hi i just finished ‘aphasia’ and…. wow. i didn’t even realize how tightly wound i was until will got to the cottage and i started to exhale. will’s hyper-vigilance and general malaise was SO palpable. on top of all my worry for mack. i mean this in the best way: this fic made my stomach hurt at baseline. and then there were the kicks while i was down of “how he’s already bracing for will to say no.” and will noticing mack’s face when he says people “want us in ways that aren’t real” and “well, i don’t get to choose anymore, mack” and “you keep doing this” and “or because it was me?” and “i wouldn’t have been able to [lie]” but then it unspools slow and steady and so so satisfyingly.
please excuse the perhaps too-close reading (i was an english major) but the like book-end moments of will accusing mack of not telling him he’s gay, and mack being like ‘i thought you’d figured it out’ at the beginning, and then in the last chapter being like ‘i thought you knew’ about his feelings for will. 🚬 i just love that we kind of started and ended with a similar moment because even after all that growth it’s still like… ofc mack thinks all of this is obvious, knows his heart is on his sleeve!! but ofc it isn’t, because will, intentionally or not, keeps himself in the dark. it’s such an interesting clash of core character traits and i just loved how both moments show that.
or like, one of my favorite bits of dialogue was the “bud” conversation. i thiiiink my favorite bit of dialogue was the ‘bud’ conversation. mack saying “i was trying something” seemed to be him admitting that no, he cannot be will’s friend. and i love how even at the end, which is so open and hopeful, it’s still not…. we still have to read between the lines. like, will didn’t come with this grand speech, but he told the suits it was serious and he showed up all breathless and sweaty on a bike without a plan. (btw i adored the whole sequence of will going to van. despite the heavier tone of the fic, there was a distinct ‘sprinting through the airport in a romcom’ feeling when will borrowed that random kid’s too-small bike that made me almost giddy. [p.s. shoutout bedsy for not being nosy or suspicious enough to ask questions before sending will the address. bless.]) and mack never comes out and says he’s been in love with will all along, but he is so patient and forgiving.
oh and that reminds me of another really great/favorite moment where will is thanking mack for letting him stay and mack looks embarrassed when he says he wasn’t gonna send him back. even though we’re not privy to mack’s thoughts, one can only imagine that when he left will in boston, he was telling himself that he was finally going to stand on business. and then here he is. (speaking of, have you ever heard “buckle” by florence + the machine? it’s kind of gut-wrenching and it really makes me think of mack)
this is getting really unwieldy so i’m gonna see myself out and probably go read your wedding fic as a treat 🙂↕️
bwaaa thank you so much for the lovely comment. it feels kind of wow to respond to so i was sitting on it for a bit
there is a lot of disappointment with aphasia, like little false starts and failures, which im sure contribute to that sick feeling. it was hard to wrap up, and i was so glad to have kelly/keelpay there to help me when figuring that out and get it all sorted. all those things needed to be addressed and satisfied, so i hope it did that for you.
the bike scene is definitely one of my favourites. i bike a lot and that feeling of dirt/gravel on your sweaty legs was one i was thinking about. cause in the moment you kind of just have to let it go and tell yourself to stop caring about that sensation. which was fitting. tho i really fucking hate it LMAO
thank you for the lovely message!