya didn't want me anymore."
"And you think I'd rather cheat on you than tell you that? If I did feel that way."
His cheeks went red, embarrassment creeping up on him. His explanation didn't made that much sense to you, but you also didn't get how he could be insecure.
"I'm such a fucking bitch." he said, his voice cracking slightly. "Bunny, I'm so, so sorry for everything. If you'd just...give me one last chance, swear I'd make this right."
You exhaled, your head spinning from all of the new information he gave you.
"I've been so loyal to you, Gator. Yeah, we fought a lot but I've never...not wanted you. You're the only one on my mind."
The lighting in your living room was weak, but you swore you saw a tear run down his cheek.
Gator Tillman didn't cry, right?
Then why was his voice so weak, when he uttered those three words to you.
"I love you."
Yes, you were in a relationship, but you never exchanged your feelings like that before. Never told him that you felt this way.
You stood up from the couch, your own eyes glazing with tears once again.
"You can't say things like that just because you want me to forgive you. That's fucking cruel."
Gator stood up too, coming closer and catching your hands into his, looking at you with something utterly soft in his eyes.
"Not lyin', bunny. I fuckin' love you so much."
Both of you stood there, crying softly while looking at each other and processing all that was happening.
"You're pretty when you cry." you said, and he laughed weakly, his hands hugging your waist.
"Don't get used to that."
The kiss that you shared after was like something you've never felt before. His taste mixed with salty tears, mouth working against yours like he was scared it would be the last time he got to kiss you—and maybe he was right, because you haven't really decided what's next.
You only knew that hearing him actually spill his feelings out for you, something he rarely did before, hearing him confess and cry for you...It made you want him more than you'd normally would.
"Bedroom, now." you said against his lips, and he actually whimpered, lifting you up and heading there while you still kissed, knocking over some things in the process.
When he lowered you onto the carpeted floor, you took him by the collar, making him look at you.
"On your knees."
"Bunny–"
"Now."
Usually, he was the one taking control, but fuck, you just had to put him to use after all that he's done.
You expected him to argue, but he was kneeling before you in seconds, taking off your shorts as you got rid of your shirt, tossing it somewhere on the floor.
Thank goodness you didn't have any underwear on.
"Such a pretty pussy." he murmured, gaze fixed on the already wet flesh.
"Touch me." you ordered, looking down at his face.
He caught your gaze, his finger making contact with your clit, moving it in slow circles.
You exhaled, already feeling your shoulders relax. You focused on his face as he focused on yours, bringing his mouth to your wet pussy.
He started slowly, licking into you like he was tasting you for the first time. Then, he went deeper, tongue between your folds as he moved with precision.
"Fuck..." you moaned, arching your back and pushing yourself forward into his face even more.
"Tastes like fuckin' heaven." he said, the vibration of his voice going through you.
"More, Gator." you whined, looking at him through halfway opened eyes.
He listened, adding one, then two fingers, going in and out of your entrance while still eating you out, his mouth working eagerly.
"Oh fuck." you breathed, your eyes rolling back as you felt your approaching orgasm.
"Come on, darlin'. Give it to me."
You came with a cry, latching onto his hair. You rode his face, prolonging your pleasure as he drank up every single drop of what you gave him, moaning into you with excitement.
When you stepped away from him, you didn't wait long. Your thighs clenched together again as soon as you looked down—his chin glistening with your juices and his spit, hair messy where you pulled at it, and his cock, so obviously hard, straining against his zipper.
"Take your clothes off." you ordered again, stepping backwards and laying down on the bed while still looking at him.
"Yes ma'am." he said, and you smiled at the serious way in which he addressed you.
Maybe you should take control more...
His clothes were on the floor in seconds, joining the pile of your own.
"Where do you want me?" he asked, slipping out of his underwear.
His cock was painfully hard, leaking from the top down his length.
"Next to me."
And when he was, you sat on your knees between his thighs, fingers curling around his cock.
"Bunny, please..." he breathed, his hips jerking up as soon as you made a little bit of movement.
"You're surprisingly nice to me today." you laughed, slowly working him up and down.
"I– need ya so bad. Dreamed of this...fuck...pussy every night." he confessed, moaning softly as you touched him.
"Yeah? Even when I was mad you only thought about my pussy?" you taunted, though you knew that wasn't what he meant.
"Stop playin', ya know what I– Oh, fuck." you interrupted him with your mouth closing around his cock.
Your head bobbed on him, up and down, until he was whining and moaning under you like a bitch.
Then, you stopped and laid next to him, laughing at his confusion.
"Such a tease."
"Better show me what you've dreamed of."
Now, it was his turn to lay between your thighs, his mouth finding yours and kissing you. His tongue fought with yours as his fingers closed around your hard nipple, squeezing and playing with it just how he knew you liked.
His kisses went lower—to your neck, collarbone, where he gently bit the skin there, and finally to your other nipple.
His tongue swirled around it, sucking and biting gently, causing you to moan out his name.
"Yeah? Ya like it?" he asked, smiling against your skin.
"Yes, Gator. Oh, fuck–" you answered, words becoming a breathless moan when you felt the tip of his cock gently pushing between your folds.
"You want it? Tell me you do."
"Please." you nodded, your glances meeting as he pushed himself deeper.
He kissed you just as he bottomed out, his hips slowly backing out almost all the way and slamming back into you again.
"Never want to get over you." he murmured, the sound of skin slapping against each other starting to fill the room.
"Gator..." you moaned, his cock pushing harder, meeting all the perfect places in you.
"Yeah? Like when I go deep? When I fuck ya like I hate ya?"
And you could only nod, because you knew that he was right. You loved when he slammed into you like this, your whole body buzzing with pleasure.
Without a warning, he moved your body like it weighed nothing, turning it around and positioning you on your elbows and knees, your ass in the air and perfectly on display for him.
He slammed back into you, one hand placed on your hip as the other sneaked to your peaked nipple, squeezing it as he pleased.
"You're fuckin' gorgeous." he breathed, his hips meeting your ass with every thrust. "Made for me."
It was straight up obscene—the way you moaned around his cock, pleasure overwhelming your senses. Your back arched as he pushed himself deep into that one special spot, drool pooling in your constantly open mouth, unable to close under all the sensation.
"Gator, I'm..." you tried to warn him, but he only went faster, slamming into your dripping entrance.
"Me too, baby. Come with me."
His words tipped you over, his name spilling from your mouth as he spilled into you, your pussy clenching on his length.
"Fuck...you're so good to me, so right." he babbled as you felt the warmth of his cum going down your thigh.
You stayed like this for a while, calming your ragged breathing, until he took himself out, placing a sweet kiss just above your ass.
He helped you lay on your back, then cleaned the mess between your thighs as you drifted in and out of consciousness, too tired and fucked out to do it yourself.
Finally, with Gator and you under the sheets, you looked at him, and smiled softly.
"I love you too, you know?"
He stilled, eyes widening.
"Say that again."
You laughed, coming up to his mouth and kissing it gently. He kissed back, hand cradling the back of your neck like he didn't want you to stop.
"I love you too." you repeated.
He exhaled against you and then kissed you with more force, a tear spilling from his eye once again.
"Does that mean that I get another chance?" he asked, his eyes glossy and hopeful.
"Gator, I– Let's talk about this tomorrow, okay?"
"But you said–"
"I know what I said. Me loving you doesn't change the fact that you've hurt me. Many, many times."
"I get that." he said, voice cracking. "And I'm sorry."
You exhaled, gently touching his cheek. "I know you are, Gator. So give me time to think, yeah?"
"Yeah. As long as ya need, bunny."
And he meant it, because when Gator Tillman loved someone? He loved with his whole being—even when he was bad at showing it.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
♡ Joe Keery / Djo Two Worlds One Choice- Masterlist ♡
Chapter 1 — The Library
Chapter 2 — The Moment He Turned Back
Chapter 3 — Art, Armor, and the Almost Moment
Chapter 4 — The Kiss
Chapter 5- Electric Lady
Chapter 6- The Line We Didn't Cross
Chapter 7-Halfway to Something
Chapter 8- Rooftop Mornings
Chapter 9- Figure you out
Chapter 10- Half Life
Chapter 11- The Point Of No Return
Chapter 12- Mutual Future
Chapter 13- Change
Chapter 14-Back On You
Chapter 15- On and On
Chapter 16- End Of Beginning
Chapter 17- Awake
Chapter 18- The Space Between Screens
Chapter 19- Keep Me In Your Orbit
Chapter 20- Star Chart
Chapter 21- Chateau
Chapter 22- Half In The Bubble Half In The Noise
Chapter 23- Sunlight, Paper, and Him
Chapter 24- Caught in Your Reverb
Chapter 25- The Moment Bends Sideways
Chapter 26- Fool
Chapter 27- For You
Chapter 28- Potion
Chapter 29- Gap Tooth Smile
Chapter 30- What’s a Good Life?
Chapter 31- The Sound Of Staying
Chapter 32- You Stole My Best Friend
Chapter 33- Streamers and Sunlight
Chapter 34- One Last Choice
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
summary: when you bring your newborn home from the hospital, gator finally hits the point of freaking out. your baby has a way of calming her dad down.
tags/warnings: husband!gator x reader, no use of y/n, established relationship - marriage, soft!gator, girl dad!gator, domestic fluff, character study, gator tillman holding a teeny little baby
---
“Gator, watch her head– watch– hang on, let me get the door.”
You take a full breath to try and quell your own panic as you watch your husband make his way into your house with your newborn daughter. It’s been two days since she was born, and he’s still holding her like she’s radioactive– with the kind of gentle trepidation that betrays how nervous he is about somehow breaking her. You’re not one to talk, though– you’ve been in a state of shock since you first heard her cry.
That’s how everyone’s told you it’ll be with your first. There’s been no end to the stories you’ve heard about how you and Gator are destined to fumble along blind in this.
Gator rounds the corner, your daughter tucked tight into his chest in a hold that looks suspiciously similar to how you’ve seen him carry a football. “Baby– babe, where am I takin’ her?”
