I've started a read through of every Marvel comic ever in continued prep for Secret Wars! I'll be posting my one sentence thoughts in these batches, every 30 issues!:
1. The Fantastic Four #1 ("The Fantastic Four") (August, 1961) (7\10) (notable debuts: Mr. Fantastic, Invisible Woman, Human Torch, Thing, Mole Man): A great origin story where everyone's kind of a jerk, which is both great and not great XD
2. The Fantastic Four #2 ("The Fantastic Four Meet The Skrulls from Outer Space!") (September, 1961) (8\10) (notable debuts: The Skrulls): A FAR better issue in every way where the Skrulls, our first alien species (and most definitely the only interesting one for who knows how long), decide to be mindless cows because why the fuck not. Random alien count: 1
3. Tales to Astonish #27 ("The Man in the Ant Hill!") (September, 1961) (6\10) (notable debuts: Hank Pym): Yeah, Ant-Man (in an okay scary science story) was the second major Marvel hero from the 60's onwards, bet you didn't see that coming!
4. The Fantastic Four #3 ("The Menace of the Miracle Man") (December, 1961, no idea why the long break) (8\10) (notable debuts: the fantastic four's costumes, the baxter building and the fantasticar): Another fire issue where our heroes bitch at each other so much that one of them (Johnny) quits, which is kinda hysterical ngl
5. The Fantastic Four #4 ("The Coming of... Sub-Mariner!") (February, 1962) (8\10) (notable debuts: namor (sort of)): Each FF issue is better than the last, especially thanks to everyone's favorite underwater incel, Namor, who sees all his kingdom gone after a bout of amnesia and pivots to genocide instantly, what a guy.
6. The Incredible Hulk #1 ("The Hulk") (March, 1962) (7\10) (notable debuts: Hulk, general ross, betty, rick jones, gargoyle): As flawed as it is great, The Hulk's debut isn't perfect, but the seeds for the ultimate tragic superhero are planted well! Random Boring Communist Count: 1
7. The Fantastic Four #5 ("Prisoners of Doctor Doom!") (April, 1962) (8\10) (notable debuts: Dr. Doom): Not the perfect introduction to Marvel's greatest villain, but Thing becomes a pirate so it's all worth it.
8. The Incredible Hulk #2 ("The Terror of the Toad Men!") (May, 1962) (7\10): Same strengths (tragic, operatic, kinda scary) and same weaknesses (boring aliens, boring side characters, not much actually happens). Random alien count: 2
9. Amazing Fantasy #15 ("Spider-Man!") (June, 1962) (10\10) (notable debuts: Peter Parker, Uncle Ben, Aunt May, Flash Thompson, Liz Allan, the burglar): IT'S THE FUCKING SPIDER-MAN ORIGIN, WHICH IS ONLY TRULY MATCHED BY BATMAN'S, DO I EVEN NEED TO EXPLAIN???
10. Journey Into Mystery #83 ("The Stone Men from Saturn!") (June, 1962) (7\10) (notable debuts: Thor): I love me some god of thunder, but Stan Lee loves random boring aliens more. Random alien count: 3
11. The Fantastic Four #6 ("Captives of the Deadly Duo!") (June, 1962) (8\10): Another strong issue, mostly held up by Namor being such a confusing little fucker and Doom doing his best Doofenshmirtz impression.
12. Tales to Astonish #35 ("Return of the Ant-Man") (June, 1962) (6\10) (notable debuts: The Ant-Man costume): Almost a year after his debut, Hank returns in a sort of fun subversion to his first story's message, sadly thanks to Random Boring Communist villains, which .ame for an okay at best story. Random Boring Communist Count: 2
13. Journey Into Mystery #84 ("The Mighty Thor vs. The Executioner") (July, 1962) (4\10) (notable debuts: Jane Foster): The weakest so far, because Thor, THE THUNDER GOD, SHOULD NOT BE FIGHTING BORING COMMUNISTS (also even for the era, Jane is written TERRIBLY). Random Boring Communist Count: 3
14. The Incredible Hulk #3 ("Banished to Outer Space") (July, 1962) (7\10): A decent issue with a plot device (Rick and Hulk's psychic link) they'll abandon soon because this book is so improvised, also, like, this is totally where the idea for "Planet Hulk" came from, right?
