Some headcanons for my favourite 80’s mean girls
Despite having two well known jocks in the group, they’re more of a popular group in the bitchy underhanded way than the outright bullying way (They are however on good terms with the football team who are very brute force oriented)
To be honest they don’t really concern themselves with anyone outside the popular group enough to even bully them, their style is keeping the people in their group controlled and divided - hence why Nancy is such a shock (where did Steve even find her?)
Carol moved to Hawkins when she was 11 and joined the group, because of that Tommy and Steve had already developed a complete lack of boundaries and rather than make any she just joined in
This has caused a lot of different rumors and assumptions, when they’re all so touchy and flirty with each other. It’s mostly just for fun though cause Steve is pretty hung up on the nuclear family ideal (probably because of his absent parents). Tommy and Carol would totally go for a triad though.
Carol lives on the same street as Barb and they’ve hated each other since they were kids.
It was one of those situations where their parents decided that because they were girls of the same age they should be friends and tried to force them together. Carol was sort of a tomboyish kid and Barb was super quiet and bookish as a child so they didn’t get along super well.
Carol moved in early summer, so by the time school started they knew each other but weren’t very close. Carol ditched Barb super quick for Tommy and Steve though.
Barb’s always held a bit of a grudge for Carol ditching her, but mostly she hates her because their mother’s are in the same book club and Barb is always being compared to Pretty, Popular, Carol, with her Nice Boyfriend and her B Grade Average.
As such, Steve and Tommy don’t know most of their classmates names
Steve is Bad at essays but pretty good at anything involving maths, Tommy is decent at everything but prefers history and Carol is good at maths and english but hates all sciences
Once when they were younger Tommy chased her with the dissected frog and she didn’t speak to him for a week
Not many people know this but their group is actually three jocks, Carol plays softball and has since she was a kid. There’s just not a lot of attention in Hawkins on women’s sports, especially outside of the cheerleaders
Tommy has older brothers, Carol has a younger brother and Steve is an only child
They only sit with the other popular kids at lunch twice a week because they don’t like them very much
Twice a year Steve stays at Tommy’s house and Carol hosts a big sleepover for the popular girls at Steve’s house because it’s the biggest and most intimidating (It’s a psychological minefield and the gossip she gets out of these fuel them for the whole year)
Live to cause drama, have once caused 5 break-ups, caused 3 friends to hate each other and gotten a player kicked off their team in a school week
Tommy and Carol fake break up semi regularly for entertainment
Their group works because Tommy and Carol’s best friend is both Steve
When Tommy and Carol first started dating (way after people believe) Steve tried to withdraw and give them space but they weren’t having it. Steve is the official third wheel to all of their dates and if he can’t make it they reschedule
People have been making rumour’s about Carol dating one of them or the other since they became friends, they’ve never actually addressed any
Tommy and Carol are not shy about making out in front of Steve, every time he complains they just invite him to join
Carol’s mom works in a beauty salon and is the one that cuts Steve’s hair (she also put him on the hairspray)
Tommy owns a lot of spray paint and likes to climb and tag high places
Once Carol and Steve framed someone by stealing Tommy’s spray paints and spray painting the side of the school and hiding the cans in someone else’s locker
Highly sarcastic as a group (eye-roll count high)
Max’s attitude reminds Steve of Carol when she was younger, but Carol would never be caught dead on a skateboard
Tommy’s parents are the most stable and present, Steve’s are good people but terrible parents. Mostly absent, (they don’t seem to understand that Steve isn’t just a smaller adult for most of his childhood) (i have a lot of headcannons for Steve’s parents but that’s a different post) and Carol’s dad is some military guy whoes rarely around and her mom is lovely but more interested in being Carol’s friend than her parent
Staying at Tommy’s house is the only time Steve and Carol have ever had an enforced curfew - they don’t like it
Tommy’s parents also make Carol sleep separately in the guest room, so they mostly sleep over at Steve’s.
Tommy doesn’t tell them Carol will be there when he sleeps over so whether they think she’s not there (unlikely) or that they’re all in separate rooms since there’s plenty of guest rooms (even more unlikely), is anyone’s guess. They know full well that Steve’s parents aren’t home. Carol’s theory is as long as it’s not their house they don’t see it as their responsibility.
The fight over Nancy is the only big fight they’ve ever had as a group, i don’t think any of them expected it to last but other things came up