You trail behind him, peering over his shoulder to check that your daughter’s face is still caught in that sleepy, contented expression you already adore. “Just– just go to the living room, I guess,” you offer helplessly. “I don’t know, Gator. She’s not asleep yet.”
“Okay. Okay,” he repeats, a renewed focus in his step as he ever-so-carefully treads toward the living room.
Your daughter June was born at 6:14 on a Monday morning. June like June Carter, the one country artist you and Gator can ever compromise on; June like your favorite month of the year, sticky-sweet, playful, full of tall, emerald grasses and rope swings suspended over creek beds and barbecue smoke in the air. Gator had joked that she must have had the basics of life down already, waking your asses up right before the start of the week. Tillmans were always good at being difficult.
When they make it to the sofa, Gator hesitates, looking back at you. “Here— sit down, mama. I’ll bring in the bags.” With the care of someone diffusing a bomb, he hands you your daughter, ushering you back toward the couch. You accept the baby and sit down, grunting a little at the strain on your sore body. “Forget the bags, Gate. Just come sit with us for a second.”
“I’ll be right back,” he promises, shaking his head. You frown a little at the speed with which he abandons the two of you, like he can’t stare at your daughter for too long or she’ll somehow combust. He’s always hated to feel like a coward, but he's fleeing the room right now.
When he finally returns, all the bags stowed in your bedroom for the two of you to bother to unpack later, his expression isn’t any less full of that humming, restless anxiousness. He shifts from foot to foot, wringing his hands a little, like he’s waiting for you to assign him another task. Like he needs you to.
“Gate,” you say again, attempting to soothe him with your voice as you gently bounce your daughter in your arms, “Baby, I don’t think you’ve sat down since this morning. Why don’t you just take a breath– stop moving for a second.”
He shakes his head immediately, clapping his hands together. “Can’t. Can’t sit down.”
“Why not?” you press him.
“Too much to do,” he explains, looking around the living room like he’ll find some sort of chore there. But the house is clean, there's a casserole in the fridge to heat up if you get hungry later, and the only thing left to do is unpack the hospital bags, which shouldn’t take more than ten minutes. You made sure everything was settled before you left, and he knows it.
“There’s nothing to do,” you argue mildly. “She’s not even due for another feeding.”
Gator starts pacing, back and forth and back and forth. He’s not looking at you. “Think I forgot to lock the truck. I should go–”
“Gator,” you interject, your voice stern. “Why won’t you settle down?”
Gator finally turns to you, his lips set in a line. “Because if I take a second to think, I’m gonna start thinking about the fact I have a fuckin’ kid,” he hisses, like the low tone will stop her hearing him.
“Oh, and it’s just sinking in now?” you snap, wishing you could keep your temper even. Damnit, but you’re tired and still sort of in pain and you smell like a hospital. And you wish your husband could get his shit together so you could be the one complaining right now.
“Yeah, kind of, baby,” Gator fires back, running a hand through his hair. He drops into a crouch suddenly, blowing out a breath. “I’m freakin’ out. I’m freakin’ out, mama.”
“Breathe, Gator,” you order him, grateful he's at least talking about it now. “You freaking out isn’t gonna make her any less… born.”
“I can’t do this,” he heaves. “I can’t be a dad. No fuckin’ way.”
“You’ll figure it out,” you reply dryly, unperturbed. “Better get with the program, cause she’s here.”
“I’m a fuckin’ idiot!” he protests, rising from his crouch to spread his hands and stare at you. “I can’t figure shit out. I’m probably gonna pass that to her.”
“You’re not an idiot.” you say firmly. “You figured out how to be a husband, didn’t you?”
“Barely,” he snaps.
“Gator,” you meet his eyes, turning your baby in your arms to show him her face. “Look at her.”
You watch as his eyes fall slowly to June, and his posture shifts almost imperceptibly— tension melting, expression softening. The panic fades little by little and then altogether.
“Shit or get off the pot,” you tell him. “If you’re gonna get on board and be a dad, now’s the time. Do you want her?”
Gator nods, stare caught on her sleepy face.
“Good,” you finish, eyeing him. “She wants you, too.”
He hesitates. “Can I—“
“Hold her?” you guess. “You don’t have to ask, Gate. She’s yours.”
With hands that you can tell are still shaking slightly, he lifts her out of your arms again, that tiny bundle of blankets and soft limbs, and tucks her into his own. His eyes are locked onto her, his jaw clenching and unclenching. “Hey, girlie,” he musters, his voice low and scratchy.
Your lips pull upward, your brow knitting. “Is that better?”
Gator nods, biting his lip as he stares down at her. He starts rocking a little, side to side.
You rise from the couch, getting close enough to peer into his arms and run a finger down June’s soft cheek. You mumble softly to her, “Your dad’s fucking crazy, just so you know.”
“Sorry,” Gator tells you, real emotion in the word.
You run a hand down his arm. “I’m gonna go to the bedroom for a bit. Just take a second with her and breathe, okay, baby?”
He nods again, looking a little lost for words. “You’re not worried I’m gonna break her, or something?” he asks, glancing up as you leave his side.
You snort, roll your eyes, and don’t bother to reply. And when you glance back at him, that little action looks like it shocks Gator most of all.
Gator Tillman is going to be killed by his daughter June. He knows it for a fact.
She’s staring up at him right now with that sleepy, wrinkled, barely-awake newborn face. She’s got that baby smell, like warm milk. And her black eyes, the ones that are just learning how to blink, are fixed on his.
Gator has black eyes. He’s always hated his eyes. They’re too dark, like twin pits in his head, boring into other people’s faces, setting everyone on edge. And he gave them to his daughter. And they don’t look so bad on her, as a matter of fact.
June blinks up at him, her face blank. She’s scrutinizing him, judging his reaction– he can tell. Maybe she sees the softness in his face, the way he’s completely crumpled in front of her, and knows already what a loser he is for her.
But that’s just how it is now– unavoidable. Gator Tillman is a loser. He’s lost. He cares too much, loves too hard, has altogether too many things to lose, and so he’s been defeated in the game he’s been fighting his entire life. The love swarming in his chest is so huge, so unshakable, that he knows instantly this is what his dad always warned him against feeling— devotion to the point of weakness. Loving something so much it could control you— could kill you, just like the look in his daughter’s eyes is. And right now, holding June, he’s struggling to remember why he ever bothered to fight it in the first place.
“You don’t say much, do ya?” he asks her, the words quiet enough that his wife won’t hear him from the bedroom.
June blinks back. Doesn’t so much as babble.
“Gonna be an easy baby?” he asks her, bouncing her a little. “No cryin’ all the time? Give your mama a little break?”
Another blink.
“You’re quiet already,” he observes, jaw ticking. “I was always screamin’ as a baby. You must not be a Tillman after all.”
June’s mouth opens in a little O as she yawns widely– like his self-depreciation is somehow boring to her. She gets that from her mom.
“Bet you’re gonna be the best baby there is,” he murmurs. “Probably gonna beat all the other kids by a mile.” He shifts on his aching feet, his gut twisting a little as his own words ring an old bell in his head. “Aw, who am I fuckin’ kiddin’?” he complains, blowing out a breath. “I’d be fine with it if you were the biggest loser on Earth.”
She stares back up at him, making no move to struggle against her swaddle, the pinning of her tiny arms.
“You don’t know much ‘a anything, do ya?” he realizes. She might have his eyes, but she’s nothing like him– doesn’t have the capacity to be. Nothing’s learned or set in stone. Nothing’s infecting her the way it did him, passed down by each carrier of their last name, willed into being like it was a simple fact of who they were. There’s no evil in her– no cruelty. No violence. He’d see it in her eyes if there was. “That makes two of us,” he huffs.
Slowly, he shifts the baby slightly in his arms so she can see around her, then turns in place. “Chair,” he says, gesturing to the armchair that’s become cemented as his in the time he’s owned this house with you. “Couch,” he tells her. “You can have that seat if you want. Mom likes the left side.”
He goes on naming furniture like a lunatic, letting June’s eyes sweep over it, assessing. She must be smart, he thinks to himself– smart enough to already know what’s happening around her, to look into her dad’s face and read him down the blackened core of who he is. Smart enough not to have gotten her brain from him.
He doesn’t know what to do about any of it. He doesn’t know what to do now– letting his baby girl judge him, going completely still under his stare, giving him that same look he’s so used to– the one that says, well, kid, you better not fuck this one up. Better be good for her. Better figure it out before he inevitably mars the first perfect thing that’s ever been put in his hands.
But his panic has faded, pushed back into some crevice of his chest. He’s breathing June in, and that scent, the compact weight of that little bundle, is calming him completely. He stays like that for a long moment, his daughter inches from his face. She lets out a breath through her nose.
“Alright, fine,” he mumbles, softer than he’s ever said anything. “I’ll be your dad.”
He wouldn’t know the first thing about doing it right. When you’d told him you were pregnant in the first place, he’d barely made it through the hugging you and reassuring you and smiling like it felt like good news long enough to get you out of the room– just in time, ‘cause the second you were gone, he’d run to the bathroom and puked his guts up. And he’d spent the following nine months being out-of-his-mind terrified. And two days ago, watching you grip his hand as you bore down, he’d thought that maybe that anxiety attack bullshit you were always goin’ on about might be worth looking into.
But he’s not thinking about any of that right now. His daughter is in his arms. She weighed 6 pounds, 4 ounces when she came out– so tiny. A fraction of what he’s been training himself for years to lift, and yet every time he holds her, she’s pinning him down. She’s a fragile, delicate little thing. She’s the heaviest thing he’s ever carried.
And his breathing is even. And his throat has lost its tightness. And he’s staring back into her black eyes and promising himself silently that there isn’t a minute of an hour of a day of the rest of his life that he’ll waste not being the best father on the planet for her. He doesn’t care what it takes– promotions at the station or years of therapy or unravelling the screwed-up neurons in his brain one by one. He’d die for her, easy. He’d do it in a second. But he’d change for her, too. And there’s no violence left in him except for the magnitude of what he feels in his chest for her.