15. The Fantastic Four #7 ("Prisoners of Kurrgo, Master of Planet X") (July, 1962) (7\10): Remember, kids, if you hypnotise superheroes I to being hated by the public, they'll shrink you so you can escape annihilation (that was the lesson, right?) Random Alien Count: 4
16. Strange Tales #101 ("The Human Torch") (July, 1962) (5\10): I love Johnny, but every time he appears in Strange Tales, it's like watching his Hanna-Barbera cartoon that doesn't exist. Random Boring Communist Count: 4
17. Tales to Astonish #36 ("The Challenge of Comrade X!") (July, 1962) (5\10): GUESS WHAT, IT’S ANOTHER FUCKING COMMUNIST, BECAUSE THESE AREN’T GETTING REPETITIVE! Random Boring Communist Count: 5
18. Journey Into Mystery #85 ("Trapped by Loki, The God of Mischief") (August, 1962) (8\10) (notable debuts: Loki, Asgard, the Bifrost, Heimdall, Odin, Balder, Tyr): It’s not the perfect introduction to Thor and Loki's dynamic (as the brothers who once cared for each other aspect is still missing), but it's a fun mythological battle of wits, and Loki isn't a random boring Communist, so I'll take it XD
19. Strange Tales #102 ("Prisoner of the Wizard") (August, 1962) (7\10) (notable debuts: The Wizard): Credit where credit is due, this issue proves the age old adage "Human Torch solo stories are better when he's facing that gay ass Wizard".
20. The Fantastic Four #8 ("Prisoners of the Puppet Master") (gee, they sure do love prisoner titles) (August, 1962) (10\10) (notable debuts: Puppet Master, Alicia Masters): You may be surprised by the rating, but this is about as perfect as an early FF issue gets, from exciting set pieces to a gloriously evil villain, coupled with some excellent melodrama, especially Thing's angst and that final, haunting panel.
21. Tales to Astonish #37 ("Trapped by The Protector!") (August, 1962) (6\10): I know he's small, but it doesn't mean his stories have to be of such little variety.
22. Journey Into Mystery #86 ("On the Trail of the Tomorrow Man") (September, 1962) (7\10) (notable debuts: The Tomorrow Man): I honestly hate how Thor's constantly being used for political and military stories, even in a time travelling plot that was, to be fair, quite fun.
23. The Incredible Hulk #4 ("The Monster and the Machine!" And "Mongu, The Gladiator from Outer Space!") (September, 1962) (7\10 and 4\10): Our first story continues the muddled Hulk decisions, as now he's able to transform back and forth with Gamma Rays and be just as smart as Banner in Hulk form, sure\in our second story, he actually did it, it's a random alien that turns out to be a random boring Communist, HOLY SHIT. Random Alien Count: 5. Random Boring Communist Count: 6.
24. Strange Tales #103 ("Prisoner of the 5th Dimension!") (September, 1962) (6\10): Okay, seriously, half these stories are called Prisoner of insert here, wtf XD. Random Alien Count: 6
25. The Fantastic Four #9 ("The End of the Fantastic Four!") (September, 1962) (9\10): You can tell Stan's best work in this time is reserved for FF and Spidey, who else would have the heroes go bankrupt because of stock investment, then get tricked by Namor to make a movie to get the money back, all in service of an evil scheme (and I say that with the highest affection)?
26. Tales to Astonish #38 ("Betrayed by the Ants!") (September, 1962) (6\10) (notable debuts: Elias Starr\Egghead): Another okay and slightly clever story introducing Ant-Man's arch rival, decent if nothing special.
27. Journey Into Mystery #87 ("Prisoner of the Reds!") (October, 1962) (4\10): You'll never guess what this story was about. Random Boring Communist Count: 7
28. Strange Tales #104 ("The Human Torch Meets Paste-Pot Pete!") (October, 1962) (6\10) (notable debuts: Paste-Pot Pete): It’s Paste-Pot Pete, of course it's peak fiction.
29. The Fantastic Four #10 ("The Return of Doctor Doom!") (October, 1962) (9\10): Of course, Doom was never gonna be gone for long, and thank goodness for that, since this is easily his best appearance so far, as he swaps bodies with Reed and gets even crazier!
30. Tales to Astonish #39 ("The Vengeance of the Scarlet Beetle!") (October, 1962) (7\10) (notable debuts: Scarlet Beetle): We end for now on the first truly good Ant-Man story, where we see him take on the far more fun threat of a beetle turned evil by radiation, and no one even knows he did, which honestly makes him feel quite noble!
Well, that was an interesting start! We got some great heroes introduced, plus a few banger stories! FF's been great, as was Spider-Man's one appearance, but Hulk has been messy, Ant-Man a lil average, and Thor needs a shot in the arm.