Gator leans down and presses a gentle kiss to her cheek, fighting the sting in his eyes. “Love you, girlie.”
June blinks, as if satisfied by his words. And then her eyelids lower slowly, and she goes to sleep in his arms.
It’s later and dark outside when the three of you start getting ready for bed.
June has been passed out since five o’clock, and you and Gator have been trading off holding her while she sleeps since then. You’re already getting rather good at doing things one-handed, to your own pride.
But now, you’ve been sitting in your bedroom for almost fifteen minutes, and you haven’t seen Gator since he left to go set June in her crib in the nursery. Slowly, you ease off the bed and make your way down the hallway toward the room. The door’s slightly ajar, the only light coming from the glowing nightlamp in the corner. You find Gator standing over the crib, his hands braced on the wood as he stares down at a sleeping June.
You come up behind him and wrap your arms around his middle, pulling him close to you. His hand moves to cover yours, but he doesn’t break his stare.
“Come to bed,” you whisper.
He doesn’t respond. When you peer over his shoulder, trying to glimpse his face, you realize his jaw is clenched tightly, his eyes soft. Like he’s torn between fierce protection and gentle care.
“She’s not going anywhere,” you tell him quietly.
“I know,” he murmurs back.
You stay with him like that for a second, your fingers scratching lightly against his stomach.
“She’s so little,” he finally admits, eyes locked onto June’s sleeping face.
You hum in reply, a smile pulling at your face. He says it like it’s shocking to him– like it’s worrying him. Like he thinks if he looks away, that vulnerability that’s always felt like a curse to him will rear up and bite him again, and all the good things in this nursery will disappear.
“Nothing’s gonna happen to her, Gator,” you assure him, the words soft.
He shakes his head. “It might.”
“The monitor’s on,” You remind him. “We’d hear her cry. You sleep light, anyway.”
“Something might happen,” he repeats, firmer. The way he’s gripping the wood tells you just how terrified he is.
“You built the crib,” you go on. “You know how sturdy it is. And you set up the alarm system, too.”
He shakes his head again, unconvinced.
Your hands keep scratching at his abdomen, trying to calm him. “You need to sleep, baby. You’ve been up for forever. Come to bed.”
“Can’t.”
You keep holding him, understanding the paralysis that’s keeping him poised here— the protecting hes telling himself he needs to do. Gator had told you once that he’d never felt like he owned much— never had much that was his alone. And the things he did possess— the people he cared most for, his wife and his daughter—those were to be held onto with an iron grip. Those were to be safeguarded at any cost; one that outweighed his own trauma and hurt and self-loathing. That’s who Gator was— iron-fisted. Iron-hearted.
You see it now, in the set of his shoulders, the breathing your daughter has seemed to inexplicably steady. The determination in his stark face turned gentle, turned diligent, filled by devotion.
“Everything’s gonna be okay,” you promise him. “We’re gonna be good, Gate.”
So many promises are wrapped up in those few words. We’re gonna be safe. We’re gonna do this right. You’re gonna be the dad she needs you to be. You wonder if he hears it, or if it’s another of the sweet nothings you sometimes attempt to utter into the abyss his father carved into him.
But Gator’s hand tightens over yours, and as he squeezes you back, he only says, “Okay.”
---
author's note: if you guys would let me know if there are errors in this that would be hella chill 'cause I do not have it in me to read this again right now
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
Summary: Steve expects just another birthday. Instead, he discovers he's spent years building himself the family he'd always dreamed of.
Warnings/tags: 18+ ONLY, minors DNI, no use of y/n, established relationship, fluff, hurt/comfort, mentions of a neglectful childhood (steve's), found family, angst, everyone loves steve harrington (lmk if i missed anything)
A/N: pls blame jess (@holawdw) for the emotional damage 😭😭 thank you SO much for giving me this idea and then spending several days screaming about it with me in dms because i genuinely don't think i would've written this without you. i knew the second you said it that this had to become a fic. i really hope i did your beautiful idea justice. thank you for trusting me with it, and thank you for emotionally ruining both me and steve 🫶
W/C: 8k
Read more of my writing here: [masterlist]
If you want to be added to my taglist, leave a comment to lmk!
You wake before Steve does.
The curtains are still only half-lit, the early morning sun filtering through the gaps in soft bands of gold that stretch lazily across the bedroom floor. Outside, Hawkins hasn't quite decided to wake up yet. Somewhere in the distance a lawnmower coughs into life before giving up again, birds chatter noisily from the oak tree outside the window, and the whole house sits in that strange, peaceful quiet that only exists before the rest of the world remembers itself.
Steve is still asleep beside you, one arm escaped from beneath the duvet during the night, stretched lazily across the mattress until his fingertips brush yours, as though even unconscious he has some quiet need to know you're still there. His hair sticks up in every possible direction, flattened on one side and hopelessly unruly on the other, his face softer in sleep than it ever is when he's awake.
You smile to yourself.
Twenty-three.
It feels impossible somehow - not because twenty-three is particularly old, but because you've spent long enough loving Steve to remember nineteen. Twenty. Twenty-one. Twenty-two. Every version of him that existed between those birthdays and this one. Each year he'd grown a little gentler, a little quieter in himself, as though life had slowly been teaching him that he no longer had to carry everything alone.
Carefully, so as not to wake him too suddenly, you lean across and press a kiss against the centre of his forehead.
His nose wrinkles immediately. A low, sleepy groan rumbles somewhere beneath the blankets before one eye cracks open just enough to find you. "...Morning."
"Morning, birthday boy."
His expression falls with almost theatrical disappointment. "...Do I have to get older?"
You laugh quietly. "I'm afraid you don't have much choice."
"I was hoping we could skip this one."
"I'll write to the calendar."
"You think it'd listen?"
"Probably not."
He sighs dramatically before rolling onto his back, staring up at the ceiling with the sort of resignation usually reserved for tax returns and dentist appointments. "...Worth asking."
You reach over to smooth an impossibly stubborn piece of hair away from his forehead. "You know," you say, "most people get excited about their birthday."
Steve hums. "I know."
"You don't."
Another small shrug. "I've just never really been bothered."
He says it so casually that anyone else might have believed him.
But you've known him long enough to understand the difference between someone who doesn't care and someone who learned, very early on, not to expect much in the first place.
Steve never disliked birthdays. That wasn't it. He'd simply stopped allowing himself to build them into something worth looking forward to.
Growing up, they were... fine.
There'd usually be a couple of presents, carefully chosen by parents who knew roughly what an eight-year-old boy ought to like but never quite what their eight-year-old boy actually did. His mother insisted on the same dense, healthy carrot cake every year because she preferred it to chocolate, somehow never stopping to consider that perhaps the birthday boy himself might have had other opinions.
Sometimes his parents were away entirely, leaving him with grandparents or a childminder and promising they'd celebrate properly when they got back. Sometimes they were there, though never really present. A birthday dinner if everyone happened to be home. A quick "happy birthday" over breakfast before somebody rushed off to a meeting. There was never anything cruel about it.
Just... distance.
Nothing bad enough to complain about.
Nothing good enough to miss.
By the time you'd met him, birthdays had become something he accepted with the same quiet indifference he accepted rainy Tuesdays or running out of milk. Nice enough if somebody remembered. Easily forgotten if they didn't.
He catches you looking at him. "What?"
You realise you've been absent-mindedly tracing your thumb across the back of his hand. "Nothing."
"Your face tells me it isn't nothing."
You smile. "I was just thinking."
"Dangerous."
"Oh, absolutely."
He grins, the corners of his eyes creasing in that familiar way that still makes something inside your chest soften. Then, just as quickly, he stretches with another sleepy groan and reaches for his glasses on the bedside table.
"So..." He pushes them onto his nose. "...What's the plan today?"
The question is completely innocent.
There's no expectation behind it. No hopeful curiosity. No excitement. Just the quiet assumption that whatever happened would be perfectly nice, and perfectly ordinary.
You hold his gaze for a moment before leaning across to steal one more kiss.
"Oh," you murmur, smiling against his cheek. "I think you're going to have a very different birthday this year."
Robin is the first to arrive.
You hear her before you see her.
The front door flies open without so much as a knock, followed almost immediately by, "HAPPY BIRTHDAY, DINGUS."
Steve has barely managed to look up from the mug of coffee in his hands before something rectangular bounces unceremoniously off the side of his head.
"...Ow."
"You're welcome."
He picks the envelope up from the floor, turning it over suspiciously.
Across the front, written entirely in thick black marker, are the words:
HAPPY BIRTHDAY, DINGUS.
Beneath them, in much smaller handwriting:
Don't let this inflate your ego.
Steve laughs quietly through his nose. "I haven't even opened it yet."
"I know." Robin folds her arms with exaggerated satisfaction. "I just wanted to establish the tone."
You disappear into the kitchen under the pretence of making more coffee, partly because somebody has to rescue breakfast before it burns, and partly because you've known Robin long enough to recognise the expression she's trying very hard to hide.
She's nervous.
Steve, blissfully unaware, slides a finger beneath the flap and unfolds the card.
Silence.
Then another page unfolds.
And another.
Steve blinks. "...Robin."
"What?"
"It's..." He flips another page over. "...Really long."
She shrugs with studied indifference. "I got carried away."
"What did you write?"
"I don't know."
"You wrote it."
"I wasn't paying attention."
He gives her a look.
She refuses to meet it.
You watch him begin reading.
The smile appears immediately, tugging at one corner of his mouth as he reaches the first insult.
Happy Birthday to Hawkins' second-biggest idiot.
Congratulations on somehow surviving another year despite making some of the dumbest decisions I've ever witnessed.
He snorts.
Robin looks insufferably pleased with herself.
Then the smile begins to change.
It softens almost imperceptibly, his eyes moving more slowly across the page now.
You can't read the words from where you're standing, but you know Robin well enough to know exactly what she'll have hidden between the jokes.
She'll have thanked him for making Family Video bearable, for never making her feel like she had to be anyone other than herself, for listening when she came out without making it weird, without asking questions she didn't want to answer, without changing the way he looked at her afterwards. She'll have written about Starcourt. About Russian secret bases and demobats and everything in between. About the fact that, somehow, Steve Harrington had quietly become the safest place she'd ever known.
By the time he reaches the final page, the kitchen has gone strangely quiet. Robin is studying a loose thread on her sleeve with almost academic concentration.
Steve clears his throat before reading the last line aloud, his voice noticeably softer than before. "'Don't get emotional.'" He smiles to himself. "'I'm only saying this once.'"
Robin points at him immediately. "Exactly."
"You literally wrote three pages."
"I know."
"You called me your favourite person."
"I was clearly concussed."
"You said you'd trust me with your life."
"I mean..." She sighs dramatically. "I would."
His smile grows impossibly soft. "You know..." He glances down at the card again. "...Thank you."
Robin groans so loudly you almost laugh. "Ugh."
"What?"
"Stop looking at me like that."
"Like what?"
"Like you're about to hug me."
Steve doesn't even pretend to think about it. He simply walks around the table and wraps his arms around her.
Robin lets out the most exaggerated sigh you've ever heard. "This is disgusting."
"You started it."
"I wrote a card."
"You wrote three pages."
"I regret everything."
"No, you don't."
"...No."
She hugs him back anyway. Only for a second. Only because nobody's looking.
Except you absolutely are.
When they finally pull apart, Robin immediately pokes him in the shoulder.
"If you tell anybody I have feelings, I'll deny the whole thing."
Steve laughs. "My lips are sealed."
"They'd better be." She narrows her eyes. "And if you cry..."
"I'm not going to cry."
"You looked dangerously close."
"I wasn't."
"You were."
"I definitely wasn't."
Robin glances towards you. "He was, wasn't he?"
You smile over the rim of your coffee mug. "A little."
"I wasn't."
"You've still got watery eyes."
"It's allergies."
"In February?"
"...Shut up."
The conversation drifts naturally onto something else after that.
Dustin is apparently running late. Robin immediately starts complaining about his inability to tell the time while Steve joins in as though nothing unusual has happened, the two of them slipping back into familiar bickering before Nancy wanders in from the hallway carrying an armful of paper plates, looking between them with a knowing smile. "He's late again?"
Robin throws her hands into the air. "When isn't he?"
The room fills with laughter, and before long the conversation has moved on entirely.
Later, while everyone else is distracted in the kitchen and Robin is attempting to convince Joyce that frozen chips absolutely count as a vegetable, you catch Steve standing alone in the hallway.
The card is open again.
He's reading the third page for a second time, his thumb lingering over the final paragraph before he quietly folds it closed with surprising care. The smile on his face is small, thoughtful, the sort that only ever appears when someone has managed to tell him something he didn't realise he'd needed to hear.
He slips the card carefully back into its envelope.
Not tossed onto the side. Not left amongst the wrapping paper.
Carefully. Like something he already knows he'll keep forever.
Dustin arrives nearly forty minutes late.
He bursts through the front door carrying three different bags, a box of doughnuts, and what appears to be a screwdriver for reasons known only to himself.
"Sorry!" he announces before anybody has the chance to say hello. "The bus was late, the car wouldn't start, and then I had to help my mum move a bookshelf because apparently I'm 'the man of the house now.'"
Robin raises an eyebrow. "...You brought a screwdriver."
"I know."
"Why?"
Dustin looks down at it as though only just noticing it in his own hand. "...Huh."
Steve laughs. "There he is."
Dustin grins, dropping everything onto the kitchen table with considerably more force than necessary. "Happy birthday, old man."
"Thanks."
"You look ancient."
"I'm twenty-three."
"Exactly."
Steve rolls his eyes. "You'll understand one day."
"I'll never be twenty-three."
"You literally will."
"I refuse."
The conversation dissolves into laughter almost immediately.
Nancy is still trying to work out where everyone's coats are supposed to go. Joyce keeps disappearing back to the kitchen because she insists she's forgotten something. Holly trails after Steve, carrying a balloon almost as big as she is, asking if she can help despite clearly having no idea how. Derek is outside trying to light the barbecue with considerably less success than he'd predicted.
After everything that's happened over the last few years, days like this have become strangely precious. Nothing extraordinary. Nobody saving the world. Just everyone existing in the same place at the same time, talking over one another, stealing chips from each other's plates, and interrupting conversations with terrible jokes as though they haven't spent the better part of adolescence fighting monsters together.
More than once, you catch Steve quietly looking around the room.
Not at anything in particular.
Just... everyone.
It makes something warm settle gently inside your chest.
Eventually, as plates begin disappearing into the kitchen, Dustin freezes mid-conversation. "...Oh."
Steve glances up. "What?"
Dustin slaps a hand dramatically against his forehead. "...I forgot your present."
Robin doesn't even look up from her drink. "No, you didn't."
"I did."
"You absolutely didn't."
"I absolutely-" He stops, sighing with theatrical defeat. "...Fine."
Steve laughs. "I knew it."
"You were supposed to believe me."
"I've known you too long."
Dustin disappears into the hallway before returning a moment later, carrying something wrapped in Christmas wrapping paper. It's awkwardly shaped, too large to be a book and too flat to be anything else. Without meeting Steve's eyes, he thrusts it into his hands. "There."
Steve turns it over carefully. "...What's this?"
"I said don't ask questions."
"You literally handed it to me."
"I know."
"Can I open it?"
Dustin rubs awkwardly at the back of his neck. "...Yeah."
The room gradually quietens. Even Mike abandons the card game long enough to look over.
Steve peels the paper back with surprising care, trying not to tear it.
Inside is a thick scrapbook.
The cover is slightly crooked, one corner clearly glued back into place after an unfortunate accident, and across the front, in unmistakably Dustin Henderson handwriting, is written a single word.
STEVE.
Nothing else. Just... Steve.
His smile falters almost immediately.
Slowly, he opens it.
The first page is covered in old cinema tickets from Family Video movie nights.
The second is photographs.
Robin asleep against his shoulder. Lucas laughing so hard at something Steve had said that he's almost falling over. Max pulling a face behind Steve's back while he remains blissfully oblivious. A much younger Dustin wearing Steve's sunglasses, the frames so oversized they practically swallow his face.
Then come the things Steve doesn't even remember keeping.
Campaign maps from old Dungeons & Dragons sessions. Drawings Holly had made years ago that somehow ended up forgotten in his glove compartment. Polaroids. County fair wristbands. Birthday invitations. Receipts. Little scraps of paper everyone else would have thrown away.
One page is filled entirely with handwriting.
Robin's. Nancy's. Lucas's. Mike's. Will's.
Even Erica's, squeezed into one corner with the words:
"Don't let it go to your head, Harrington."
Beneath each name is a tiny memory.
"Steve bought me fries because I forgot my wallet."
"He waited outside my maths exam because he knew I'd panic afterwards."
"Drove us home in a thunderstorm even though he hates driving in the rain."
"He always says yes."
"Best babysitter ever."
Steve turns the next page much more slowly.
His fingertips linger against the edges as though he's frightened of damaging something.
"...Dude." His voice is barely above a whisper.
Dustin shrugs without looking up. "I know."
"You..." Steve lets out one quiet, disbelieving laugh. "...You made this?"
"...Shut up."
"No, seriously."
"It wasn't a big deal."
Robin snorts immediately. "He spent three weeks chasing us for photos."
"I did not."
"You literally made Joyce search her loft."
"That," Dustin points accusingly, "was research."
"And you bullied me into writing two pages."
"You wrote three because you got emotional."
"I did not."
"You absolutely-"
"Shut up, Henderson."
Laughter ripples around the room.
Steve doesn't join in.
He's still turning the pages. Slowly. As though every photograph contains a memory he'd forgotten belonged to him.
Then he stops. Halfway through the book.
You can't see the page from where you're standing.
You only notice the way his expression changes.
His shoulders soften. His eyes linger. His thumb brushes gently across whatever Dustin has glued onto the paper. "...You kept that?"
Dustin finally looks up. "...Yeah."
Steve swallows. "I didn't even know anybody still had it."
Dustin shrugs as though the answer should be obvious. "You don't throw away stuff that matters."
The words are so matter-of-fact that Dustin probably doesn't even realise what he's said.
But the room falls quiet anyway.
Because Steve is looking down at years of little moments he'd long since forgotten.
Movie tickets. Drawings. Receipts. Photographs. Inside jokes. Evidence. Proof that people had been quietly collecting pieces of him long before he'd ever thought to collect pieces of himself.
You watch him blink rapidly once. Then again.
Very carefully, he closes the scrapbook, resting one hand against its cover. "...Thank you."
Dustin clears his throat. "Yeah." A beat. "...Don't cry, dude."
Steve laughs softly, rubbing quickly beneath one eye. "I'm not crying."
Robin doesn't even glance up from her drink. "Third lie of the day."
Another ripple of laughter breaks the silence, the conversation slowly picking back up around him. But you notice something Steve doesn't seem aware he's doing.
He never lets go of the scrapbook.
Every time somebody shifts it to make room on the table, his hand finds it again almost instinctively, fingertips resting lightly against the cover as though he's quietly reassuring himself that it's still there.
The presents continue throughout the afternoon, though calling them presents hardly feels accurate anymore. Some are wrapped carefully, others arrive in supermarket carrier bags or with the price stickers hastily scratched away, and none of them are particularly expensive. None of them need to be. Somewhere between Robin's card and Dustin's scrapbook, the day has quietly stopped being about gifts at all; instead, it becomes a long series of people finding their own ways to tell Steve Harrington that they love him.
Lucas is next. He hands Steve a neatly wrapped box with a shrug that tries very hard to look casual, though he watches far too closely as Steve begins peeling back the paper. "It's not a big deal."
Steve smiles. "It didn't have to be."
Inside is a new baseball glove, the leather still stiff and untouched. Steve hadn't asked for one, but Lucas had noticed weeks ago that the stitching was beginning to unravel on the old glove he used whenever he played with the kids.
"You remembered," Steve says, turning it carefully in his hands.
Lucas looks almost confused. "Well... yeah."
"You noticed that?"
"You use it every week."
A quiet laugh escapes Steve. "I didn't think anybody was paying attention."
"Steve." Lucas shakes his head as though the answer should be obvious. "We notice everything."
Steve looks down again, his thumb moving slowly across the smooth leather before he thanks him with one of those small, genuine smiles that always reaches his eyes. Across the garden, Erica loudly informs Derek that the new glove still won't make Steve any less terrible at baseball, prompting Lucas to shout something defensive on his behalf while Steve laughs and calls them both ungrateful.
Max wanders over a few minutes later carrying nothing but a dog-eared paperback she'd spent the last month insisting he needed to read.
"You keep stealing mine," she says, pushing it into his hands. "Now you have your own."
Steve turns the book over. "I thought you liked lending them to me."
"I don't. I like getting them back eventually."
"I always return them."
"After six months."
"They're long books."
"They're four hundred pages."
"I'm a slow reader."
"I know." Her mouth twitches despite herself, but the amusement fades as she hesitates, scuffing the toe of her trainer against the grass. "...Thanks, though."
Steve blinks. "For what?"
"For always treating me like..." She pauses, searching for something precise enough. "...Just me. You never acted like I was broken."
His smile softens immediately. "You aren't."
"I know." Max shrugs one shoulder, suddenly fascinated by the book in his hands. "You just made it easier to remember."
She bumps her shoulder against his before walking away, leaving Steve watching after her for a moment before his attention drops back to the paperback. Nearby, Will quietly makes room for her beside him on the patio steps, neither of them saying anything as she steals a crisp from his plate.
Nancy catches Steve later while he's helping Joyce carry a tray of drinks into the garden. She slips a small envelope into his pocket so discreetly that nobody else notices. "Open it later."
He raises an eyebrow. "Secret?"
"I'd rather Robin didn't make fun of me."
"Fair."
When you find him reading it alone in the hallway a little while later, you discover it isn't really a birthday card at all. It's a letter, short enough to fit on half a page but written with the sort of care that makes every sentence feel deliberate. Nancy thanks him for always showing up, for never once asking whether somebody deserved saving before trying anyway, and for reminding her that kindness and courage were never mutually exclusive.
She ends simply:
The world is better because you're in it.
Nothing more. Nothing less.
Jonathan doesn't write anything. That wouldn't be him.
Instead, while everyone mills around the garden balancing paper plates and cups of lemonade, he quietly hands Steve a photograph he'd developed himself. It was taken the previous summer, though nobody had realised Jonathan was holding a camera that afternoon. Steve is sitting on the grass with Holly asleep against one shoulder while Joyce is topping up everybody's drinks without asking. Will is showing Max one of his sketches, Mike is laughing at something beyond the frame, and El is lying flat on the grass looking at clouds.
You aren't looking at the camera either.
You're looking at Steve, smiling in that completely unconscious way people only ever do when they don't know they're being watched.
On the back, Jonathan has written a single sentence.
You always make it feel like home.
Steve stares at it for a long time. "...You took this?"
Jonathan nods. "You looked happy."
"I was."
"I know."
A quiet, bewildered laugh leaves Steve as he looks around the garden. Nancy is collecting empty plates; meanwhile, Robin is stealing chips off them before they can be picked up and taken into the kitchen. Everyone is talking over everyone else. Nobody is paying Steve any particular attention anymore.
The celebration has simply become itself.
"...You all remembered," he says, his voice nearly lost beneath the noise.
Jonathan studies him for a moment before giving the smallest shake of his head. "No."
Steve frowns. "What?"
"We didn't just remember." Jonathan glances towards the garden. "We wanted to."
It's such an ordinary sentence, spoken so quietly it almost disappears beneath the laughter drifting through the open door, but you watch something shift inside Steve anyway.
All day, some part of him has been waiting for somebody to admit they felt obligated; that birthdays are merely something decent people acknowledge because convention tells them to. Instead, every person keeps offering him the same truth in a different form.
Not simply happy birthday, but:
I'm glad you're here.
You make things better.
Life would look different without you.
And, perhaps for the first time in his life, Steve doesn't quite know what to do with the possibility that every one of them genuinely means it.
By the time the sun begins dipping behind the trees, the garden has dissolved into the sort of comfortable chaos that always seems to follow this particular group of people. Dustin and Erica have started teaching Holly a card game that she keeps accidentally cheating at. Mike and Lucas are throwing around a football, while El keeps spectacularly missing the catches and laughing anyway. Hopper has claimed the garden chair furthest from the noise with the determination of a man pretending not to enjoy himself, and Jonathan wanders quietly between them with his camera, capturing moments nobody else seems to notice.
Joyce, meanwhile, has somehow produced enough food to cater for an entire wedding.
Steve stands in the kitchen doorway, staring at the dining table. "...Joyce."
She looks up from the casserole she's carrying. "Hm?"
"There's enough food here to feed about thirty people."
"I know."
"There are, like, twelve of us."
"I know."
He gestures helplessly towards the mountain of dishes covering every available surface. "How did you even make all this?"
Joyce shrugs as though she'd thrown together a sandwich rather than enough food to sustain Hawkins through the winter. "I got carried away."
Robin wanders past and steals a roast potato straight from the tray. "She always gets carried away."
"I heard that."
"I wanted you to."
Steve laughs, shaking his head. "This is ridiculous."
Joyce smiles without looking up. "I know."
Nobody goes hungry when Joyce Byers is involved. Plates are filled faster than they're emptied, second helpings appear before anyone has the chance to refuse them, and every attempt to help clear away is met with a gentle but immovable, "Sit down. I've got it."
Steve tries anyway. Of course he does.
He appears beside Joyce with an armful of empty plates before she's even reached the sink. "I can help."
"I know." She takes them from him. "But today's your birthday."
"I don't mind."
"I know." She smiles at him over the top of the washing-up bowl. "So let somebody look after you for once."
The words are spoken so casually they almost disappear beneath the rush of running water, but you see Steve pause.
Only for a second.
Later, after dinner has dissolved into coffee, cake and half a dozen conversations happening at once, you wander back into the kitchen in search of more plates and find Joyce standing at the counter surrounded by plastic containers. She fills one, then another, then another: pasta, roast potatoes, slices of pie, enough leftovers to feed two people for the better part of a week.
Steve wanders in behind you just as she's clipping the lid onto the final container. "...Joyce?"
"Hm?"
"What's all this?"
She looks at him as though the answer is obvious. "Your dinners."
"My..."
"You work long shifts." She stacks another container neatly on top. "And I know you'll forget to cook for yourself if I don't send you home with something."
Steve laughs softly. "You don't have to do that."
"I know."
"You've already fed all of us."
"I know."
"This is too much."
Joyce finally stops what she's doing, placing both hands on the lid of the last container before sliding the entire stack towards him. "You'll take these."
He hesitates. "I don't need-"
"I wasn't asking."
There's no sharpness to it, no irritation, only the gentle certainty of someone who has spent years making sure the people she loves never leave her house hungry.
Steve looks down at the containers, then back at Joyce, and something shifts across his face so quickly that, had you not been watching for it all day, you might have missed it.
Recognition.
Not of the food.
Of the feeling.
Joyce has done this before: when he'd arrived after a shift looking exhausted, when he'd spent too many evenings helping the kids instead of himself, when she'd quietly wrapped slices of lasagne in foil because she'd "made too much again," despite everyone knowing perfectly well she'd cooked extra on purpose.
You realise, with a sudden ache beneath your ribs, that she has been mothering Steve for years. Neither of them has ever said it aloud. Neither of them has needed to.
Joyce notices his silence. "What?"
Steve blinks, almost startled back into the room. "...Nothing."
"You've got that look where you're thinking too hard."
A small smile finds him. "I was just..." He glances down at the containers again. "...Nobody's ever packed me leftovers before."
The kitchen falls unexpectedly quiet.
Joyce's expression softens almost imperceptibly. "Oh, sweetheart." She reaches out without hesitation, smoothing an affectionate hand over his shoulder as though she's done it a hundred times before. "Well." Another gentle squeeze. "They do now."
Steve doesn't answer. He only nods once, swallowing a little too hard before carefully carrying the stack across the kitchen and opening the fridge. He rearranges half the shelves to make room, setting each container inside with absurd precision before closing the door as though he's placing something valuable somewhere safe.
They're only leftovers. A few plastic tubs that will probably become lunch before work tomorrow.
But as you watch his hand linger briefly on the fridge handle, you realise they were never really about food at all. They were proof that somebody had been thinking about tomorrow on his behalf.
For someone who'd spent most of his life quietly taking care of everyone else, that might just have been the greatest gift he'd received all day.
When he finally wanders back outside, the evening has settled into that soft golden hour where everything seems to slow down. Fairy lights strung between the fence posts have begun to glow faintly against the darkening sky, somebody has started another pot of coffee, and the birthday cake sits half-demolished in the middle of the table, one candle still stubbornly refusing to go out despite Robin's repeated attempts to blow it over with exaggerated determination.
You lean against the kitchen doorway for a moment, simply watching.
Steve barely makes it back onto the patio before Dustin catches him again, insisting he absolutely has to see the scrapbook page he'd forgotten to point out earlier. Mike throws a crisp at him. Lucas joins in without even asking what they're arguing about. Max rolls her eyes so dramatically you're surprised they don't disappear entirely.
And through it all...
Steve laughs.
Not the polite laugh he gives customers. Not the awkward one he used to force whenever his parents invited colleagues over for dinner.
This one is different.
Loose. Easy. It belongs here.
You don't think he'd even realised the difference.
Not until today.
Hopper chooses his moment carefully.
He waits until Steve wanders away from the noise with another cup of coffee, escaping towards the edge of the garden where the old oak tree throws long shadows across the grass. It's the sort of place Steve always drifts towards when everything gets a little too loud - not because he dislikes the company, but because he's always needed a minute to breathe between moments.
Hopper follows a few seconds later.
Not obviously.
You watch from the patio without saying anything.
Steve hears the footsteps and glances over his shoulder. "Oh. Hey."
Hopper grunts something that could generously be interpreted as a greeting before stopping beside him.
For a while, neither of them says anything.
They simply stand shoulder to shoulder, looking out across the garden while laughter drifts faintly behind them. Joyce is gathering empty mugs onto a tray. Nancy is folding paper napkins that don't really need folding. Robin has somehow persuaded Holly to help blow bubbles across the garden while Dustin insists bubbles are scientifically impossible to catch.
Steve smiles into his coffee. "...Nice day."
Hopper nods once. "Yeah."
Silence settles again.
Not uncomfortable. Just... Hopper.
Eventually, he clears his throat. "Happy birthday."
Steve looks faintly surprised. "Oh." A small smile appears. "...Thanks."
Another long pause passes, and you almost wonder whether that's going to be the entire conversation.
Then Hopper speaks again, his eyes still fixed somewhere out across the garden. "You've done good."
Steve frowns. "What?"
"The kids."
A shrug. "They're good kids."
"They are." Hopper nods slowly. "They're better because you're around."
Steve's expression changes almost imperceptibly.
Hopper keeps talking before he has the chance to interrupt. "I've seen the way they look at you." Only then does he turn his head. "They trust you."
Steve opens his mouth.
Nothing comes out.
"You didn't have to keep showing up." Hopper's voice is as gruff as ever. "Nobody asked you to." Another pause. "But you did."
Steve looks down at the coffee cup in his hands. "I just..." A quiet laugh escapes him. "...They needed somebody."
"They did." Hopper nods once. "They got you."
For a moment, neither of them moves.
The sounds of the party carry on behind them as though nothing extraordinary is happening. Someone starts another round of Happy Birthday purely to annoy Steve. Robin groans loudly enough for the entire neighbourhood to hear.
Steve laughs automatically.
His eyes, however, have become suspiciously bright.
Hopper notices.
Naturally.
He pretends not to.
Instead, he reaches out, giving Steve's shoulder one firm, awkward squeeze before offering his hand.
Steve blinks. "...Really?"
"What?"
"The handshake."
"I'm trying."
Steve laughs through the thickness in his throat. "I know."
He takes Hopper's hand.
The handshake lasts barely two seconds.
It's probably the closest Hopper has ever come to saying I'm proud of you.
When he lets go, he clears his throat. "Don't make it weird."
"I wasn't gonna."
"You were thinkin' about it."
"...Maybe."
Hopper points back towards the house. "Go enjoy your party."
Steve smiles. "...Yeah."
He watches Hopper wander back towards the others before letting his gaze drift across the garden.
Robin has somehow ended up with Holly asleep against her shoulder despite loudly insisting children "smell weird". Joyce is packing slices of cake into foil while Nancy labels the containers before anyone can forget whose is whose. Lucas and Mike have wandered to the end of the garden with a football, Jonathan is crouched beside the flowerbed trying to photograph a butterfly Holly spotted, and Erica is shamelessly raiding the snack table one last time before anybody notices.
You catch Steve's eye from across the lawn.
He smiles at you.
Not because anything funny has happened. Not because he's trying to.
Simply because, for perhaps the first time all day, he's beginning to understand what every single person has been trying to tell him.
He hadn't just been thrown a birthday party.
He was home.
By the time the last of the washing up has been stacked beside the sink, the house has settled into a gentler kind of noise.
The loud laughter has softened into quieter conversations, and the music drifting from the old radio has become little more than background static. Through the kitchen doorway you can still see everyone scattered comfortably around the house, no longer celebrating in any organised sense of the word, simply... staying.
Robin has somehow ended up half-curled across one end of the sofa, arguing lazily with Max over what film everyone should watch before they eventually leave. El sits cross-legged on the rug with Mike, the two of them still passionately debating something that nobody else is listening to anymore, while Will quietly contributes the occasional comment that neither of them acknowledges. Joyce is wrapping the last slices of birthday cake in foil, Hopper pretending not to help while hovering close enough to hand her the tape every few minutes without ever admitting that's exactly what he's doing. Holly has fallen asleep against Nancy's side, Jonathan is carefully packing away his camera, and Erica is wandering through the living room helping herself to whatever snacks everyone else has forgotten about.
Nobody seems in any hurry to go home. Nobody seems to want the day to end.
Steve stands beside you at the sink, drying the final plate with considerably more concentration than the task really requires.
He's been quieter ever since Hopper wandered back inside. Not unhappy. Just... Thoughtful.
You hand him another plate, and he dries it automatically before speaking into the comfortable silence. "...I don't get it."
You glance sideways. "What don't you get?"
A quiet laugh escapes him, though it carries none of its usual ease. "Today." He runs the tea towel slowly around the edge of the plate. "They all..." He trails off, searching for words. "...They actually wanted to come."
The sentence settles heavily between you. Not because of what he's saying. Because of what he's accidentally revealing.
You wait.
He keeps looking down at the plate in his hands. "I know birthdays are..." He shrugs awkwardly. "People feel like they have to come, right? You buy a present. You sing. You eat cake." Another small shrug. "It's just... what people do."
You lean your hip against the counter. "Is that what you think today was?"
"I don't know." His smile is almost embarrassed. "It didn't feel like that."
"No."
"They weren't just doing birthday stuff."
"No."
He looks through the doorway towards the living room, where Robin has thrown another cushion at Dustin, Lucas catches it before it reaches him, and Joyce laughs so hard she has to steady herself against the arm of the sofa. "...They were celebrating me."
You smile. "They were."
He looks back at you, his brow creasing slightly. "I've never..." The sentence never reaches the end. Instead, he laughs quietly, rubbing at the back of his neck. "...I don't think I've ever had that before."
Your heart aches. Not because he's upset. Because he says it with such genuine surprise, as though the possibility had never once occurred to him.
You reach for his hand. "C'mere."
He follows without question.
You lead him slowly through the house without saying anything, simply letting him look.
Nancy is gently lifting Holly so she doesn't wake her. Hopper is quietly locking the back door, while Joyce wraps up slices of cake in individual napkins. Jonathan is wiping down camera lenses, Mike has drifted asleep in the armchair, and El gently covers him with a blanket. Robin is trying to convince Max that one more film won't kill anyone, despite half the room already falling asleep, while Erica is counting how much birthday cake she's managed to smuggle home.
Nobody's performing anymore. The party is over. This is simply what remains. People comfortable enough to exist in one another's spaces without needing a reason.
Steve watches them quietly. "They're still here."
"Mhm."
"They don't have to be."
"No."
"They've all got homes."
"They do."
He looks around again, confusion softening into something quieter. "So why..."
People who had arrived separately, from entirely different corners of his life, and somehow fit together now. People who, before him, had never all belonged in the same room.
"You spent years looking after everyone because you thought that's what made you useful."
His eyes meet yours.
"You drove them everywhere. You showed up. You fixed things. You carried everyone else's worries until they stopped feeling so heavy."
He nods slowly. "I thought..."
"I know." You step closer, your thumb brushing gently across his knuckles. "But somewhere along the way... they stopped needing you because of what you did."
His brow furrows.
"They stayed because of who you are."
The words seem to settle somewhere deep inside him.
"You became loved long before you even noticed."
For a long moment he simply looks at you.
Then his eyes begin to shine again.
You smile softly. "I've still got one more present."
He blinks. "You do?"
"Mhm."
You disappear upstairs for barely a minute before returning with something wrapped carefully in plain brown paper and tied with twine.
Steve laughs quietly. "I thought we'd finished."
"We had." You place it gently into his hands. "This one's different."
He unwraps it slowly.
Inside is a dark leather-bound photo album.
No title. No ribbon.
Just his name, pressed carefully into the cover in tiny gold letters.
Steve.
He opens it.
The first page isn't a photograph.
Just a single sentence:
You spend so much of your life looking after everybody else.
He turns the page.
Steve teaching Dustin how to drive. Steve asleep on the sofa with Holly curled against his chest. Robin laughing so hard she's crying while Steve looks completely bewildered. Max stealing chips from his plate. Lucas teaching him a ridiculous handshake. Jonathan catching him mid-laugh behind the camera. Joyce handing him another plate of food. Hopper clapping him awkwardly on the shoulder.
You.
All of them.
Beneath each photograph you've written a single line.
Not describing the picture.
Describing what it meant:
The day Dustin stopped needing a babysitter and started needing a brother.
The first time Robin laughed like she wasn't afraid anymore.
The afternoon you accidentally became Holly's favourite person.
He keeps turning the pages until he reaches the last one.
There are only six words:
Home isn't always somewhere you arrive.
He turns one final page:
Sometimes it's something you build.
Nothing else.
Steve doesn't realise he's crying until a tear lands quietly on the paper.
He lets out a breath that sounds almost like a laugh, shaking his head. "...Honey."
Very gently, you close the album beneath his hands.
"So..." You smile. "Happy birthday."
He looks at you for a long moment.
Then, without saying a single word, he wraps both arms around you.
Not because he doesn't know what to say.
Because, for perhaps the first time in his life... being loved has left Steve Harrington completely speechless.
By the time the two of you finally climb into bed, the house has fallen completely silent.
The fairy lights outside the bedroom window still glow faintly against the darkness, casting soft pools of amber across the ceiling, and somewhere downstairs the dishwasher hums steadily through the last traces of the evening. Steve's birthday cards are stacked neatly on the dresser, Robin's sitting proudly on top, still slightly bent where she'd thrown it at his head that morning.
The leather photo album rests beside them.
Closed now, but not put away.
You curl instinctively beneath the duvet, expecting exhaustion to pull you under almost immediately after such a long day.
It doesn't.
Some time later, you wake to find Steve still lying beside you, exactly where he'd been when you fell asleep. Only now his eyes are open, fixed quietly on the ceiling, his hands folded loosely across his stomach as though he's trying to untangle a thought that's been sitting with him for hours.
"...Hey."
He turns his head. "Oh." His voice is barely above a whisper. "Sorry."
"You don't have to apologise for existing."
A tired smile appears. "I know."
You roll onto your side, propping yourself up on one elbow. "What're you thinking about?"
For a while, he doesn't answer. The silence between the two of you has never needed filling.
Eventually, he lets out a quiet breath. "...When I was little..." He laughs softly to himself. "...I always wished I'd grown up with a big family."
The confession catches you off guard. He keeps looking at the ceiling.
"I used to imagine one of those really noisy houses. People everywhere. Dinner all squashed around one table. Too many birthdays. Too many Christmas presents." He smiles faintly at the thought before it fades again. "I don't know... I just thought it'd be nice."
You reach across the mattress until your fingers find his. He threads them through yours automatically.
"I thought..." He swallows. "...I thought I'd missed my chance."
You shake your head. "No."
For the first time since he started talking, he turns to look at you. "No?"
"You didn't miss it."
His brow furrows.
"You built it."
A quiet, disbelieving laugh escapes him. "I don't..."
"You've got Robin. Dustin. Lucas. Max. Mike. Will. El. Erica." You smile gently. "Nancy. Jonathan. Joyce. Hopper. Holly." You pause. "And me."
His eyes soften.
"They're your family, Steve."
He looks away again. "They..."
"They are."
"I know they care about me, but-"
"No." You squeeze his hand before he can disappear back into old habits. "They don't love you because you drove them everywhere. They don't love you because you babysat them. They don't love you because you fixed every problem before anyone else even noticed it."
You think back over the day.
Robin's card. Dustin's scrapbook. Jonathan's photograph. Joyce quietly packing tomorrow's dinner before Steve had even thought about feeding himself. Hopper, standing beneath the oak tree, trying to say I'm proud of you without ever using the words.
"They love you because you're Steve."
The room falls quiet again.
"You spent years believing people only stayed because you made yourself useful."
His eyes glisten.
"But somewhere along the way..." You smile. "...they stayed anyway."
He lets out one small, disbelieving laugh. "...When did that happen?"
"I honestly don't think anybody knows."
You think about Dustin, twelve years old, following Steve everywhere. Robin slowly deciding she could trust him. Joyce wrapping leftovers in foil because she'd quietly started expecting him for dinner. Holly climbing into his lap without asking.
None of it had happened all at once.
There wasn't a single moment where strangers became family.
It happened on ordinary Tuesdays. On lifts home from school. Movie nights. Late-night phone calls. Shared meals. Inside jokes.
One quiet act of kindness after another until, somehow, nobody could remember a version of life that didn't include Steve Harrington standing somewhere in the middle of it.
"It just..." Your thumb brushes gently across his knuckles. "...Kept happening."
His breathing catches.
You nod gently towards the bedroom door, beyond which the cards, photographs and carefully stacked leftovers still wait downstairs.
"If every single person chose to spend today celebrating you..." Your voice is barely louder than the rain-soft silence outside. "...it's because every single one of them can't imagine their life without you in it."
For a long time, he doesn't speak.
His breathing catches once. Then again.
He laughs quietly through the tears gathering in his eyes. "...You're really laying it on thick for a birthday."
"I know."
"You trying to make me cry?"
You smile, brushing the same stubborn strand of hair away from his forehead that you'd smoothed back that morning. "No." A gentle kiss against his temple. "I'm just telling you the truth."
Something inside him finally gives way.
Not dramatically. There are no great sobs. No speeches.
Just one quiet exhale that seems to carry years of loneliness away with it.
A tear slips silently down his cheek. Then another.
Without saying a word, he turns towards you and buries his face against your neck exactly as though that's where he'd always belonged.
You wrap your arms around him instinctively, your fingers disappearing into his hair as he lets himself be held. Completely.
For perhaps the first time in his life, Steve Harrington doesn't apologise for crying.
He doesn't explain it away. He simply allows someone else to carry the weight for a little while.
You press one last kiss into his hair. "Happy birthday, sweetheart."
His reply is almost lost against your shoulder. "...Best one I've ever had."
You close your eyes, holding him a little tighter as the fairy lights continue glowing softly beyond the bedroom window.
This morning he'd asked if he could skip his birthday.
Now, listening to the steady rhythm of his breathing against your chest, you realise birthdays were never really supposed to celebrate surviving another year.
Sometimes they're simply an excuse for everybody who loves you to remind you how very glad they are that you did.
maybe a little something about gator getting used to living with girly!reader? Like her everything shower routine, nighttime routines, drinking tea, candles in the house, cleaning up, small things like that that he wasn’t used to on the ranch as a bachelor. Idk i feel like this could be cute and fluffy!!
The Space You Fill
soft!Gator Tillman x girly!reader
Summary: Gator grew up in the world of other people's rules and choices, where he was forbidden to want, ask, or get attached. But when you enter his small apartment, everything changes.
Tags/Warnings: soft!Gator, girly!reader, fluff, really very-very sweet, a brief mention of Roy.
W/C: 2,8k
A/n: I really enjoyed writing this! I hope you like it too! Thank you! 💘 I tried to use short forms to replicate Gator's manner of speaking, but I'm rather bad at American abbreviations and other things (I study British English at the institute). English is my second language, please, correct me if anything is wrong.
Gator thought that some things might change with you moving in with him, but he definitely didn't expect it to affect him in any way.
Even before you fully moved in, his already small apartment had started to rapidly fill up with your things. At first, it was just the basics: shampoo and hair conditioner on the shower shelf, a couple of books you brought so you wouldn't get bored if he got called into the police station, an old lipstick and a powder compact so you could quickly fix your makeup if needed.
But now you live with him, and your presence is everywhere.
It becomes noticeable from the very first week.
Morning. It's almost strange that you're working today while he is on shift at night. Gator stands in the middle of the bathroom, holding a bottle of shampoo that smells like ripe raspberries, and stares at his old shampoo with its half-peeled-off "2-in-1 for hair and body" label, feeling a little betrayed. It has been pushed to the farthest corner of the shelf, like some outcast in a kingdom of beauty, a criminal exiled for being almighty. Well, what's wrong with that? The last thing he needs is to buy a bunch of separate products for every part of his body. He is perfectly fine with slathering that stuff on, rinsing it off, and smelling like menthol and eucalyptus until his next shower. Simple, no fuss.
He steps out of the bathroom and notices your slippers in the hallway. They're woolly and pink, looking like giant paws. He tried to stick his foot into them once, thinking they were big enough, while you squealed that he'd stretch them out. As you can see, they're perfectly fine. You were rushing, you're always afraid you're running late, and yet you always end up arriving early. You left a little chaos behind, but Gator doesn't mind – he's already made peace with it. He steps over the slippers, then turns around, picks them up, and sets them by the wall so no one stumbles.
The changes in the kitchen have been quite the revelation too. Now he doesn't just make himself coffee in the morning: he asks you what you want to drink. Gator remembers that you always ask for tea. You even placed a tea organizer next to the electric kettle! Where you carefully stashed his lone box of black tea, which has more dust and tea crumbs in it than actual leaves and flowers.
Gator opens the fridge in search of a quick breakfast (he doesn't say that he actually likes the yogurts too, but you notice when they disappear and silently buy a few extra each time) and sees a container with a sticky note attached.
"Some for you too. Eat it before evening. If you lied about liking strawberries, you'll have to like them now. Kiss you."
With you, Gator started eating much better. He never bought fruit for himself, never made salads, and his snacks at work were dried meat and soda. He still remembers how dumbly he stared at you when you shoved a container of food at him to take with him.
Besides, no one had ever cut fruit for him before.
Gator opens the container with sliced strawberries and kiwis inside. He smirks at the thought that it's just like you and him. You're sweet, and everyone loves you, like strawberry. And he's unappealing and an acquired taste, but inside, not so bad. Probably.
Gator is grateful that you don't change things radically, just improve them, leaving what he already had.
You fill all the free space that was actually just empty because Gator had nothing to put there. And honestly, he even felt a little joyless looking at the surfaces and shelves that only held a layer of dust. But that problem is solved. On the sofa lies a glossy magazine, and Gator will definitely investigate what you circled with a marker in the cosmetics section. Your cardigan with golden flower-shaped buttons is draped over the back of a chair. And on the coffee table is a box with a set of hairpins, but only two are left because you have lost the rest.
He won't tell you that one of them is in his uniform pocket.
By the second week, you had finally moved all your things in.
Gator comes home late from work. As usual, he takes a quick shower, and then comes the worst part of the day. Untangling his hair from its styling. And for some reason, in the morning he couldn't get it to lay flat on the first try, so it's horribly stuck together from too much gel, because water got on it while he was washing himself. Gator steps out of the bathroom looking for his comb and, of course, he can't sneak past you.
"What are you doing?" You turn down the TV volume and look at him.
"My comb's gone somewhere." He sees several combs on the dresser, but his isn't there.
"You mean half a comb?"
"I said what I said." Gator snorts, a little irritated, water dripping onto his shoulders. "Wait, you didn't throw it out, did you?" It suddenly dawns on him.
"No, it's in the drawer. Come on." You stand up, and he lets you go first because he likes watching you in that satin set: the top with straps and ruffled shorts. You rummage through the drawer where he keeps his spare razor cartridges and the new deodorant he bought on the BOGO deal. You pull out a comb – a wide-toothed one, with a third of the teeth missing.
"Thanks." Gator replies flatly, but you don't leave. "You can go."
"I want to see what happens next." You say with distrust, but Gator just shrugs. He tries to comb his hair, but it's tangled, with knots even forming in places where the comb snags. It looks like torture. But not for him. For you. "What are you doing!"
Gator flinches at your loud exclamation, which hits his ears. You shout like he's nearly broken federal law. "I almost went deaf. It's your own fault for staying to watch. I thought you were a spectator, not a critic."
"Give it to me. Sit." You pull a stool from the corner for him to sit on. You grab a squeeze tube from the shelf, and Gator tenses up. This is better than scissors, sure, but still...
"What's that for?" He tries to read the label.
"Just hair conditioner, for easy detangling." You take a little in your hand and apply it to his head.
"It's gross, like jelly." Gator sniffs it. "And it smells terrible!"
"Would you rather go bald by ripping your hair out with... that?" You're pointing at his pathetic hair care kit.
"Fine, just do what you gotta do." Your fingers gently massage his scalp, spreading that disgustingly sweet conditioner through his hair. He wants to protest, say he's a cop, not a poodle being groomed before a show, but the words get stuck in his throat because... this feels nice.
Damn. This really feels pleasurable.
You run your fingers through his wet hair, untangling the knots he made himself. Gator closes his eyes, feeling the tension leave his shoulders. When you touch the back of his head, he almost purrs. Almost. He'd never admit it.
"Always start combing from the bottom up. And how many times have I told you that shampoo dries out your hair?" You advise and explain reasonably, without pressure. "We can get you something without such a strong scent."
"I'll think about it..." Gator grumbles, but already knows he'll go to the store with you this weekend and smell everything you shove under his nose until he approves.
"Now you can wask it all off." You wait patiently while Gator washes his hair. And when he reaches for a towel, you hand him something completely different.
"This is a t-shirt." He looks at you with a hint of skepticism. Was just touching his hair enough to drive you crazy?
"No. Well, yes, but that's the point. Terry towels tangle hair, but cotton just absorbs water." You make him bend down and wrap his head in your old pink t-shirt. You bite your lip, stifling a laugh, because Gator looks ridiculous.
"I opened a portal to hell when I let you do this." He hangs his head dejectedly, more theatrically, but still a little offended. You don't even pay attention to his antics, patting his hair dry with the t-shirt again. Before turning on the hairdryer, you grab another product from the shelf and spray it over him without warning. "Chemical attack! I'm in a gas chamber! Exit is blocked..." Gator covers his eyes with his hand and coughs. It smells like meadow flowers and honey. Harmless.
"Oh, Gator, you're so dramatic." You turn on the hairdryer and don't hear him cursing. Honestly, you really like touching his head, especially when his hair is so silky. When you finish drying, you lean down, pressing your face into the top of his head, inhaling the scent.
"What are you plotting now?" Gator fidgets, because everything he's let you do so far is way out of bounds. But he looks in the mirror and sees you hugging him around the neck, your hands on his shoulders, slightly bent, pressed against his back.
"Nothing. I'm done." You shrug and walk out, heading back to the bedroom.
Gator examines himself in the mirror, and giving you your due, he's never looked this good.
So... Domestic.
He walks over to you, and you're sitting at the dressing table on a low pouf, brushing your hair. Gator squats down next to you.
"You didn't comb your hair? I showed you where your comb is." You run the brush through his front strands, and his bangs fall into his eyes. You laugh, and he rests his head on your lap. Complete surrender. You comb his hair, and his arms wrap tightly around your waist. "You smell like me."
"Y'know, maybe it's not so bad."
By the third week of living side by side with you, Gator realized how lucky he was.
He doesn't say it out loud, but he understands that he's ready to take back every word he ever said. He likes this. Being in comfort. Not just surviving, as it was at the ranch. When he lived in his father's house, he wasn't allowed to have excess belongings – only the bare essentials – and it felt more like the army than a home where, it turns out, you can keep fond things and warm memories. When he moved into a separate little house on the same ranch, it got better. Though he had to fix it up himself so the roof wouldn't leak and the wiring wouldn't short. But it was his den, where posters could hang on the walls and he could listen to any music he liked, as loud as he wanted.
And in a world of constant prohibitions and reproaches, you showed him that getting attached to things isn't bad at all: it's actually good to have something you love. Something of your own. Because when he left the ranch, he realized he didn't know how to choose something other than the first thing he grabbed or the cheapest option, how to want something, and most importantly, how to ask for it. He grew up convenient, quiet, obedient. But you started proving to him that he could be selective, picky, have his own opinions, and not be punished or humiliated for it.
Gator started to understand that you wouldn't mock him for never having tried matcha or alternative milk – you'd stop by a café after work and buy him something to try. And iced caramel latte is now his favorite drink there. You wouldn't scold him for picking the same cereal that a five-year-old would choose at the store, because his father ate nothing but oatmeal for breakfast, and the family ate only what he liked.
Gator lived by other people's choices, and sometimes he just didn't have the energy left to make his own, because after a 24-hour shift, he didn't care what movie was on TV. He turned it not just to fall asleep in silence.
And now he falls asleep cuddling and talking to you.
You let him try and make mistakes. And that tells him more about your love than any words ever could, and Gator is glad that you see it too. A couple of days ago, you were putting hand cream on at night, and he just reached out his hand to place it in yours. At first, you didn't understand what he wanted, but when you felt how dry his hands were and how cracked his skin was, you didn't ask questions. You applied some cream and traced each knuckle.
That's how you learned that chamomile and sandalwood appeal to him more than geranium and bergamot. And now that cream lies on his side of the nightstand. There's a lot more stuff there now, actually: a velvet cloth where Gator places his watch and badge so they don't scratch the nightstand; a moisturizer he needs, especially in winter; sometimes a mug of jasmine tea, because you broke him of the habit of drinking coffee at night.
With you, Gator feels significant, not like a hollow space. At first, he thought it was silly when you asked him about the color of the blanket to cover the sofa in the living room or the kitchen towels you wanted to buy, or any other trifling question you could have answered yourself but chose to consult him on.
That's how you show him that he matters.
And he tries to pay you back in kind.
Tonight is just for the two of you. Gator booked a table at some fancy restaurant, having researched options in advance to make sure you'd like it. He's trying to get used to styling his hair without gel, so it's soft and pliable with a faint hint of mint and lemongrass, because that way you can run your hands through it and ruffle it. He put on a crisp white shirt, and you helped him roll up the sleeves.
Gator waits for you. He peers into the bedroom, and you're almost ready too, finishing your styling. You're sitting, twisted at an awkward angle to see what you're doing in the mirror. Your hair is already curled into perfect ringlets in the front and on the sides, but the back is still straight.
You notice him. "I'll be done soon, the mirror isn't helping me synchronize my hair and the styler." You joke.
"Give it to me." Gator takes it from your hands.
"Do you know how to use it?" You ask, and Gator can't help but admire how your eyes sparkle, and it's not from the shimmery eyeshadow.
"I know how to follow orders. If you guide me, maybe something will come out of it."
"Okay." You turn your back to him. "Basically, it does everything itself: just separate a strand, turn it on, bring it close. It'll curl it."
"Sounds simple, like even I could do it." Gator smiles and does exactly what you say. He separates a strand, turns on the styler, and brings it to your hair. The hair wraps around the heated cylinder, and Gator waits a few seconds. "Then what?"
"There's a button, cool it with cold air, then turn it off." You explain, feeling his breath on the top of your head. Gator switches the air to cold, then turns off the styler. A perfect curl. He repeats it three more times before proudly declaring that it's done.
"Now spray it with hairspray." You grab it and hand to Gator.
"Just take it and...?" Gator makes a motion with his hand but doesn't press the nozzle.
"Yes, like when I sprayed the heat protection on you in the bathroom."
"Oh, well, I can do that." He sprays a cloud of hairspray over you, then puts everything aside and rests his hands on your shoulders, squeezing gently. Gator kisses the back of your head. "You look pretty. Very-very pretty."
"So do you." You reply with a smile, and he leans back a little to look at you.
"Did the hairspray get into your eyes?" Gator laughs, but you're actually serious.
"Not at all." You stand up and reach your arms out to him. He doesn't want to ruin your makeup, so he just hugs you, but you press your cheek against his. "Thank you, Gator."
"Anytime, baby." Gator looks at you, and one side of his face is shimmering from your highlighter.
"Now you're glowing too." You try to wipe the glitter off his cheek, and he covers your hands with his.
"That's all because of you." Gator leans in and presses his forehead against yours, his nose barely touching yours. "Come on, we don't want to be late, right?"
You nod, and he takes your hand, certain that it couldn't get any better.
He thought moving in was about letting you into his life.
But it turns out that he's been living in yours for a long time.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
gator on top, your legs spread wide and him putting just the tip in and legit jerking himself off into your pussy, his hand moving over himself fast, faster, fastfastfast until he nuts shallowly right in you, his come collecting just inside your hot, wet channel. you sob a little with desperation as he holds your cunt open, spreading your creamy slit apart with his thumbs, watching his release drool back out of you, right in his face
you beg him for his mouth, for something more—anything more—but all he does it push it back in, his fingers flat against your slit, rubbing side to side over your hole before he finally crooks two fingers into you, playing with his come, scissoring his fingers apart before he straightens up and fucks his thick, fat, heavy cock right back into you.
his come oozes out around him, rolling down your labia on either side of his length in thick rivulets as he moves into you, hips slamming yours, balls slapping your ass, and he comes again deep inside you, filling you for real this time.
he lays down, has you climb up and sit on his face, spreading your arousal and his release all over his nose and mouth and lips and tongue as you just grind down against him, dirtying both of you—your cunt your thighs, his cheeks his chin—with one hand on his hip, the other jerking him off again.
he comes weakly with a groan, just a scant little dribble rolling down the side of his cock as you finally get your chance and come on his tongue, the squelching squeeze of your cunt as you finish pushing his release back out of you onto his waiting mouth and chin. it drips down his neck, collecting in the hollow of his throat as you push down hard against his face, feeling his body stutter beneath you for a moment bc he can’t breathe, but fuck if he’s gonna let you pull away for something as trivial as air.
he holds you there tight against him by your thighs until you finish, your hand loosely wrapped around his softening prick, lowering your front to his, body pliant and twitchy as all hell when you slide off of him, the gasping breath you allow him to take full of contentment, fulfillment—satisfaction.